Between Composition and Improvisation: Indian Raga, Wed, Sep. 23

Basic Terms

  • Composition: The term is often used in opposition to improvisation, implying an activity carried out prior to performance or a work whose features are specified in sufficient detail to retain its essential identity from one performance to another. (The Oxford Dictionary of Music, 2003)

  • Improvisation: The creation of music in the course of performance. It is tempting to distinguish between composed, or “precomposed,” music (determined in advance) and improvisation (created on the spot), the world of music comprises repertories and performances in which improvisation of different sorts is present in various degrees (The Oxford Dictionary of Music, 2003).

  • Raga: Indian melodic type, first mentioned in the 5th cent. AD. Various raga systems have developed over the centuries. A raga comprises an unchangeable series of notes presented as an ascending and descending scale, with some notes used only in one direction. It is also associated with particular moods, ceremonies, and times of day or year (The Oxford Dictionary of Music, 2003).

Main Ideas

  • Understanding the basics of Indian raga;

    • Western individuality and the idea of the composer vs. the raga performer;

    • Raga modes and the gradual extension of melodies with room for individual expression;

    • The use of microtones and sliding notes (gamakas);

    • The concept of seed ideas: Growth, expansion and spontaneity.

  • Examining the limits of improvisation as a universal term;

    • Hip hop, African American culture, and the importance of improvisation (freestyle).

    • Rappers can deliver rhymes on the spot, while others may use verses from their sketchbooks.

    • Are rappers really freestyling or just combining rhymes from their sketchbook?

    • The rejection of the overused “lyrical,” “miracle,” and “spiritual,” freestyle pattern.

  • Exploring Western popular music genres such as jazz, creating points of comparison with raga;

    • Improvisation in Western music: “In the 18th and early 19th centuries, improvisation was also present in Western classical performance, especially among organists. In jazz, improvisation by solo instrumentalists around a central theme, chord sequence, or other material is central to the idiom” (The Oxford Dictionary of Music, 2003).

    • Links between Western notions of improvisation, jazz and stereotypes about non-Western music;

    • Rethinking the composition–improvisation binary through raga and jazz;

    • The limits of concepts and terminology as historically and culturally situated.

  • Reflecting on the limitations of terminology and how we can make the best use of it.

    • To what extent does the raga melodic framework—and live performance, particularly in jazz—complicate the binary between composition and improvisation?

      • the binary kind of fizzles out in raga - the improv is the composition and vice versa

      • in western jazz, there’s a pathway you have to follow in regards of styaing on key and in intonation, while in raga, there’s less of that