Culture, Devolution, and Technology in Geography
Concepts of Cultural Relativism and Ethnocentrism
- Cultural Relativism:
- Defined as the belief that cultures should be judged based on their own cultural merits rather than by comparing them to other cultures.
- Core Principle: Each culture is unique and should be valued as its own distinct entity.
- It emphasizes that a culture should not be judged against the standards of another.
- Ethnocentrism:
- Defined as the practice of judging another culture based on the standards and values of one's own culture.
- A primary characteristic of ethnocentrism is the belief that one's own culture is superior to others.
- Exam Tip: In a multi-part question, defining these terms typically earns one point each. If a prompt requires an explanation, it must be written in complete sentences and connect back to the provided reasoning or argument.
Cultural Reflection in Landscape Features
- Definition of Cultural Landscape: How the physical landscape is affected and modified by people to reflect their culture.
- Examples of Cultural Landscape Features:
- Agricultural Modifications:
- Terrorist farming (specifically in hilly or mountainous regions): This demonstrates how humans modify the environment to benefit their specific needs, such as providing food.
- Agriculture serves as a primary example of human impact on the mountains or land they inhabit.
- Religious Architecture:
- Religious buildings serve as markers of local belief systems.
- Mosques: Areas that are predominantly Muslim will feature mosques, often with specific orientations (e.g., facing Mecca).
- Churches: Areas predominantly Christian may feature churches, often serving as local communal gathering places.
- Buddhist Shrines: These may reflect individual worship patterns versus the communal worship seen in other faiths.
- Environmental Management: Concepts such as possibilism can be used to explain how humans adapt to and modify their environment despite physical constraints.
Cultural Diffusion and Society
- Cultural Diffusion: Defined as the spreading of culture.
- Effects on Society:
- Assimilation: A process where individuals or groups join a dominant culture and lose their original cultural identity.
- Acculturation/Syncretism: Instances where groups gain new cultural traits from a dominant culture but still retain some of their own original traits, or the blending of cultures.
- Exam Strategy: Use specific vocabulary like "assimilation" or "syncretism" when describing how the diffusion of culture affects society.
Devolution and Political Geography
- Definition of Devolution: The process by which a central state breaks up or transfers power to lower levels of government.
- Forces Leading to Devolution:
- The transcript identifies centripetal forces (note: often contextually referred to as centrifugal forces in geography) as factors leading to state breakup.
- Specific factors include:
- Differing beliefs and social problems.
- Wars and conflict over resources.
- Government instability.
- Genocide and terrorism.
- Economic problems.
- Diversity in population groups with conflicting goals.
Impact of Devolution on State Sovereignty
- State Sovereignty: The power and authority of a state to govern itself.
- Challenges to Sovereignty:
- Devolution challenges sovereignty as the state loses power and stability.
- Internal conflict and fractured popular sovereignty (government lacking the backing of the people) leads to political instability.
- This instability can lead to the state breaking apart into different, smaller states.
- Regional Examples of Devolution:
- Canada: Quebec seeks more independence due to cultural differences, specifically language.
- Spain: Includes groups like the Basque country and Catalonia that seek autonomy.
- The United Kingdom: History of conflict and groups wanting to break away, notably in Northern Ireland.
- Nepal: Experiences instability due to two different groups claiming to be the legitimate government.
Communication Technology and Cultural Patterns
- Degree of Impact: The impact of communication technologies on cultural patterns is categorized as High to Moderate.
- Key Concepts:
- Time-Space Compression (or Time-Space Convergence): The concept that the physical distance between places matters less because communication is instantaneous.
- Globalization and Pop Culture: Technology increases connectivity, allowing similar information and trends to spread rapidly, leading to a dominant global popular culture.
- Language and Lingua Franca:
- Communication technology often leads to the diminishnent of local or ethnic languages.
- Use of a lingua franca (a common language used for communication, such as English) increases through digital platforms.
- Stimulus Diffusion: Technology can facilitate the spread of an underlying idea even if the specific trait is modified.
Questions & Discussion
- Jacob: Asked if cultural relativism is about how much a culture is present.
- Response: No, it is the belief in accepting religions/cultures on their own merits and uniqueness.
- James: Identified ethnocentrism as the opposite of cultural relativism, involving judging others based on your own culture.
- Boston: Suggested Terrorist farming as an example of cultural landscape and noted that devolution causes states to rely on others as they weaken.
- Clarification: Devolution primarily refers to the internal breaking apart of the state and the loss of internal stability/government backing.
- Karen: Observed that devolution causes fractured popular sovereignty because the government no longer has the unified backing of the people.
- Nate: Asked about invasive communication and language.
- Response: The discussion focused on how communication technologies like phones and the Internet impact language patterns and globalization.
- Bronson: Explained that technology removes the "concept of distance" and drives globalization because everyone has access to the same information and trends.