Introduction to International Relations Theory and Realism Foundations of Realism

The Importance of Theory in International Relations

  • The course is designed with a heavy theoretical focus, which may appear daunting to students accustomed to focusing on specific empirical events.
  • Students often question why the study of International Relations (IRIR) involves abstract theories instead of focusing solely on concrete entities or events such as:
    • The UNUN Security Council.
    • The Civil War in Syria.
    • The Strait of Hormuz.
  • Theories are essential tools that allow scholars and practitioners to understand, conceptualize, and manage global events.
  • The lecturer admits to feeling similarly daunted by theory when he was a student in the "1820s1820\text{s}" (humorous anecdote regarding his age).

The Four Primary Functions of Theory

Theories and the ongoing debates between competing theoretical perspectives serve four interconnected and overlapping functions:

  1. Understanding the "Big Picture"

    • Theories help organize how issues relate or do not relate to one another.
    • Example/Metaphor: A theory is like the "box top" of a jigsaw puzzle. While one can dump out pieces and flip them over, the box top provides the overall picture of how the pieces fit together before assembly begins.
    • Different theories prioritize different variables (e.g., one theory may focus on 55 specific factors, while another replaces those with 33 different factors).
  2. Defining Knowledge and Facts

    • Theories help determine what constitutes a "fact" versus a social construct.
    • Mainstream theories like Realism or Liberalism have different understandings of reality compared to Critical Theory or Postmodern Theory.
    • Theories assist in determining which facts are important, which are unimportant, and which are socially constructed.
  3. Connecting IR to Broader Traditions of Knowledge

    • Theories situate IRIR within wider academic fields, such as Political Science, Sociology, and Economics.
    • Theories help clarify the relationship between international relations and domestic politics.
  4. Determining Question Merit

    • Theories help scholars decide which questions are worth investigating and which ones can be safely ignored.

Introduction to Grand and Midrange Theories

  • The course curriculum is divided into two primary sections:
    • Grand Theories: These occupy approximately the first 23\frac{2}{3} of the term and offer broad, overarching frameworks.
    • Midrange Theories: These will be covered later and are more applied and less abstract than grand theories.
  • Realism is identified as the oldest of the grand theories of international relations.

Realism: Influence and Context

  • Realism is a widely held and highly influential theory, despite significant criticism from various academic quarters.
  • Academia vs. Practice: While influential in universities, realism is especially prevalent among practitioners—individuals working in governments, militaries, and global strategic positions.
  • Reactionary Basis: Understanding realism is necessary because many other IRIR theories emerged specifically as reactions to or criticisms of realist thought.

Hans Morgenthau and the Realist Canon

  • Hans Morgenthau (19041904 – 19801980) is considered the most influential realist scholar.
  • Seminal Work: His book, Politics Among Nations, is one of the most famous textbooks in the field. It was written for both academic students and policymakers.
  • Morgenthau synthesized historical realist strands (some dating back hundreds of years) while adding his own contributions, particularly regarding the dilemmas of the "Balance of Power."

Assumption 1: The Science of Politics and Human Nature

  • Realists believe there is a "Science of Politics" governed by objective, knowable laws.
  • Human Nature: The ultimate source of these laws is inherent human nature. This perspective is deeply influenced by the philosopher Thomas Hobbes.
  • The Hobbesian View: Hobbes possessed a pessimistic view of humanity, seeing people as selfish, untrustworthy, and prone to violence.
  • Famous Hobbesian Quote: He described life in the state of nature as "solitary, poor, nasty, brutish, and short."
  • Science vs. Natural Science: Unlike the natural sciences where outcomes are predetermined, realists acknowledge "human agency."
    • Chemistry Metaphor: Sodium (NaNa) and Chlorine (ClCl) atoms have no choice but to form Sodium Chloride (NaClNaCl) (salt).
    • Political Agency: A wise leader who understands realist laws can adjust to circumstances, mitigate problems, and improve their state's odds, even if they cannot completely solve every issue.

Assumption 2: States as Unitary Rational Actors

  • Principal Actors: States are the most important actors on the world stage because they control the "principal instruments of violence" (armies, tanks, artillery, drones, submarines, and ICBMsICBM\text{s}).
  • Other Actors: Realists recognize other entities but view them as secondary to the state:
    • Transnational Corporations (e.g., Coca-Cola, Pepsi, Microsoft, Elon Musk's XX).
    • Non-Governmental Organizations (NGOsNGO\text{s}) (e.g., Amnesty International).
    • Religious Organizations (e.g., The Catholic Church headed by the Pope).
    • International Organizations (e.g., United Nations, World Trade Organization (WTOWTO), IMFIMF, World Bank).
  • National Interest: The primary goal of the state is to pursue the national interest, also known by the French term Raison d’Eˊtat\text{Raison d'État}.
  • Unitary Rational Actor Assumption: Realists treat the state as a "black box." They ignore internal complexities (lobbies, pressure groups, voters, domestic politics) and assume the state makes rational decisions to maximize its interest. The focus is on the final outcome: whether a state signs a treaty, raises a tariff, or goes to war.

Anecdote: The Pepsi Navy (19891989)

  • In 19891989, as communism was collapsing in Eastern Europe, Pepsi acquired a fleet of warships from the Soviet Union.
  • The Soviet Union needed hard currency and sold old, derelict warships to Pepsi for scrap.
  • Pepsi brokered a deal to sell these ships to scrap dealers (possibly in Norway or Sweden) to facilitate their entry into the Soviet market ahead of Coca-Cola.
  • For a brief period of months, Pepsi possessed approximately 2424 warships, effectively owning a navy.

Questions & Discussion

  • Lecturer's Theoretical Preference: When asked by a student which theory he personally "buys into," the lecturer declined to answer. He stated his goal is to "build up" every theory to make it seem perfect, then "crush dreams" by presenting the criticisms, forcing students to decide for themselves.
  • Real-World Examples: In response to Jimmy's question, the lecturer confirmed that real-world examples (like feminist perspectives or the Cuban Missile Crisis) are used frequently, especially as the course shifts toward more applied midrange theories.
  • Importance of Names vs. Dates: Jimmy asked about memorizing names. The lecturer emphasized that names (e.g., Hans Morgenthau) are vital as shorthand for theoretical perspectives, but specific dates are less critical unless explicitly highlighted.
  • The UN vs. States: Salma questioned if the UNUN is more powerful than individual nations. The lecturer used the Russia-Ukraine conflict to illustrate that individual states (especially those with a Security Council veto) often hold more power than the UNUN. States like Canada or the USUS can also impose sanctions independently of the UNUN.

Logistics and Administrative Notes

  • Lecture Spelling Guide: A guide containing difficult names (e.g., Morgenthau) and a brief outline is posted for every lecture.
  • IT and Uploads: Recorded lectures take approximately 11 hour to process due to university ITIT constraints. They are typically available for download by 04:0004:00.