Component 1 Question 3

Key Areas to Compare in Two Documents

1. Perspective – What's each author's main argument or viewpoint? Are they positive, negative, or mixed?

2. Language –

   • Is it formal or informal?

   • Which is more effective or persuasive?

   • How does tone affect credibility?

3. Counterarguments –

   • Are opposing views mentioned?

   • Are they addressed effectively?

4. Sources –

   • Are named sources used?

   • Are they credible and relevant?

5. Argument Balance –

   • Is the reasoning logical and supported?

   • Or is it just opinion-heavy?

6. Examples –

   • Are specific, relevant examples used?

   • Do they clearly support the argument?

7. Statistics –

   • Are there any?

   • Are they recent and directly related?

8. Primary Evidence –

   • Any quotes or first-hand accounts?

   • Do they strengthen the argument?

9. Historical Context –

   • Is it included, and is it needed for understanding?

10. Global Scope –

• Does the author look at international views or just one place?

11. Recency –

• How current is the evidence or data?

• More recent = more relevant.