1984 context pack


Definitions:

Capitalism - economic system in which individuals own and control resources

Collectivisation - the government taking control of all a country’s resources

Communism - the equal distribution of resources, owned by the government

Socialism - equal distribution of resources, owned by individuals & the government

Dictator - a ruler with total power over a country

Fascism - a far-right regime characterised by dictatorial rule and military oppression

Marxism - the aim of creating an equal or ‘classless society’

Revolution - forcible overthrow of a government in favour of a new system

Totalitarian - a government that requires the complete subservience of all its citizens

Karl Marx - German economist who called for a classless society (b.1818, d.1883)

Bolsheviks - A Marxist faction in Russia that led a Revolution in 1917

Vladimir Lenin - Bolshevik leader and a founding member of Soviet Union

Leon Trotsky - A globally-minded member of Lenin’s Bolshevik government

Joseph Stalin - General Secretary, Communist Party of the Soviet Union, 1922-52

Adolf Hitler - Führer of Germany, 1934-45

Molotov-Ribbentrop Pact - 1939-41 treaty between Stalin and Hitler

Winston Churchill - British Prime Minister, 1940-45, 1951-55

Franklin D. Roosevelt - President of the United States, 1933-45

Harry S. Truman - President of the United States, 1945-53

The Allied Forces - Alliance of Stalin, Roosevelt & Churchill against Hitler in 1941





Orwell’s early life

Eric Arthur Blair was born on 25th June in 1903 in Motihari, India. It was not until 1928 that he changed his name to George Orwell. Eric’s parents both participated in the British Empire: his mother, Ida Mabel Blair, had grown up in Burma, while his father, Richard Walmesley Blair, was an agent in the Opium Department of the Indian Civil Service, managing the production of opium to be sold to China. When Eric was still a baby his mother Ida moved him to Oxfordshire, England. Orwell understood the British class system well from an early age, partly because of his paradoxical position within it: he later described his family as “upper-middle-class without money” (The Road to Wigan Pier, 1936).

Blair was a bright child and gained a scholarship to the prestigious Eton College. He later claimed that he was bullied for being a “scholarship boy”--that is, a precocious pupil whose family did not have the money to pay the fees. The other pupils exposed him to the reality of the British class system, and how the mentality of future political rulers was shaped from a young age. Later, in a 1941 book about British life, Orwell had harsh words for his fellow Old Etonians: “One of the dominant facts in English life during the past three quarters of a century has been the decay of ability in the ruling class” (The Lion and the Unicorn, 1941).

After graduating Eton, in 1922 Eric took the surprising decision to join the Burmese Police

Force. In a 2013 BBC podcast ‘The Road to 1984’, Eric’s friends remember being surprised that somebody so critical of authority and the British Empire would decide to become a policeman in a province of British India. In Burma Eric discovered that tyrannical power structures could corrupt and destroy even those who seemed to be in charge. Later, he would recount his experience of being forced by his superiors to shoot an elephant: “It was at this moment, as I stood there with the rifle in my hands, that I first grasped the hollowness, the futility of the white man’s dominion in the East. Here was I, the white man with his gun, standing in front of the unarmed native crowd – seemingly the leading actor of the piece; but in reality I was only an absurd puppet pushed to and fro by the will of those yellow faces behind. I perceived in this moment that when the white man turns tyrant it is his own freedom that he destroys.” (Shooting an Elephant, 1936)

On returning to Britain in 1928 Eric became a journalist and changed his name to George Orwell. He probably took the name ‘Orwell’ from a river in Sussex, where he had attended prep school–though the pseudonym also echoes the name of sci-fi utopian novelist H.G. Wells. As a journalist Orwell was determined to write about the lives of working-class people, as he did in his books Down and Out in Paris and London (1933) and The Road to Wigan Pier (1937). His troubled experiences at Eton and in Burma had led him to greatly value equality and freedom above all else. Writing about the lives of poor people in Wigan, he reflected: “We are living in a world in which nobody is free, in which hardly anybody is secure, in which it is almost impossible to be honest and to remain alive.” (The Road to Wigan Pier, 1937)



George Orwell’s early life

Connections to Nineteen Eighty-Four

Utopian literature

The earliest text that can be called ‘Utopian’ is Plato’s Republic (circa 375 BC), which seeks to describe how justice and daily life would operate in a perfect state. For instance, Plato reflects that in a perfect world people work that suits them: “each person does one thing for which he is naturally suited, does it at the right time, and is released from having to do any of the others”. However, Plato also argues that “poets” would need to be banned from his Republic, since their imaginary works could confuse and corrupt the minds of citizens. Since Plato, utopian writers have had to grapple with the question: who must be excluded, for a perfect society to exist?

In 1516, in England, Thomas More wrote Utopia. As the British Library’s online literary timeline explains, More “coined the word 'utopia' from the Greek ou-topos meaning 'no place' or 'nowhere'. It was a pun - the almost identical Greek word eu-topos means 'a good place'. So at the very heart of the word is a vital question: can a perfect world ever be realised? It is unclear as to whether the book is a serious projection of a better way of life, or a satire that gave More a platform from which to discuss the chaos of European politics.”[1] Since More, the genre of Utopia has remained riddled with ironic humour, as writers have confronted the risk that their fantasies are unachievable or simply ridiculous.

The craze for utopia accelerated in the nineteenth century. Nineteenth-century Britain was a time of rapid technological progress, including the invention of cameras, telephones, aspirin, batteries and automobiles. For this reason, many writers began to speculate about a more perfect future. The most famous utopia from this time is American novelist Edward Bellamy’s Looking Backward (1888), in which a narrator wakes up in the year 2000 to find that American society had achieved peace and prosperity through military rule and the wonders of technology. H.G. Wells immediately wrote his own novel in response, The Sleeper Awakes (1899). In it, Wells imagined a far more sinister future, in which machines control daily life and humans have scarcely any freedom. Since Bellamy and Wells, the genre of utopia had to consider that technological progress could be fearsome as well as beautiful.

In the early twentieth century, Wells’ fears seemed proven correct by totalitarian leaders like Hitler and Stalin, who promised their citizens a utopian future, only to create oppressive regimes. Writers like Jack London, Aldous Huxley and Arthur Koestler imagined threatening totalitarian futures in novels like The Iron Heel (London, 1908), Brave New World (Huxley, 1932), and Darkness at Noon (Koestler, 1940). Also important for understanding 1984 is the work of New York intellectual James Burnham, who argued that the takeover of the United States by huge corporations would lead to an obsession with rules and productivity, leaving no room for personal freedom (The Managerial Revolution, 1941). As Utopian worlds slipped into Dystopian visions, writers like Orwell were also heavily influenced by Yevgeny Zamyatin’s consideration of Soviet oppression in his 1921 novel, We.



The Spanish Civil War

The Spanish Civil War (Guerra Civil Española) was a conflict in Spain fought from 1936 to 1939. In simple terms, the war was between the Republicans - socialists who sought to abolish the monarchy - and the Nationalists, led by General Francisco Franco, a violent dictator. In reality, however, the picture was more complex, involving several factions within each of these broad coalitions. In both Britain and the United States, Franco and his Nationalist alliance were seen as oppressive, which generated international support for The Republicans among left-leaning journalists.

Orwell was one such journalist, and he travelled to Catalonia, an autonomous region of Spain, to fight for the Republican socialist cause in 1936. Specifically, he joined the POUM faction of the Republicans, also known as the ‘Workers’ Party of Marxist Unification.’ On arriving in Catalonia, Orwell admired the socialist ideals on display, and wrote that people had a great deal more freedom in socialist Catalonia than they did in capitalist Britain: “Above all, there was a belief in the revolution and the future, a feeling of having suddenly emerged into an era of equality and freedom. Human beings were trying to behave as human beings and not as cogs in the capitalist machine.” (Homage to Catalonia, 1938)

However, Orwell’s experience of the Spanish Civil War soon turned sour. The many factions of the Republican party turned against each other, revealing a totalitarian, Stalinist presence that sought to eradicate other groups. Stalinist Republicans accused the POUM Republicans of being secret agents for General Franco and his Nationalists. Almost overnight, Orwell saw people he had considered “comrades” turn against him and the POUM. Around this time, Orwell was shot through the throat by a sniper, and believed that he was bleeding to death. Had the bullet been a millimetre toward his windpipe, he would have been correct.

The Spanish Civil War led Orwell to draw a distinction between democratic socialism, which he admired, and totalitarianism, which he detested. In the essay ‘Why I Write’ (1946) he explains: “The Spanish war and other events in 1936-37 turned the scale and thereafter I knew where I stood. Every line of serious work that I have written since 1936 has been written, directly or indirectly, against totalitarianism and for democratic socialism, as I understand it. It seems to me nonsense, in a period like our own, to think that one can avoid writing of such subjects.”

The Republicans failed in their cause, and no socialist revolution took place. General Franco ruled over Spain until 1975.



Stalinism

Joseph Stalin was the totalitarian dictator of the Soviet Union from 1924-53. The Soviet Union under his rule is sometimes referred as Stalinist Russia. Stalinism is the name used to describe key characteristics of Stalin’s regime.

In 1917, a Revolutionary Marxist group called the Bolsheviks took control of Russia, overthrowing centuries of rule by Tsars (Emperors). This overhaul was known as the 1917 Russian Revolution. The Bolsheviks promised a classless society of democratic socialism. Vladimir Lenin emerged as their leader in the newly founded Soviet Union, along with Leon Trotsky, his commissar of Military and Naval Affairs. When Lenin died in 1922, Stalin won a leadership battle and became General Secretary of the Communist Party in 1924.

Stalin sought to ‘collectivise’ Russia, bringing all farms and factories under government control. To do this he implemented ‘five-year-plans’, the first of which began in 1928. By the end of the second Five-year-plan, it was clear that collectivisation was not working as intended. For instance, between 1932-33 a ‘Holodomor’ (famine) took place in Ukraine due to lack of food. As criticism mounted against Stalin in the late 1930s, he ramped up his propaganda, creating fictional heroic workers to support his exaggerations about how much food, steel and energy were being produced. He even claimed that five-year-aims could be achieved in four years, insisting that “2 +2 = 5”. He began to purge (exterminate) experts who questioned his claims, as well as over half-a-million citizens he believed were traitors, including many high-profile Jews. Stalin also used ‘show trials’ to force people to publicly confess to crimes they had not committed. In the media, he scapegoated Trotsky as an enemy of the people, and used a newspaper titled Pravda, meaning ‘Truth,’ to dictate what people were allowed to think and say.

For Orwell, Stalinism encapsulated the problem that democratic socialism, which he had admired in Catalonia during the Spanish Civil War, could slip into violent totalitarianism. In his novel Animal Farm (1945) he uses animals to create an allegory for the Russian Revolution (1917). As the animals (Bolsheviks) overthrow the human farmers (the old Tsarist regime) and revolutionise the farm (Russia), the pigs (Stalinists) become so corrupt that, toward the end of the novel, “the creatures outside looked from pig to man, and from man to pig, and from pig to man again; but already it was impossible to say which was which.” In a 1946 letter to his friend Dwight Macdonald, Orwell explained that his novel was pro-socialist, but anti-Stalinist: “I meant the moral to be that revolutions only effect a radical improvement when the masses are alert and know how to chuck out their leaders as soon as the latter have done their job.”

Stalin’s violence and propaganda techniques are clearly echoed in 1984. Orwell was also alarmed at how easily the BBC could flip between attacking Stalin when he established the Molotov-Ribbentrop Pact with Hitler in 1939, and then gratefully praising Stalin when he broke the pact and joined The Allied Forces in 1941. Orwell was also frustrated with British socialist writers who refused to acknowledge Stalin’s corruption of the socialist cause.


Nazi Germany

After its crushing defeat in World War One, Germany was left poor, powerless, and desperate. Adolf Hitler and his Nazi (National Socialist) party exploited this situation by promising German citizens great wealth, prosperity, and even a ‘Third Reich’ of German dominance, if they could be elected on their platform of Aryanism, anti-semitism, and nationalism. (Hitler imagined that the First Reich was the Holy Roman Empire of 800-1806, followed by the Second Reich of the German Empire in 1871-1918.) Hitler developed a cult of personality, not least by establishing the Hitler Youth organisation for children in 1922. As he wrote in his 1925 memoir Mein Kampf (‘My struggle’): “He alone who owns the youth controls the future.”

From the start of 1933, events in Germany moved with violence and pace.[2] On 30th January Hitler was elected Chancellor of Germany. On 27th February the Reichstag - Germany’s parliamentary building - was burned down by Nazis, signalling Hitler’s fascist disdain for democracy and desire for unqualified power. On 24th March Hitler passed the Enabling Act, giving him totalitarian power over Germany, not held by any previous political leader. The Nazis took control of education, first banning Jews from teaching in schools or universities (7th April) and then publicly burning thousands of books written Jews or containing dissenting ideas (10th May).

Between 1934-1938 the onslaught against Jewish people was accelerated, and on 13th March 1938 the Nazis march into Austria, making evident their ambition to control all of Europe. In Germany the persecution of Jews continued, perhaps most appallingly on ‘Kristallnacht’ or ‘the night of broken glass’ (9th-10th November), during which over one-hundred Jews were murdered. After Hitler invaded Poland on 1st September 1939, Britain, France, India, Australia and New Zealand declared war on Germany.

In 1940 George Orwell wrote a review of Mein Kampf. The review foreshadows aspects of 1984: “Suppose that Hitler’s programme could be put into effect. What he envisages, a hundred years hence, is a continuous state of 250 million Germans with plenty of ‘living room’ (i.e. stretching to Afghanistan or thereabouts), a horrible brainless empire in which, essentially, nothing ever happens except the training of young men for war and the endless breeding of fresh cannon-fodder.”

The philosopher Hannah Arendt survived the Holocaust (1941-45), in which around six-million Jews,as well as members of other groups deemed undesirable by the Nazis. In 1951 Arendt wrote a book, The Origins of Totalitarianism. In it she describes the fragility of truth in totalitarian regimes: “The ideal subject of totalitarian rule is not the convinced Nazi or the convinced Communist, but people for whom the distinction between fact and fiction (i.e., the reality of experience) and the distinction between true and false (i.e., the standards of thought) no longer exist.”


Second World War and its aftermath

The singular term ‘Second World War’ is misleading, as there were actually multiple global conflicts during the 1930s and 1940s. A basic way of remembering the war’s scope is that it had two endings: VE Day and VJ Day. Here what that means:

The conflict in Europe began in earnest when Adolf Hitler’s forces marched into Poland in 1939, signalling his desire to take over the whole continent. This European war ended when Stalin’s Red Army seized Berlin, allowing Britain’s Prime Minister Winston Churchill to declare ‘Victory in Europe Day’, VE Day, on 8th May 1945.

Meanwhile, in Asia, the Second Sino-Japanese war began in 1937, partly caused by Japan’s desire to expand their Empire into China. In December 1941 Japan bombed Pearl Harbour in Hawaii, United States. Until that point, the US had provided weapons and strategic recommendations to Britain, China, and the Soviet Union. After Pearl Harbour the US more directly joined the fighting, culminating in President Harry S. Truman’s decision to drop atomic bombs on Hiroshima and Nagasaki on 6th and 9th August 1945. This forced Japan to surrender to the Allies on 15th August, which the Allies called ‘Victory in Japan Day’, VJ Day.

During the war, the ‘Allied Forces’ - the United States, Britain, the Soviet Union - were opposed to the ‘Axis Powers’: Nazi Germany, the Kingdom of Italy, and Japan. Stalin’s Soviet Union came out of World War 2 very strongly, which President Truman of the United States recognised was a problem. While the United States was ideologically committed to capitalism, Stalin’s Soviet Union embraced totalitarian communism. This opposition, along with Japan’s desire in World War Two to meld Japan and China into one vast Asiatic Empire, raised the spectre of an ongoing ‘Cold War,’ a term George Orwell coined in 1947 to describe a deadlock whereby the United States, the Soviet Union and an East Asian alliance would each possess atomic nuclear weapons, and none would dare use them. In his essay ‘Toward European Unity’ in the Partisan Review’ (Summer 1947) Orwell predicts:

“That the fear inspired by the atomic bomb and other weapons yet to come will be so great that everyone will refrain from using them. This seems to me the worst possibility of all. It would mean the division of the world among two or three vast super-states, unable to conquer one another and unable to be overthrown by any internal rebellion… Within each state the necessary psychological atmosphere would be kept up by complete severance from the outer world, and by a continuous phony war against rival states. Civilizations of this type might remain static for thousands of years.”

Question: What did Orwell mean by ‘Cold War’? What did he find disturbing about it?

Question: How would you have felt upon seeing Levy’s photograph in 1945 (p.14)?