Contract L15
Termination: Under Influence
Barclays Bank v O’Brien 1993
Type 1: actual undue influence
Type 2A: presumed undue influence: the “double presumption”
Type 2B: presumed undue influence: the “single presumption”
O’Brien Type 1: actual undue influence
BCCi v Aboody 1992- requires:
“That the other party to the transaction … had the capacity to influence the complaint;
That’s the influence was exercised
That its exercise was undue;
That its exercise brought about the transduction
O’Brien type 2A (“the double presumption”):
Influence existed + the influence was exercised = undue influence
A relationship of a defined type (e..g parent and child, guardian adn ward, trustee and beneficiary, solicitor and client, medical advisor and patient)
→ Influence existed + the influence was exercised = undue influence
Goldsworthy v Brickell 1987
“Doctors and solutions are trusted and confined in by their patients and clients to hive them conscientious and disninterested advice on matters which profoundly affect, in one case their physical and mental and, in other their material wellbeing. It is natural to presume that out of trust and confidence grows influence…. A banker, being a person having a pre-existing and conflicting interest in any loan transaction with a customer, cannot ordinarily be trusted and confided in so as to come under a duty to take care of the customer and give him disinterested advice.”
(Image)
Bourse LJs examples: doctors and lawyers
Allcard v Skinner 1887
“But if the gift is so large as not to be reaosnbly accounted for on the grounds of friendship, relationship, charit or other ordinary motives on which ordinary men act, the burden is on the done to support the gift.
Images)
Damages
The restitution interest
Unjust enrichment:
Concerned with unfair profits, rather than losses
Separate cause of action
Duress and undue influence
Cutter v Powell 1795- “quantum merit”
Wrotham Park Estate v Parkside Homes 1974
Attorney General v Blake 2000