Progressiveism

Introduction

  • Discussion on final projects at USM by a top artist.

  • Construction on the North Side of McCain Library blocking usual entrance:
      - Need to enter from the South Side.   - Phone number available for assistance if unable to use stairs.

  • Meeting in Room 305 to talk about projects and review boxes.

  • Announcement about the meeting posted on Canvas.

  • Information and instructions will also be posted on Canvas for those unable to attend.

Historical Context: The Triangle Shirtwaist Factory Fire

  • Date & Event: March 25, 1911, fire at Triangle Shirtwaist Company in NYC.
      - 500 workers (mostly young single Jewish and Italian women) in the factory.
      - Earnings as low as $3 per week.

  • Locked doors meant to prevent theft and maximize production led to tragedy:
      - Workers trapped inside; instead, many jumped to their deaths.

  • Fire department reached only 6th floor, exacerbating the situation.

  • Casualties: 46 dead on the street and over 100 found inside.

  • Public response: 100,000 marched to the site; funeral procession of 300,000 attendees.

  • Changes following the fire: New regulations and fire safety laws enacted by New York state legislature.

Emergence of Progressivism

  • Definition: A broad movement aimed at reforming social and political life in America (1900-1917), known as the Progressive Era.

  • Distinction: Early 20th century Progressives differ from modern progressives (capital P).   - Primarily urban, middle class, moderate reformers (not radicals).

  • Key elements:
      - Labor activists aiming to empower industrial workers.
      - Female reformers focusing on protection of women & children.
      - Social scientists utilizing research to address economic issues.

Characteristics of Progressivism

  • Urban-based movement reacting to challenges from the Gilded Age:
      - Industrial revolution, immigration, urbanization, and social displacement.

  • Population statistics:
      - U.S. population tripled between 1860 and 1920; urban population increased nine times.
      - 2/3 of 25 million immigrants settled in cities, e.g., New York, Cleveland, and Pittsburgh.

  • Major shift in lifestyle: By 1920, majority of Americans lived in cities.
      - Example: Chicago in 1900 had 80% of its population as immigrants or children of immigrants.

  • Issues faced in urban areas included overcrowding, poverty, disease, and pollution, driving demand for reform.

Goals of Progressives

  • Desire for order, fairness, and renewal in society, combating corruption and greed prevalent in the Gilded Age.

  • Economic Goals:
      - Curb corporate power and introduce efficiency in economic life.

  • Political Goals:
      - Restrain political corruption and promote fair governance.
      - Improve transparency and effectiveness of local/state governments.

  • Social Goals:
      - Advance social morality, justice, and individual character.

Methods and Innovations of Progressives

  • Trust-busting: Breaking up monopolies to ensure fair competition.

  • Electoral reforms:
      - Direct primaries allowing party members to select candidates.
      - Initiatives empowering voters to pass laws directly.
      - Referenda and recalls for public officials.

  • Introduction of secret ballots to reduce pressure from parties.

  • Promotion of popular elections for judges and implementation of a graduated income tax (16th Amendment).

  • Shift in authority with the belief that a stronger federal government was necessary to manage corporate power.

Muckrakers and Social Reformers

  • Muckrakers: Investigative journalists exposing societal issues.
      - Example: Jacob Riis ("How the Other Half Lives"), Ida B. Wells Barnett (lynching culture scrutiny), Lincoln Steffens ("The Shame of the Cities"), Ida Tarbell (expose on John D. Rockefeller).

  • Literary contributions:
      - Upton Sinclair's "The Jungle" raising public awareness on unsanitary meat production, influencing Congress to pass food safety regulations.

Labor Issues and Child Exploitation

  • Focus on child labor, often viewed through the lens of white supremacy.
      - Victims sympathetic due to their vulnerability and exploitation in the workplace.

  • Lewis Hine's photography depicted the harsh realities of child labor.

  • Labor conflicts continued to manifest during the Progressive Era, paralleling the fight for rights among marginalized workers, including strikes that highlighted racial solidarity.

Labor Movement Dynamics

  • Distinction between Knights of Labor and American Federation of Labor (AFL):
      - Knights were more inclusive; AFL focused on skilled workers.

  • AFL grew significantly; collective bargaining rights were established.

  • Emergence of IWW (Industrial Workers of the World) advocating for a revolutionary approach among workers.

Socialist Movement in America

  • Eugene Debs and the Socialist Party emerged, advocating for social reforms.
      - 1912 presidential campaign garnered nearly a million votes reflecting readiness for radical change.
      - Decline of socialism due to alignment with moderate reformers and evolving public perception during WWI.

Progressive Presidents

  • Significant shifts in the role of the federal government under three progressive presidents; Roosevelt, Taft, and Wilson.

  • Roosevelt: Square Deal focused on corporations, consumer protection, and conservation.
      - Example: Trust-busting (Northern Securities case) showcased differentiating between good and bad corporations.

Taft’s Administration and Legislation

  • Continued aggressive trust-busting efforts; landmark Supreme Court case against Standard Oil led to disbandment into multiple companies.
      - Implemented the graduated income tax; tensions between progressive ideals and Taft's actions strained his relationship with Roosevelt.

Wilson's New Freedom

  • Wilson's reforms aimed at reducing corporate power while increasing competition, with landmark legislation supporting economic reform:   - Clayton Act (1914): Protect unions from antitrust laws.
      - Economic interventions including Federal Reserve Act establishing federal oversight of banking.

Women's Suffrage Movement

  • Advocacy for the right to vote as part of the progressive movement, framed around women's moral authority to improve society.

  • Key figures: Julia Lathrop (Children’s Bureau), Florence Kelley (National Consumers League), demonstrating success in legislative reforms.

  • Social housekeeping ideology promoted involvement of women in public spheres to achieve societal change.   

Campaign for the 19th Amendment

  • Shift in tactics towards mass mobilization, leveraging modern advertising and strategic advocacy.

  • Growing militancy and the influence of World War I experiences pushed towards finally achieving suffrage with the 19th Amendment in 1920.

Legacy of Progressivism

  • Acknowledgment of dark elements of progressivism, including eugenics and racial bias resulting in exclusionary practices.

  • Progressives contributed significantly to the alteration of the federal government's role and the expansion of governmental powers to address social issues.

  • Movement also revealed a tendency to prioritize certain grievances over others, particularly concerning racial and immigration issues, indicating an incomplete progressive vision.   

Conclusion

  • Progressive Era represented extensive reforms but also highlighted societal inconsistencies in approach towards fundamental rights for all citizens, laying groundwork for subsequent reform movements in American history.