presocial psychology notes (day 1)

Study Session Structure

  • Option to conduct studies during class or outside class time depending on what makes more sense for students.

  • No class time will be allocated for study-related activities.

  • Topics to be covered leading up to the next week include aggressive behavior.

Class Format

  • Today's format will be traditional lecture.

  • Future classes will incorporate unique participation points related to submitted studies.

Bystander Effect Case Study: Kitty Genovese

  • Introduction to the infamous case of Kitty Genovese, highlighting inaccuracies in the narrative.

  • Kitty Genovese was attacked and killed in a New York neighborhood with potential witnesses who did not respond.

  • The New York Times reported:

    • "For more than half an hour, 38 respectable, law-abiding citizens in Queens watched the killer stalk and stab a woman in three separate attacks in two days."

    • Multiple witnesses indicated a concerning absence of response during the assault.

  • The incident became a catalyst for research into pro-social behavior and the bystander effect.

Pro-Social Behavior Research

  • The research stemming from this case focuses on the concept that the likelihood of intervention decreases with the number of witnesses present, known as the bystander effect.

  • Criticism of the Genovese narrative highlights inaccuracies regarding the timeline and responses of witnesses, leading to revised understandings in recent years.

  • The idea that everyday events can stimulate significant research in the social behavior domain is emphasized.

Heroic Acts of Pro-Social Behavior

  • Contradicting narratives of non-intervention is the example of a worker named Wesley who saved a man during a seizure on a subway track.

  • Wesley intervened despite the severe risks, showcasing extreme pro-social behavior.

  • The distinction between situations lacking intervention and cases of extraordinary help are noted.

The Five-Step Decision-Making Process in Emergencies

  1. Notice the Event

    • Crucial first step; if an individual fails to notice a situation, they will not intervene.

    • Factors: distractions and cognitive overload can hinder awareness, particularly during busy or rushed scenarios.

  2. Interpret the Event as an Emergency

    • Recognizing the gravity of the situation. If not perceived as an emergency, intervention is unlikely.

    • Example studies demonstrate how the presence and behavior of others can impact interpretations, notably through confederate behavior during emergencies such as smoke-filled rooms.

  3. Assume Personal Responsibility

    • Individuals must feel a personal obligation to intervene.

    • Research illustrates that reminders of personal responsibility elevate intervention rates significantly (e.g., asking a person to watch belongings increased support rates dramatically).

  4. Know How to Assist

    • Awareness of necessary actions for assistance is essential; lack of knowledge results in failure to intervene despite the will to help.

    • Many potential helpers hesitate if they are uncertain of the right action to take.

  5. Engage in Helping Act

    • The final step is executing the help. Various factors can influence whether and how someone helps, including emotional readiness and perceived competence.

Research Findings and Theoretical Models

  • Cognitive Load can distract individuals from noticing emergencies.

  • Past research includes the Good Samaritan Study that highlights the influence of time pressure on helping behavior.

  • Factors such as informational social influence and pluralistic ignorance illustrate how individuals gauge their reactions based on others' responses in ambiguous situations.

Important Definitions

  • Pluralistic Ignorance: The assumption that others are more informed or competent in a situation, leading to collective inaction among bystanders.

  • Diffusion of Responsibility: As the number of witnesses increases, individuals feel less personal accountability to help, believing others will take action instead.

Comparing Urban and Rural Support

  • A lost letter study shows higher pro-social behavior in rural settings, indicating differences in community dynamics and social norms.

  • The perceived anonymity in urban environments plays a substantial role in diminishing the likelihood of intervention.

Variables Influencing Helping Behavior

  • Mood and Emotional State: Positive emotions correlate with increased helping when the help does not threaten to disrupt their mood.

  • Gender Roles: Situational influences determine when men or women are likely to help; emotional connections often dictate preferences.

  • Attractiveness and Similarity: Individuals that are perceived as more attractive or those who share certain traits with a potential helper may prompt action.

  • Demographics: Research points to disparities in helping rates among different racial and socioeconomic groups, revealing complex underlying biases.