Week 4 : Race and Racism in Global Politics

Overview of Race and Racism in International Politics

###Introduction to Theorizing Race and Racism

  • This section dives into how race and racism have been understood in the context of international politics, drawing on significant thinkers and historical texts.

  • Key thinker Stuart Hall (1932-2014) is introduced as a central figure in understanding race theories and their implications.

  • The week’s reading centers on Barbara Fields’ article titled ‘Slavery, Race and Ideology in the United States of America’ from the New Left Review.

  • Discusses the relationship between race and international contexts, including anti-imperialism and civil rights movements, emphasizing that the idea of nation-states and capitalism is deeply intertwined with racial logics.

Part One: Theorizing Race

Racism as a Philosophy

  • Racism suggests an innate connection between physical appearance (such as skin color) and behavior or thought processes, incorrectly positing biological determinism over social context.

  • Despite being discredited intellectually, these notions continue to negatively impact society and influence international politics.

  • Reflection on the concept of race as constructed or imagined, comparable to nationalism.

Stuart Hall and the Concept of Race

Biography and Contributions

  • Stuart Hall was a Jamaican-born cultural theorist known for his work on race, class, empire, and culture.

  • Hall describes race as a “principal of classification” used to elevate or diminish social standing based on perceived biological trait differences.

The Floating Signifier

  • Hall's idea of race as a 'floating signifier' demonstrates that race functions within the classification systems of society, where its meaning is ever-changing rather than fixed.

  • He posits that race cannot be scientifically grounded in biological differences and suggests a shift toward a socio-historical understanding of race.

  • Race, akin to a language, gains meaning through its relation to other concepts within cultural systems.

Hall's Claims and Racialization Processes

Racialization and Context

  • Hall suggests that blackness can carry different racial connotations based on context, demonstrating that racism is systemic and not merely individual opinions.

  • It’s posited that claims of 'anti-white racism' are misleading within the broader context of structural racism in society.

Policing the Crisis

The 1970s and Authoritarian Policing

  • Hall's Policing the Crisis highlights a turning point in policing where black communities faced more authoritarian methods, reliant on public consent and influenced by media narratives creating moral panic.

  • The racialization of crime metrics, particularly through the figure of the 'mugger', showcased societal anxieties surrounding race and urban crime.

Racial Language in International Context

The Role of Media in Framing Violence

  • The discussion transcends to how violent acts, particularly in the West, are framed using specific language when associated with different racial groups, especially Palestinians.

  • This analysis leads to reflections on Hall's floating signifier theory and ties to Edward Said’s Orientalism, underlining contemporary racial language use.

Part Two: Race as Ideology

Barbara Fields' Analysis

  • Fields’ approach situates race as a mutable ideology influenced by historical and economic circumstances.

  • She asserts that ideology persists through ritualistic social behaviors, requiring adaptation to changes in social terrain.

The Relationship Between Race and Slavery

  • Fields critiques the common perception of slavery, arguing against the notion that it solely served a racial hierarchy and positing that the economic motivations were also pivotal.

  • The reconciliation of slavery with liberty in America hinged upon the racial categorization of Afro-Americans.

The Invention of the White Race

Historical Context

  • Pre-17th century, the concept of a 'white race' was non-existent, indicating a significant ideological shift that shaped modern racial dynamics and social hierarchies.

International Context of Race and Politics

W.E.B. Du Bois' Contributions

  • Du Bois connected racism to imperialism, noting that modern imperialism maintained a duality of democratic ideals at home while exerting authoritarian control in colonies.

  • Race and racism are depicted as critical frameworks that inform the operation of global political structures.

Concept of Double Consciousness

  • Du Bois’ notion of double consciousness illustrates the conflict faced by Afro-Americans in achieving self-identity within a prejudiced framework.

Anti-Semitism Connections

Broader Implications of Race

  • Race discourse transcends mere physical attributes, reflecting deep-seated societal and cultural issues that pervade multiple communities.

Internationalism and Civil Rights Movements

Cross-linking Anti-Racism and Anti-Imperialism

  • Activists of the Civil Rights Movement and the Black Power Movement intertwined their struggles against racism with a critique of imperialism, resonating with contemporary global politics.

  • A notable figure, Muhammad Ali, articulated a powerful criticism of U.S. military engagement abroad, highlighting domestic injustices faced by African Americans.

Black Panther Party and Anti-Colonial Theories

Internal Colonialism

  • The Black Panther Party framed police brutality as a form of colonial oppression, embodying the theories of critical thinkers such as Frantz Fanon.

Concluding Perspectives on Race

Evolving Understandings of Race

  • Many theorists argue for conceiving race as a consequence of racism rather than the origin, indicating that race concepts evolve with societal transformations.

  • The interplay between economics, class, and forms of racism prompts scholarly debate, especially regarding the gratuitous violence stemming from white supremacy.

Seminar Readings

  • Focus on race and racism as foundational elements in international political structures, as outlined by Anevias, Shilliam, Manchanda, and Barbara Fields' critical examination of race as ideology.