Crime and the Media: Comprehensive Notes
Moral Panics
- Definition: Moral panic is a widespread fear that an evil person, group, or entity threatens a community or society.
- Folk Devils: A sociological term for individuals or groups that are stereotyped and demonized by the media and society as a threat to social values and norms, often becoming a scapegoat for societal problems.
- Relationship to Social Control: Moral panics are linked to mechanisms that enforce conformity to norms, values, and laws, contributing to social order and stability.
- Media Framing: Media framing shapes public understanding, perception, and opinion by selecting and emphasizing certain aspects of crime and the criminal justice system.
- Social Construction of Reality: Humans construct their own understanding of reality through interactions and communication, influencing interpretation of events and social behavior.
- Narratives: Theoretical paradigm that stories influence harmful actions and social arrangements.
- Media categories:
- News Media
- Entertainment Media
- Infotainment
- Media have a symbolic relationship with corporations and politicians: framing and representation are tied to broader power structures.
- Media Framing: Reiterated here as a key mechanism by which information about crime is packaged for audiences.
- Social Problems: Media contributes to the construction and highlighting of social problems through framing and storytelling.
The Problem Frame
- Narrative Structure: How a story about crime is built (setup, conflict, resolution).
- Morality Play: Stories are framed with clear moral judgments about right and wrong.
- Specific Time & Place: Problems are situated in particular contexts.
- Problem Frame implies:
- Something is Undesirable
- Parts are easily identified
- Can be changed or fixed: The frame suggests solutions and fixes.
- Repair Agent—Government: The government is often portrayed as the primary agent able to repair the problem.
- Real policy consequences: Framing can lead to actual policy changes and practical outcomes.
- Example: Missing children as a case study referring to a problem frame that mobilizes policy responses.
Claims Making and the Cycle of Issues
- Claims Making/Claims Makers: People and groups who articulate and push for public attention to an issue.
- Cyclical process (7 steps):
- A Problem is identified
- The Mass Audience is engaged
- Competing with other problems occurs
- A New Angle or Problem emerges
- The problem is broadcast to the public
- Information about the topic is provided to the audience
- The cycle repeats as the issue evolves
- Exemplar: Missing children often cited as an example that kicks off the cycle.
Page 3: Core Concepts in Media and Criminology
- Media Criminology: A sub-discipline of criminology studying the intersection of media and crime, focusing on how media representations influence public perception, behavior, and policy.
- Hard News: Journalism covering serious, timely, and important events (e.g., politics, international affairs) with broad impact and based on factual reporting and rigorous investigation.
- Infotainment: Broadcast material intended to entertain as well as inform.
- Reflexivity: Critical examination of one's own beliefs, assumptions, biases, and how these influence actions, thoughts, and research.
- Mediascape: All institutionalized forms of media used to communicate; the global flows of information and images that connect people and shape understanding and virtual spaces.
Page 4: Mediation, Literacy, and Theories of Crime Media
- Mediated: A process where a neutral third party helps disputing parties resolve conflicts outside of court (often involving victims and offenders).
- Media literacy: The ability to critically analyze mass media stories and determine their accuracy or credibility.
- Deviance: Departing from established social or sexual norms.
- Media effects: The ways mass media can influence thoughts, beliefs, attitudes, emotions, and behaviors at individual and societal levels.
- Moral Panics: Reiterated definition and role in labeling certain individuals or groups as threats to societal values.
- Risk Society: A society preoccupied with future safety, where risks are socially constructed and induced by modernization.
- Public Interest: The welfare or general good of the public as opposed to private or sectional interests.
- Crime Waves: A sudden rise in the number of crimes in a country or area.
- Hypodermic Syringe Model: Claims media is solely responsible for negative direct effects, with audiences as passive recipients of media messages.
- Uses and Gratification Thesis: People are active media users who choose media to satisfy specific needs, rather than passive recipients.
- Audience reception analysis: Studies how audiences interpret and understand media messages.
- Framing Devices: Techniques that surround a main story with an outer context to provide structure, context, and meaning.
Page 5: Debates on Media Influence and Representation
- Ongoing Debate about Media influence: Unresolved questions about how powerful media effects are.
- Media does not represent reality but a version of reality: Media presents a constructed version, not a direct replica of the world.
- Exposure to the mediatization of crime and criminality has been linked to changes in individual behavior, often negative in tone.
- Potential for mediated representations of crime and violence to cause imitative acts: The possibility that media portrayals can inspire similar real-world actions.
- Crimes against property are among the most common crimes, but they are often underrepresented or not depicted in media.
- Media effects tradition tends to overstate the power of media while underestimating audience agency; overlooks production-consumption convergence in the contemporary mediascape.