Moving from Individual Developmental Counseling Theories to Advanced Multicultural & Social Justice
Theory & Integration
a theory can guide you, much as a roadmap or a navigational instrument
a set of directions tells you where are you starting out, where you hope to end, and the steps along the way
even with a plan, you will need to be flexible in modifying the way you try to reach your goals
developing an integrative approach is a process that will likely take years and will evolve as you gain experience and fine-tune your own clinical style
consider your own personality, interpersonal strengths, life experiences, and worldview as you choose the concepts and techniques that work best with a range of clients
Individual Theories & Limitations
definition
related set of ideas that explain or make predictions
individual theories in counseling are exclusionary
recently theories are being interrogated
race & deviance are intertwined when referencing clients of color
cultural application in groups
individual theories are commonly applied to groups
these theories are based on dominant cultures
group related theories & culturally responsive theories are needed
limitations
focus individual work and theoretical frames into a group perspective
gaps & research evidence to substantiate outcomes
practice isn’t fully accepted as science yet
Group Developmental Theories
Tuckman
very popular schematic to identify and apply group development
terms are active
terms may influence development
leaders experience drives group outcome
intersectionality
created to understand experiences of Black women
racism & oppression are at the core
used as a research paradigm
goal ensures inclusivity and social justice movements
critical race theory
centers voices of racially marginalized individuals
flexible framework underscoring White privilege
theories used to highlight perspective of the silenced
emerging framework for mixed methods research
relational cultural theory
all people want to connect with others
individuals within a group are seen as part of the system
connection, relationships, and interactions of members is key
individuals grow in concert with others inside and outside of group
Relationship of Theories to Techniques
psychodynamic approaches stress insight in therapy (psychoanalytic and Adlerian therapy)
experiential and relationship-oriented approaches stress feelings & subjective experiencing (existential, person-centered, Gestalt therapy, and psychodrama)
cognitive behavioral approaches stress the role of thinking and doing and tend to be action-oriented (behavior therapy, cognitive therapy, rational emotive behavior therapy, and reality therapy)
postmodern approaches stress understanding the subjective world of the client and tap existing resources for change within the individual (solution-focused brief therapy, narrative therapy, motivational interviewing, and feminist therapy)
Psychoanalytic Groups
emphasizes insight, unconscious motivation, and reconstruction of the personality
group therapy often consists of a lengthy process of analyzing inner conflicts that are rooted in the past (first 6 years of life)
primary goals include making the unconscious conscious and the restructuring of personality for all group members
Modern Psycho Dynamics
major techniques include maintaining the analytic framework, free association, interpretation, dream analysis, analysis of resistance, and analysis of transference
group members may freely associate to begin sessions and then respond to initial topic
two key features of psychodynamic group therapy are ways that transference and countertransference are played out in the context of the current group situation
in contrast to the classical model of the impersonal & detached analyst, the contemporary formulation emphasizes group cohesiveness and especially the relationship with the leader
Adlerian Group Therapy
key component is the way the individual fits into his/her/their interpersonal environment (the social interest), and the quality of life depends on our views about others, the world, and ourselves (in relationship)
the group becomes a social microcosm
holistic, phenomenological, goal-oriented, motivational
highly technical, with many worksheets, but also focuses on interpersonal learning
the group itself will complete worksheets both in group and at home, and then share with each other
family constellation
has long term impact on individual’s interpersonal relationships
social interest
democratic climate
elements
heavily psychoeducational, with group leaders teaching clients about systems
present and future orientation
brief approach
the therapeutic relationship is based on cooperation, mutual trust, respect, confidence, collaboration, and alignment of goals
technique oriented
gathering life-history data
lifestyle analysis
interpretation of early family experiences
early recollections
encouragement
homework
Person-Centered Approach
group work becomes a process group but based on person-centered principles
therapy based on the self-actualizing tendency
ability to solve our own problems & resolve them
community of group members represents a ‘support team’
focus on the present moment, here-and-now
unconditional positive regard
acceptance of self and other group members
implicit goal of establishing safety and group cohesion
therapeutic relationship serves as foundation for self-exploration and increased awareness of blocks to growth
Existential Approach
key propositions of existential therapy
we have the capacity for self-awareness
freedom and responsibility
individualism and knowing ourselves through social connection
we create our own meaning throughout our lives
anxiety is part of the human condition
death & existential aloneness
goal is to help members accept responsibility and become meaning-makers
the group cohesion and the therapeutic relationship are of paramount importance
subject-subject relationship, acknowledging unity of being and authenticity
process illumination around authentic connection between humans
appropriate for use in grief therapy
opposed to techniques
Gestalt Group Approaches
focus on
here and now
direct experiencing
bringing unfinished business into the present
the primary goal of gestalt therapy is attaining awareness and greater choice in group members
gestalt group therapists prioritize…
presence
authentic dialogue between group members
gentleness
direct self-expression
focus on trusting in the group member’s honest experience
experiments over techniques
experiments move group members from talk to action and experience
group leaders need to be willing to challenge group members who are not behaving authentically
feelings, thoughts, body sensations, and actions are all used as pathways to understand what is central for the group members in each moment
Psychodrama
theatrical approach in which individuals act out past experiences or inner processes
goal of fostering creativity in the individual, the group, and ultimately in the culture
other goals include promoting catharsis and insight
leaders are active & directive, using a “protagonist” who is the primary focus
others are ‘role players’
specific techniques used to
intensify feelings
clarify implicit beliefs
increase self-awareness
practice new behaviors
Behavior Group Therapy
the cornerstone of this approach is the identification of specific goals at the outset of therapy, which serves as a way to monitor and measure the progress of members
includes an assessment of each group member, either in a pre-group screening meeting or during that first session
evidence based practice includes techniques that are selected (once goals are set) to deal with specific member problems
leaders tend to be active and directive and to function as consultants and problem solvers
techniques include having group members work individually on own issues and then sharing
relaxation methods
behavioral rehearsal
coaching
guided practice
mindfulness skills
cognitive restructuring
systematic desensitization
Cognitive Therapy
assumes that people are prone to learning erroneous, self-defeating thoughts but that they are capable of unlearning them
groups are present-centered, psychoeducational, and time-limited
the goal is to change the way group members think by identifying their automatic thoughts and introduce the idea of cognitive restructuring
the group leader assists members in forming hypotheses and testing their assumptions
process known as collaborative empiricism
group leaders combine empathy & sensitivity with technical competence
leaders function as teachers
techniques include Socratic questioning and guided discovery
Narrative Therapy
this approach is based partly on examining the stories that people tell & understanding the meaning of their stories
the therapist attempts to separate clients from their problems (through externalizing conversations) so that they do not adopt a fixed view of their identity
group members are invited to view their stories from different perspectives, with the support of other group members and their input, and eventually co-create an alternative life story
members are invited to describe their experience in fresh language and identify how societal standards are internalized in ways that constrain them
narrative therapy’s most distinctive feature is captured by the statement, “ the person is not the problem, but the problem is the problem”
therapists ask questions from a not-knowing perspective
members learn that they are not cemented to their problem-saturated stories and can develop alternative and more constructive stories
Feminist Therapy
this approach focuses on issues of diversity, the complexity of sexism, and the centrality of scoial context in understanding gender issues
group counseling has the task of bringing to awareness how gender-role socialization is deeply ingrained in adult personality
problematic symptoms can be viewed as coping or survival strategies rather than as evidence of pathology
the major goal of feminist therapy is empowerment
feminist group therapists work in an egalitarian manner and use empowerment strategies tailored to each client
goal of empowerment
the leader works to demystify the therapeutic process & include ach member as an active partner in the treatment process
techniques include
gender-role analysis and intervention
power analysis and intervention
social action
group members actively take on leadership roles within the group
Inclusive Model of Group Therapy
intersectionality
accounts for both leaders & members
it is an active process
choices are made by leaders and members
ecological systems
participants have varying perspectives
bronfenbrenner’s diagram lacks inclusivity
each participant could create their own diagram based on intersectionality
critical race theory
racism is real and ongoing
whites are invited to participate too
honest reflection leads to potential change
relational cultural theory
group learning actively applied to life outside of group
opportunities to apply learning are intentional
growth within the group occurs with both individuals and group overall
conflict
conflict is normal in groups
anger focused on the leader is inevitable
avoiding conflict is destructive
addressing conflict leads to productivity