Moving from Individual Developmental Counseling Theories to Advanced Multicultural & Social Justice

Theory & Integration

  • a theory can guide you, much as a roadmap or a navigational instrument

  • a set of directions tells you where are you starting out, where you hope to end, and the steps along the way

  • even with a plan, you will need to be flexible in modifying the way you try to reach your goals

  • developing an integrative approach is a process that will likely take years and will evolve as you gain experience and fine-tune your own clinical style

    • consider your own personality, interpersonal strengths, life experiences, and worldview as you choose the concepts and techniques that work best with a range of clients

Individual Theories & Limitations

  • definition

    • related set of ideas that explain or make predictions

      • individual theories in counseling are exclusionary

      • recently theories are being interrogated

      • race & deviance are intertwined when referencing clients of color

  • cultural application in groups

    • individual theories are commonly applied to groups

      • these theories are based on dominant cultures

      • group related theories & culturally responsive theories are needed

  • limitations

    • focus individual work and theoretical frames into a group perspective

      • gaps & research evidence to substantiate outcomes

      • practice isn’t fully accepted as science yet

Group Developmental Theories

  • Tuckman

    • very popular schematic to identify and apply group development

      • terms are active

      • terms may influence development

      • leaders experience drives group outcome

  • intersectionality

    • created to understand experiences of Black women

      • racism & oppression are at the core

      • used as a research paradigm

      • goal ensures inclusivity and social justice movements

  • critical race theory

    • centers voices of racially marginalized individuals

      • flexible framework underscoring White privilege

      • theories used to highlight perspective of the silenced

      • emerging framework for mixed methods research

  • relational cultural theory

    • all people want to connect with others

      • individuals within a group are seen as part of the system

      • connection, relationships, and interactions of members is key

      • individuals grow in concert with others inside and outside of group

Relationship of Theories to Techniques

  • psychodynamic approaches stress insight in therapy (psychoanalytic and Adlerian therapy)

  • experiential and relationship-oriented approaches stress feelings & subjective experiencing (existential, person-centered, Gestalt therapy, and psychodrama)

  • cognitive behavioral approaches stress the role of thinking and doing and tend to be action-oriented (behavior therapy, cognitive therapy, rational emotive behavior therapy, and reality therapy)

  • postmodern approaches stress understanding the subjective world of the client and tap existing resources for change within the individual (solution-focused brief therapy, narrative therapy, motivational interviewing, and feminist therapy)

Psychoanalytic Groups

  • emphasizes insight, unconscious motivation, and reconstruction of the personality

  • group therapy often consists of a lengthy process of analyzing inner conflicts that are rooted in the past (first 6 years of life)

  • primary goals include making the unconscious conscious and the restructuring of personality for all group members

Modern Psycho Dynamics

  • major techniques include maintaining the analytic framework, free association, interpretation, dream analysis, analysis of resistance, and analysis of transference    

    • group members may freely associate to begin sessions and then respond to initial topic

  • two key features of psychodynamic group therapy are ways that transference and countertransference are played out in the context of the current group situation

  • in contrast to the classical model of the impersonal & detached analyst, the contemporary formulation emphasizes group cohesiveness and especially the relationship with the leader

Adlerian Group Therapy

  • key component is the way the individual fits into his/her/their interpersonal environment (the social interest), and the quality of life depends on our views about others, the world, and ourselves (in relationship)

    • the group becomes a social microcosm

  • holistic, phenomenological, goal-oriented, motivational

  • highly technical, with many worksheets, but also focuses on interpersonal learning

    • the group itself will complete worksheets both in group and at home, and then share with each other

  • family constellation

    • has long term impact on individual’s interpersonal relationships

  • social interest

  • democratic climate

  • elements

    • heavily psychoeducational, with group leaders teaching clients about systems

    • present and future orientation

    • brief approach

  • the therapeutic relationship is based on cooperation, mutual trust, respect, confidence, collaboration, and alignment of goals

  • technique oriented

    • gathering life-history data

    • lifestyle analysis

    • interpretation of early family experiences

    • early recollections

    • encouragement

    • homework

Person-Centered Approach

  • group work becomes a process group but based on person-centered principles

  • therapy based on the self-actualizing tendency

    • ability to solve our own problems & resolve them

    • community of group members represents a ‘support team’

  • focus on the present moment, here-and-now

  • unconditional positive regard

    • acceptance of self and other group members

  • implicit goal of establishing safety and group cohesion

    • therapeutic relationship serves as foundation for self-exploration and increased awareness of blocks to growth

Existential Approach

  • key propositions of existential therapy

    • we have the capacity for self-awareness

    • freedom and responsibility

    • individualism and knowing ourselves through social connection

    • we create our own meaning throughout our lives

    • anxiety is part of the human condition

    • death & existential aloneness

  • goal is to help members accept responsibility and become meaning-makers

  • the group cohesion and the therapeutic relationship are of paramount importance

    • subject-subject relationship, acknowledging unity of being and authenticity

      • process illumination around authentic connection between humans

  • appropriate for use in grief therapy

  • opposed to techniques

Gestalt Group Approaches

  • focus on

    • here and now

    • direct experiencing

    • bringing unfinished business into the present

  • the primary goal of gestalt therapy is attaining awareness and greater choice in group members

  • gestalt group therapists prioritize…

    • presence

    • authentic dialogue between group members

    • gentleness

    • direct self-expression

  • focus on trusting in the group member’s honest experience

  • experiments over techniques

    • experiments move group members from talk to action and experience

  • group leaders need to be willing to challenge group members who are not behaving authentically

  • feelings, thoughts, body sensations, and actions are all used as pathways to understand what is central for the group members in each moment

Psychodrama

  • theatrical approach in which individuals act out past experiences or inner processes

  • goal of fostering creativity in the individual, the group, and ultimately in the culture

    • other goals include promoting catharsis and insight

  • leaders are active & directive, using a “protagonist” who is the primary focus

    • others are ‘role players’

  • specific techniques used to

    • intensify feelings

    • clarify implicit beliefs

    • increase self-awareness

    • practice new behaviors

Behavior Group Therapy

  • the cornerstone of this approach is the identification of specific goals at the outset of therapy, which serves as a way to monitor and measure the progress of members

  • includes an assessment of each group member, either in a pre-group screening meeting or during that first session

  • evidence based practice includes techniques that are selected (once goals are set) to deal with specific member problems

  • leaders tend to be active and directive and to function as consultants and problem solvers

  • techniques include having group members work individually on own issues and then sharing

    • relaxation methods

    • behavioral rehearsal

    • coaching

    • guided practice

    • mindfulness skills

    • cognitive restructuring

    • systematic desensitization

Cognitive Therapy

  • assumes that people are prone to learning erroneous, self-defeating thoughts but that they are capable of unlearning them

  • groups are present-centered, psychoeducational, and time-limited

  • the goal is to change the way group members think by identifying their automatic thoughts and introduce the idea of cognitive restructuring

  • the group leader assists members in forming hypotheses and testing their assumptions

    • process known as collaborative empiricism

  • group leaders combine empathy & sensitivity with technical competence

    • leaders function as teachers

  • techniques include Socratic questioning and guided discovery

Narrative Therapy

  • this approach is based partly on examining the stories that people tell & understanding the meaning of their stories

  • the therapist attempts to separate clients from their problems (through externalizing conversations) so that they do not adopt a fixed view of their identity

  • group members are invited to view their stories from different perspectives, with the support of other group members and their input, and eventually co-create an alternative life story

  • members are invited to describe their experience in fresh language and identify how societal standards are internalized in ways that constrain them

  • narrative therapy’s most distinctive feature is captured by the statement, “ the person is not the problem, but the problem is the problem”

  • therapists ask questions from a not-knowing perspective

  • members learn that they are not cemented to their problem-saturated stories and can develop alternative and more constructive stories

Feminist Therapy

  • this approach focuses on issues of diversity, the complexity of sexism, and the centrality of scoial context in understanding gender issues

  • group counseling has the task of bringing to awareness how gender-role socialization is deeply ingrained in adult personality

  • problematic symptoms can be viewed as coping or survival strategies rather than as evidence of pathology

  • the major goal of feminist therapy is empowerment

  • feminist group therapists work in an egalitarian manner and use empowerment strategies tailored to each client

    • goal of empowerment

  • the leader works to demystify the therapeutic process & include ach member as an active partner in the treatment process

  • techniques include

    • gender-role analysis and intervention

    • power analysis and intervention

    • social action

  • group members actively take on leadership roles within the group

Inclusive Model of Group Therapy

  • intersectionality

    • accounts for both leaders & members

      • it is an active process

      • choices are made by leaders and members

  • ecological systems

    • participants have varying perspectives

      • bronfenbrenner’s diagram lacks inclusivity

      • each participant could create their own diagram based on intersectionality

  • critical race theory

    • racism is real and ongoing

      • whites are invited to participate too

      • honest reflection leads to potential change

  • relational cultural theory

    • group learning actively applied to life outside of group

      • opportunities to apply learning are intentional

      • growth within the group occurs with both individuals and group overall

  • conflict

    • conflict is normal in groups

      • anger focused on the leader is inevitable

      • avoiding conflict is destructive

      • addressing conflict leads to productivity