Literature
Reed 2002
Animal behaviour as a tool in conservation
Chapter in a book
Reed (2002) states that behaviour affects species persistence through
Social disruption of breeding
Dispersal and settlement decisions
Learned and socially facilitated foraging
Translocation success
Maladaptive canalized behaviour
What examples does Reed (2002) give regarding the importance of animal behaviour in conservation?
How to create proper corridors to facilitate dispersal among protected areas
By understanding animal behaviour, we can solve one aspect of corridor design.
e.g. domesticated sheep dislike walking in their own shadows
Determining species management goals
Reed discusses how behaviouralists have only just recently entered the field of conservation, and that journals from respective field discuss few (if any) of the other’s issues.
Reed continues the chapter by presenting the ways that animal behaviour can be used as a tool to achieve conservation goals.
Which issues in conservation biology does Reed (2002) bring up?
Finding behavioural indicators of ecosystem health
Increasing reproductive success and survival
Facilitating movement
Improving population viability analysis
Facilitating species translocation or reintroduction
Reducing loss of genetic variability
Popular indicators of ecosystem health or integrity
Presence/abundance of particular pollutants in wildlife
Specific habitat structures
Presence/abundance of particular species
Disadvantages of many indicators
High economic cost of measurement
Destruction of the individual being tested
Necessity of long-term data
Long time lag between the introduction of a problem and response of the indicators
Particular behaviours/disruption of behaviours can be used as indicators of ecosystem health
These sometimes avoid the problems that other bioindicators have
Certain behaviours (or lack of them) can indicate sublethal levels of toxins/pollutants in animals.
E.g. tremors in limbs, altered time/energy budgets, disrupted motor and sensory functions, decreased performance in learned tasks.
Not all studies find behavioural responses to the pollutants,
experimental work is needed if one needs to know what responses are expected to which specific toxin, both on affected animals and healthy animals.
High population density might be associated with
nonterritorial animals (non-breeding)
social disruption
reduced reproductive success
Changes in time budgets, such as time spent foraging, also can reflect changes in environmental condition, such as sea bird foraging time reflecting fish prey stocks.
Downsides to using behaviours as indicators
necessity to decide on discreet, quantifiable behaviours to measure
difficulty of determining specific cause and effect
Reed (2002) says this is less important if the goal is to determine whether or not there IS a problem, and not when trying to figure out WHAT the problem is.
Behaviour can affect reproductive success
e.g. small population sizes
reduction in reproductive success/survival
increased frequency of hybridization
resulting from inadequate behavioural barriers to mating
SOLUTIONS
Some birds will not mate in small population sizes
Fix this by putting up mirrors (flamingos displayed prereproductive displays)
No breeding has been observed though
Behaviours that affect survival rate
Predator avoidance
in some species, related to local habitat familiarity
in other species, social behaviour depending on a minimum group size
Learned foraging skills
often learned through social learning and to offspring
larger groups feeding simultaneously —> lower predation risk —> conspecifics join the group to feed —> longer time spent foraging
using feeding stations encourage feeding/foraging behaviour, e.g. exposing them to new foods (either safe or “unsafe” food to train aversion)
one study did this and due to altered food distribution, monogamous birds turned polygamous which threatened the genetic variety in the population
^^ important when releasing animals back into the wild
Fragmentation and habitat loss lead to both physical and psychological isolation, with the latter being behavioural.
Some species refuse to migrate across habitats, which is important to know in conservation.
Roth & McGreevy (2025)
Discusses horse vision through Tinbergen’s 4 questions + the Five Domains
Argues that this is important for the horses and their handlers.
Uses biological (+anatomical), and welfare perspective
The Five Domains:
Nutrition and Hydration
Physical Environment
Health
Behavioural interactions with the environment, conspecifics, and humans
Overall welfare status
Horses, due to being prey, have a panoramic vision, with the only blind spots due to its own body (behind itself + immediately in front of the forehead.
T3: Fitness due to being prey and have a higher chance of survival with panoramic vision
e.g. when running in a group, the one in the front can focus on guiding the others while the rest look out for predators.
T4: Many ungulates share this trait
T2: In sheep, the mother-lamb bond may be important for the development of depth perception in the lamb.
Horse myths:
That if horses see thing with one eye, it doesn’t mean it also understands it when it sees it with the next eye (walking back and forth from stable and is startled by a thing on the way back but not on the first walk)
T1: object appears in another background context when it is perceived from a 90 degree different angle
T1: due to wind etc the horse could be hit with other sensory input
T3: It is important for prey to be cautious of even small changes in the environment for their survival
Horse eye shape:
T3/T4: Many herbivorous prey animals share the horizontal pupil
T1: autonomic nervous system controls the pupil size, triggered by light
Domains and horses
D1: Foals use vision (and other senses) to locate the mother’s udders. Looks horizontally. Vision affects their foraging decisions (long grass preferred). Horses in captivity deficate at similar spots and avoid eating there, but wild horses do not, so there is no evolutionary pressure to avoid these areas using vision.
D2: Lack of light can lead to myopia in other species. Give foals a very rich visual environment.
D3:
Sih et al. (2004)
About behavioural syndromes/personalities
General consenus that when traits are correlated, they should be studied as a package. Sih et al argues they should be studied separately.
Studies sometimes show that one behavioural syndrome remains the same across contexts (e.g. high aggressiveness in mating also gives high aggressiveness in feeding), while other studies show no such correlation.
Distinct personality types persist because of
large cost of flexibility, or,
the benefit of being predictable (consistent) is large
Behavioural syndromes (across contexts) are important because they can
limit behavioural plasticity
explain non-optimal behaviour
help to maintain individual variation in behaviour
These behavioural effects can have major impacts on
Individual fitness
Species distributions
Species responses to environmental change
Speciation rates