Comprehensive Study Notes on Abortion and Motherhood in Social and Social Dynamics
The Socio-Moral and Technical Realities of Abortion
- Foundations of Arguments Against Abortion: The practical reasons invoked against legal abortion are considered unfounded. They are often reduced to a theological argument: the belief that the fetus possesses a soul and that baptism is required for its entry into paradise.
- Religious and Institutional Inconsistencies:
- The Church historically authorizes the killing of adults in contexts like war or the death penalty but maintains an "intransigent humanitarianism" toward the fetus.
- During holy wars, unbaptized "infidels" were massacred with encouragement from the Church.
- Victims of the Inquisition and guillotined criminals were often not in a "state of grace," yet the Church leaves their salvation to God while refusing the same for an embryonic soul.
- Masculine Sadism and Bad Faith: The text cites a book dedicated to Pétain in 1943 by a Dr. Roy as a "monument of bad faith."
- Dr. Roy promotes Cesareans as "hygienic" while labeling abortion a crime rather than a misdemeanor.
- He argues against therapeutic abortion even when the mother’s life is in danger, suggesting the mother should be sacrificed because the fetus is an "autonomous being."
- Contradictory views: Some "right-thinking" doctors exalt motherhood by claiming the fetus is part of the mother's body, while simultaneously arguing it is not a parasite to prevent her liberation.
- Failure of Legal Repression:
- Partisans and enemies of legal abortion agree that repression has failed.
- Statistical data: Professors Doléris, Balthazard, and Lacassagne estimated 500,000 abortions per year around 1933.
- A statistic cited by Dr. Roy for 1938 estimated 1,000,000 abortions.
- In 1941, Dr. Aubertin of Bordeaux estimated between 800,000 and 1,000,000.
- Comparison: Dr. Desplas (1948) estimated that in the Seine district (1943), there were only 513 condemnations out of an estimated 15,000 presumptive abortions.
The Class Dynamics and Living Conditions of Abortion
- The Concept of the "Class Crime": Abortion is often described as a class crime because of the disparate conditions under which it is performed.
- Bourgeoisie Advantages: Contraceptive practices are more prevalent due to better facilities (e.g., bathrooms/running water); household wealth makes children less of a burden; easy access to "therapeutic" exceptions or travel to Switzerland where abortion is tolerated.
- Proletariat/Peasant Struggles: Lack of hygiene (no running water); necessity for wives to work; poverty and housing shortages are primary drivers for seeking abortion.
- The "Common Ward" Anecdotes (October 1945): Geneviève Serreau described patients at a hospital following curettages:
- Number 9: Wife of a market porter; had 10 children (only 3 living); had 7 miscarriages (5 induced); used the "coat hanger" technique.
- Number 16: 16 years old, married; contracted salpingitis from an abortion.
- Number 7: 35 years old; had a lover for the first time in 20 years of marriage; chose abortion for "self-respect" and to avoid discovery.
- Number 14: Had 5 children in 5 years; looked like an old woman at age 40.
- Physical and Economic Hardships:
- In the countryside, peasant women resort to falling off ladders or throwing themselves down stairs.
- In cities, incompetent "backstreet abortionists" cause injuries like perforated uteri with knitting needles or incorrect injections (e.g., vinegar into the bladder instead of the uterus).
- L’étoile vesper and Gribiche (Colette) highlight the dangers of soap solutions and physical exertion used to induce miscarriage.
The Psychological and Moral Impact on Women
- The Moral Dilemma: Even women who despise bourgeois morality may feel intimidated by the law and feel they have committed a crime. The act of begging for an address or a doctor's care is seen as humiliating.
- Alienation and Guilt:
- Abortion is not viewed as a simple contraceptive practice because an "absolute commencement" is halted.
- Remorse is often tied to childhood jealousy regarding siblings, manifesting as a belief that they have "killed a child."
- Resentment against men: Women often become frigid toward the man who accepted or requested the abortion.
- In extreme cases, the trauma leads some women to become homosexual or view their sex as a "malediction."
- Male Hypocrisy: Men often forbid abortion collectively but accept it individually as a convenient solution. The woman feels the contradiction in her "wounded flesh" while the man just uses "words."
- Stekel's Conclusion: "Prohibition of abortion is an immoral law, since it must be forcibly broken every day, every hour."
The Paradoxes of Conception and Pregnancy Desires
- Indetermination of Choice: Fecundity is a mix of considered desire and chance. A woman may desire pregnancy but be sterile, or give birth against her will.
- The Complexity of Motivations:
- An unwed mother may find secret satisfaction despite material distress.
- A married woman may outwardly welcome pregnancy but internally hate it due to infantile fantasies.
- Phases of Motherhood Perception:
- Childhood: A miracle or game (dolls).
- Adolescence: A threat to personal integrity (Colette Audry’s heroine wanted her body to stay "hard and sealed").
- Psychic Defense Mechanisms: Functional infertility can be caused by fear (e.g., Mme H. became pregnant only after 6 years when she stopped "talking" about it).
- The Role of the Mother-Daughter Relationship:
- Becoming a mother can be a total emancipation from one's own mother.
- If guilt toward the mother is strong, a woman may fear her child will die or kill her (Remorse-induced miscarriages).
- Case of Mrs. Smith (Helene Deutsch): Experienced miscarriages triggered by the abandonment or changes in her "maternal" friend, reflecting her unresolved mother problems.
- Enrichment vs. Mutilation: The fetus is both part of the body and a parasite. The mother feels as "vast as the world" yet feels she is nothing else.
- Immanence and Transcendence: The pregnant body is a passive instrument of life. The woman becomes "plant and animal," an "incubator," or an "egg."
- The "Breeders": Women who seek the "passive fertility" of the body as a tranquil justification for existence. They seek the fusion in the child that they could not find in the male.
- Ambivalence of Creation:
- The mother does not "make" the child; it is a "gratuitous proliferation."
- She engenders the generality of a body but cannot provide the child's reasons for being.
- Two contradictory fantasies: The child as a "hero" (consciousness/liberty) vs. the child as a "monster" (contingent flesh).
The Medical and Psychic Symptoms of Pregnancy
- Alienation and Fear: The realization of pregnancy often brings fright, manifested in vomiting. This is identified by Stekel and Deutsch as an "oral expulsion tendency" or hostility toward the fetus.
- Psychogenic Symptoms:
- Bulimia, lack of appetite, and constipation reflect hesitations between keeping and destroying the embryo.
- Mme T. Case: Suffered irrepressible vomiting because she subconsciously identified with a friend who died during pregnancy.
- The "Cravings" Culture: Infantile obsessions focused on food.
- Duchesse d’Abrantès: Relates how her social circle imperiously suggested a craving for pineapple until she felt she would die without it, only to find it hateful once she had it.
- The "Long Holiday" (Colette): For some women, pregnancy is a state of euphoria and pride, a "saving grace" where they are "governed by calm animality."
- Separation Anxiety: The last stage marks the transition from imaginary individual to a heavily present intruder.
- Birth as Stoicism or Martyrdom:
- Isadora Duncan: Described childbirth as more cruel than the Spanish Inquisition, with "relentless, cruel" genie tearing her sinews.
- Other Perspectives: Some women feel creative power or even sexual pleasure during the act.
- Postpartum Disappointment:
- Cécile Sauvage: Expressed a "terrifying void" and the feeling of a "house from which they have removed a body."
- The child is a newcomer, a stranger with whom the mother has no shared past.
- Nursing: Prolongs the "vacation" state of plenitude. Colette describes the newborn as an "assembly of marvels" (shrimp-scaled nails, almond-incised sex) but admits she did not initially feel this as love.
- Linda (Katherine Mansfield, "Prelude"): Illustrates the exhaustion of childbearing and the indifference felt toward children because her courage was "broken" by them.
The Toxic and Authentic Dynamics of Maternal Devotion
- The Myth of Maternal Instinct: Maternal attitude is defined by the woman's total situation, not a biological mandate.
- Mothers as Failing Individuals: Children are often given to unfulfilled women who are sexually unsatisfied or socially inferior.
- Symbolic Vengeance: A mother who beats her child (e.g., Enrico/Mouloudji or Violette Leduc) is often taking revenge on a seducer or on the world.
- The "Cruel Stepmother" trope: A hypocritical way society avoids discussing the "bad mother."
- Narcissism and Social Tyranny:
- Mothers may use children as "jewels" (Cornelia) to show off.
- Mrs. Mazzetti case: An Italian woman who tried to impose her own failed ambitions and moral standards on her children, driving them to rebellion, alcoholism, and promiscuity.
- The Mater Dolorosa: Uses suffering as a weapon, creating lifelong guilt in the child.
Maternal Relations Based on the Child’s Gender
- Relations with Sons:
- The son is the "hero" who will provide the mother with access to the world she was denied.
- Ambivalence: She wants him to be a genius/conquerer but also wants him to remain a dependant baby she can dominate.
- She may treat him with "ironic familiarity" or threaten castration to keep him immanent.
- Relations with Daughters:
- The daughter is treated as a double. The mother projects her own ambiguity and resentment of the feminine condition onto her.
- Sido (Colette): A rare example of a mother who cherishes a daughter's freedom without demands.
- The Curse: "You will be a woman." Mothers often inflict the same defects and restrictions they suffered on their daughters.
- Jealousy: The mother envies the daughter’s flourishing body and future as she herself declines. This leads to rages against makeup, going out, and friendships.
Social and Philosophical Conclusions
- The Illusion of Panacea: Motherhood is not a cure for neurosis or boredom. Sophia Tolstoy's diaries prove that giving birth 12 times did not prevent her from feeling that everything was "useless and empty."
- The Responsibility of Education: It is a "social neglect" to entrust the most serious undertaking—forming a human being—to individuals (women) who are denied education and culture.
- Montesquieu’s Proposal: Suggested it is better to entrust women with the government of the state than with a family because she rises above her sex in concerted action.
- Conditions for Authentic Motherhood:
- Motherhood should be a voluntary commitment (engagement).
- In a properly organized society, the child would be taken charge of by the group, and motherhood would be compatible with a mother's professional work.
- The woman with the richest personal life (work, social participation) is the best fit to bring up children because she does not seek to live through them by proxy.
- Equality Myth: Motherhood does not make a woman man’s equal. It is often glorified only within marriage where the woman remains subordinate to the husband's economic power.