The Criminal Justice System: Goals, Operations, Models, and Disparities

Definitions and Categories of Crime

  • Definition of Crimes:

    • Actions that violate laws defined by society.

  • Classifications of Crime:

    • Mala in se:

    • Crimes that are traditionally accepted as inherently wrong in themselves or by their very nature.

    • Examples include homicide and sexual assault.

    • Mala prohibita:

    • Offenses that are prohibited by law, but regarding which members of society disagree concerning their degree of harmfulness.

    • Examples include gambling, prostitution, and drug possession.

Core Goals of the Criminal Justice System

  • Doing Justice:

    • Focuses on upholding society's interests in a fair and just manner, where fairness and equity serve as the foundational elements.

    • Key operational components include:

    • Establishing fair laws.

    • Imposing fair punishments.

    • Maintaining institutional accountability.

    • Ensuring equal treatment for all individuals under the system.

  • Controlling Crime:

    • Focuses on identifying, prosecuting, convicting, and punishing offenders in a fair, equitable, and legal manner.

    • Involves actively arresting and punishing offenders, requiring police officers and prosecutors to adhere strictly to rules while taking direct action against lawbreakers.

  • Preventing Crime:

    • Focuses on executing fair, equitable, and lawful prosecutions and punishments that set a clear deterrent example for society.

    • Utilizes technological surveillance and search mechanisms alongside proactive, common-sense actions carried out by citizens.

  • Advancing System Goals Through Evidence-Based Practices:

    • Involves enacting and enforcing justice policies based on factual, science-driven data designed to ensure measurable policy success.

Criminal Justice Operations in a Federal System

  • System of Federalism:

    • The United States divides governmental authority between national (federal) and state governments.

    • Operates two distinct justice systems:

    • Federal Justice System: Prosecutes violations of federal statutes and laws.

    • State Justice System: Prosecutes violations of state statutes and local laws.

  • Distribution of Criminal Justice Personnel:

    • The vast majority of criminal justice employees are situated at state and local levels rather than the federal level.

Percentage of criminal justice employees by level of government
  • Police Employment Distribution:

    • Federal: 11.9 %11.9\,\%

    • State: 9.2 %9.2\,\%

    • Local: 78.8 %78.8\,\%

  • Judicial and Legal Employment Distribution (includes prosecution, public defense, and courts):

    • Federal: 6.4 %6.4\,\%

    • State: 38.2 %38.2\,\%

    • Local: 55.3 %55.3\,\%

  • Corrections Employment Distribution:

    • Federal: 4.8 %4.8\,\%

    • State: 59.3 %59.3\,\%

    • Local: 35.9 %35.9\,\%

  • Total Justice System Employment Distribution:

    • Federal: 8.8 %8.8\,\%

    • State: 29.0 %29.0\,\%

    • Local: 62.2 %62.2\,\%

    • Expansion of Federal Involvement:

  • Federal law enforcement and judicial involvement have expanded because an increasing proportion of criminal activity crosses state borders.

  • Key areas of federal expansion include:

    • Crime syndicates.

    • Terrorist activities.

    • Drug trafficking organizations.

    • Internet crimes against children.

Criminal Justice as a Social System

  • System Perspective:

    • The criminal justice system functions as a complex whole constructed from interdependent agencies, including police, prosecutor offices, courts, and corrections.

    • Each entity relies directly on the others, meaning policy or operational changes made within one agency directly impact all other connected agencies.

  • Exchange Relationships:

    • System operations depend on mutual transfers and utilization of resources across organizational boundaries.

    • Successful functioning requires securing multi-agency cooperation and assistance.

    • Plea Bargaining:

    • A primary example of system exchange wherein the accused defendant admits guilt to a crime in exchange for specific considerations, such as reduced charges or a lighter sentence.

Exchange relationships of the prosecuting attorney with various system actors
  • Key Actors in Prosecutorial Exchange Relationships:

    • Prosecuting attorneys maintain continuous exchange relationships with U.S. attorneys, state attorneys general, courts, police departments, defense lawyers, county agencies, county commissioners, and community influentials.

    • Key System Characteristics:

  • Discretion: The authority granted to criminal justice officials to make decisions based on their personal official judgment.

  • Resource Dependence: System agencies rely on external political and administrative entities for budgetary support and resources.

  • Sequential Tasks: System decisions and case processing steps must occur in a strict, fixed order.

  • Filtering: A continuous screening process that exits defendants out of the system at various procedural stages.

Core Components and Operations of Criminal Justice Agencies

  • Police Agencies:

    • Primary functions include maintaining public peace, apprehending law violators, preventing criminal activity, and providing social services to communities.

  • Court Agencies:

    • Structured around a dual court system, maintaining completely separate court infrastructures for state courts and federal courts.

    • Adjudication: The formal judicial procedure utilized to determine the legal guilt or innocence of a defendant.

  • Correctional Agencies:

    • Composed of state prisons, federal prisons, municipal or county jails, probation departments, and parole systems.

The Thirteen Steps of Decision-Making in the Criminal Justice System

  • Step 1: Investigation:

    • Law enforcement officers conduct inquiries to investigate allegations that a crime was committed.

  • Step 2: Arrest:

    • Physical custody is taken of an offender based on sufficient legal evidence establishing probable cause.

  • Step 3: Booking:

    • The arrested individual is transported to a detention facility or jail, where official administrative records, photographs (mugshots), and fingerprints are recorded.

  • Step 4: Charging:

    • Prosecuting attorneys evaluate police evidence to decide whether formal legal charges will be filed and adjudicated.

  • Step 5: Initial Appearance:

    • The defendant is brought directly before a judge to be formally notified of the filed charges and advised of constitutional rights.

    • The judge conducts an initial review to confirm that sufficient evidence exists to proceed further.

  • Step 6: Preliminary Hearing / Grand Jury:

    • Preliminary Hearing: A judge evaluates facts and evidence to determine whether probable cause exists showing that the accused committed the crime.

    • Grand Jury: A panel of citizens reviews prosecution evidence to determine whether to issue a formal indictment.

  • Step 7: Indictment / Information:

    • If a preliminary hearing establishes probable cause, an information is filed; if a grand jury concurs, an indictment is issued.

    • The prosecutor drafts the formal charging document and files it directly with the court.

  • Step 8: Arraignment:

    • The defendant appears in court to hear the official reading of the indictment or information and enters a plea of guilty or not guilty.

    • Plea negotiations may take place at any time following the formal filing of an information or indictment.

  • Step 9: Trial:

    • Judicial Oversight: A judge presides over proceedings to ensure constitutional rights and evidentiary rules are strictly maintained.

    • Bench Trial: A trial conducted solely before a judge who determines the final verdict of guilt or innocence.

    • Jury Trial: A trial conducted before a jury of peers who evaluates evidence and renders the verdict.

    • Standard of Proof: The prosecution must prove guilt "beyond a reasonable doubt" to secure a conviction.

  • Step 10: Sentencing:

    • Upon a finding of guilt, the presiding judge imposes formal punishment.

    • Available sentencing outcomes include state or federal imprisonment, suspended sentences, probation supervision, monetary fines, or mandatory community service.

  • Step 11: Appeal:

    • A convicted defendant may request a higher appellate court to review judicial proceedings.

    • Reviews ensure that law enforcement, prosecutors, defense lawyers, and trial judges did not violate legal standards or constitutional rights.

    • If significant errors or constitutional violations occurred, the appellate court may set aside the conviction and order a new trial.

  • Step 12: Corrections:

    • Correctional authorities execute sentences imposed by the trial judge.

    • Probation: Sanctions allowing convicted individuals to serve sentences within the community under supervision without custodial confinement.

    • Prison: Mandatory custodial confinement isolating the offender from society.

  • Step 13: Release:

    • Occurs when an offender fully completes their court-mandated sentence.

    • Parole: Conditional early release from custodial prison confinement, allowing the remaining portion of the sentence to be served within the community under supervision.

The Criminal Justice Wedding Cake Model

  • Concept:

    • Represents the criminal justice process as a multi-tiered structure where case handling and discretionary resources vary drastically depending on case severity and public visibility.

The four layers of the criminal justice wedding cake
  • Layer 1: The Celebrated Cases:

    • High-profile, highly public cases that receive intense media attention and full adversary court procedures.

  • Layer 2: The Serious Felonies:

    • Violent felony offenses committed by repeat offenders, subject to full formal processing and substantial sentences.

  • Layer 3: The Lesser Felonies:

    • Non-violent or less-threatening felony offenses, frequently resolved quickly through plea bargaining.

  • Layer 4: The Misdemeanors:

    • Minor offenses representing the largest volume of cases, including disturbing the peace and traffic violations.

Models of Criminal Justice: Crime Control vs. Due Process

  • Comparative Analysis:

    • Crime Control Model:

    • Primary Goal: Repression of criminal conduct.

    • Core Value: System efficiency.

    • System Process: Administrative.

    • Major Decision Point: Police investigations and pretrial screening processes.

    • Primary Decision-Making Mechanism: Official discretion.

    • Operational Philosophy: Emphasizes rapid, efficient case processing and punishment likened to an "assembly line"; accepts the risk that some innocent individuals may be wrongly convicted in exchange for systemic efficiency.

    • Due Process Model:

    • Primary Goal: Preservation of individual rights and civil liberties.

    • Core Value: System reliability and accuracy.

    • System Process: Adversarial proceedings.

    • Major Decision Point: Formal courtroom adjudication.

    • Primary Decision-Making Mechanism: Strict application of law.

    • Operational Philosophy: Prioritizes upholding justice by protecting individual constitutional rights through an "obstacle course" design; accepts the risk that some guilty defendants may go free to prevent improper government overreach.

Race, Disparity, and Discrimination in Criminal Justice

  • Distinction Between Disparity and Discrimination:

    • Disparity: Differences in outcomes or treatment between demographic groups defined by age, gender, or race; can originate from either neutral, fair practices or unfair practices.

    • Discrimination: Differential treatment directed against specific groups based on age, gender, or race resulting strictly from unfair practices.

  • Three Theoretical Explanations for Racial Disparities:

    • Explanation 1: People of Color Commit More Crimes:

    • Science-based research does not support the premise that race causes criminal behavior.

    • Criminal conduct relates directly to social contexts and socio-economic disadvantages rather than racial identity.

    • Media portrayals significantly skew public perceptions regarding race and crime relationships.

    • Explanation 2: The Criminal Justice System is Racially Biased:

    • Systemic bias manifests through law enforcement practices such as racial profiling, where police act on race-based assumptions rather than reasonable suspicion.

    • Law enforcement agencies heavily target low-income communities with minor traffic citations and arrests to generate local municipal revenue.

    • Explanation 3: American Society is Racially Biased:

    • Explicit Bias: Overt expressions of prejudice, such as police officers utilizing racial slurs.

    • Implicit Bias: Unconscious mental associations linking specific demographic groups to negative stereotypes, stemming from broader societal influence and conditioning.