The Criminal Justice System: Goals, Operations, Models, and Disparities
Definitions and Categories of Crime
Definition of Crimes:
Actions that violate laws defined by society.
Classifications of Crime:
Mala in se:
Crimes that are traditionally accepted as inherently wrong in themselves or by their very nature.
Examples include homicide and sexual assault.
Mala prohibita:
Offenses that are prohibited by law, but regarding which members of society disagree concerning their degree of harmfulness.
Examples include gambling, prostitution, and drug possession.
Core Goals of the Criminal Justice System
Doing Justice:
Focuses on upholding society's interests in a fair and just manner, where fairness and equity serve as the foundational elements.
Key operational components include:
Establishing fair laws.
Imposing fair punishments.
Maintaining institutional accountability.
Ensuring equal treatment for all individuals under the system.
Controlling Crime:
Focuses on identifying, prosecuting, convicting, and punishing offenders in a fair, equitable, and legal manner.
Involves actively arresting and punishing offenders, requiring police officers and prosecutors to adhere strictly to rules while taking direct action against lawbreakers.
Preventing Crime:
Focuses on executing fair, equitable, and lawful prosecutions and punishments that set a clear deterrent example for society.
Utilizes technological surveillance and search mechanisms alongside proactive, common-sense actions carried out by citizens.
Advancing System Goals Through Evidence-Based Practices:
Involves enacting and enforcing justice policies based on factual, science-driven data designed to ensure measurable policy success.
Criminal Justice Operations in a Federal System
System of Federalism:
The United States divides governmental authority between national (federal) and state governments.
Operates two distinct justice systems:
Federal Justice System: Prosecutes violations of federal statutes and laws.
State Justice System: Prosecutes violations of state statutes and local laws.
Distribution of Criminal Justice Personnel:
The vast majority of criminal justice employees are situated at state and local levels rather than the federal level.

Police Employment Distribution:
Federal:
State:
Local:
Judicial and Legal Employment Distribution (includes prosecution, public defense, and courts):
Federal:
State:
Local:
Corrections Employment Distribution:
Federal:
State:
Local:
Total Justice System Employment Distribution:
Federal:
State:
Local:
Expansion of Federal Involvement:
Federal law enforcement and judicial involvement have expanded because an increasing proportion of criminal activity crosses state borders.
Key areas of federal expansion include:
Crime syndicates.
Terrorist activities.
Drug trafficking organizations.
Internet crimes against children.
Criminal Justice as a Social System
System Perspective:
The criminal justice system functions as a complex whole constructed from interdependent agencies, including police, prosecutor offices, courts, and corrections.
Each entity relies directly on the others, meaning policy or operational changes made within one agency directly impact all other connected agencies.
Exchange Relationships:
System operations depend on mutual transfers and utilization of resources across organizational boundaries.
Successful functioning requires securing multi-agency cooperation and assistance.
Plea Bargaining:
A primary example of system exchange wherein the accused defendant admits guilt to a crime in exchange for specific considerations, such as reduced charges or a lighter sentence.

Key Actors in Prosecutorial Exchange Relationships:
Prosecuting attorneys maintain continuous exchange relationships with U.S. attorneys, state attorneys general, courts, police departments, defense lawyers, county agencies, county commissioners, and community influentials.
Key System Characteristics:
Discretion: The authority granted to criminal justice officials to make decisions based on their personal official judgment.
Resource Dependence: System agencies rely on external political and administrative entities for budgetary support and resources.
Sequential Tasks: System decisions and case processing steps must occur in a strict, fixed order.
Filtering: A continuous screening process that exits defendants out of the system at various procedural stages.
Core Components and Operations of Criminal Justice Agencies
Police Agencies:
Primary functions include maintaining public peace, apprehending law violators, preventing criminal activity, and providing social services to communities.
Court Agencies:
Structured around a dual court system, maintaining completely separate court infrastructures for state courts and federal courts.
Adjudication: The formal judicial procedure utilized to determine the legal guilt or innocence of a defendant.
Correctional Agencies:
Composed of state prisons, federal prisons, municipal or county jails, probation departments, and parole systems.
The Thirteen Steps of Decision-Making in the Criminal Justice System
Step 1: Investigation:
Law enforcement officers conduct inquiries to investigate allegations that a crime was committed.
Step 2: Arrest:
Physical custody is taken of an offender based on sufficient legal evidence establishing probable cause.
Step 3: Booking:
The arrested individual is transported to a detention facility or jail, where official administrative records, photographs (mugshots), and fingerprints are recorded.
Step 4: Charging:
Prosecuting attorneys evaluate police evidence to decide whether formal legal charges will be filed and adjudicated.
Step 5: Initial Appearance:
The defendant is brought directly before a judge to be formally notified of the filed charges and advised of constitutional rights.
The judge conducts an initial review to confirm that sufficient evidence exists to proceed further.
Step 6: Preliminary Hearing / Grand Jury:
Preliminary Hearing: A judge evaluates facts and evidence to determine whether probable cause exists showing that the accused committed the crime.
Grand Jury: A panel of citizens reviews prosecution evidence to determine whether to issue a formal indictment.
Step 7: Indictment / Information:
If a preliminary hearing establishes probable cause, an information is filed; if a grand jury concurs, an indictment is issued.
The prosecutor drafts the formal charging document and files it directly with the court.
Step 8: Arraignment:
The defendant appears in court to hear the official reading of the indictment or information and enters a plea of guilty or not guilty.
Plea negotiations may take place at any time following the formal filing of an information or indictment.
Step 9: Trial:
Judicial Oversight: A judge presides over proceedings to ensure constitutional rights and evidentiary rules are strictly maintained.
Bench Trial: A trial conducted solely before a judge who determines the final verdict of guilt or innocence.
Jury Trial: A trial conducted before a jury of peers who evaluates evidence and renders the verdict.
Standard of Proof: The prosecution must prove guilt "beyond a reasonable doubt" to secure a conviction.
Step 10: Sentencing:
Upon a finding of guilt, the presiding judge imposes formal punishment.
Available sentencing outcomes include state or federal imprisonment, suspended sentences, probation supervision, monetary fines, or mandatory community service.
Step 11: Appeal:
A convicted defendant may request a higher appellate court to review judicial proceedings.
Reviews ensure that law enforcement, prosecutors, defense lawyers, and trial judges did not violate legal standards or constitutional rights.
If significant errors or constitutional violations occurred, the appellate court may set aside the conviction and order a new trial.
Step 12: Corrections:
Correctional authorities execute sentences imposed by the trial judge.
Probation: Sanctions allowing convicted individuals to serve sentences within the community under supervision without custodial confinement.
Prison: Mandatory custodial confinement isolating the offender from society.
Step 13: Release:
Occurs when an offender fully completes their court-mandated sentence.
Parole: Conditional early release from custodial prison confinement, allowing the remaining portion of the sentence to be served within the community under supervision.
The Criminal Justice Wedding Cake Model
Concept:
Represents the criminal justice process as a multi-tiered structure where case handling and discretionary resources vary drastically depending on case severity and public visibility.

Layer 1: The Celebrated Cases:
High-profile, highly public cases that receive intense media attention and full adversary court procedures.
Layer 2: The Serious Felonies:
Violent felony offenses committed by repeat offenders, subject to full formal processing and substantial sentences.
Layer 3: The Lesser Felonies:
Non-violent or less-threatening felony offenses, frequently resolved quickly through plea bargaining.
Layer 4: The Misdemeanors:
Minor offenses representing the largest volume of cases, including disturbing the peace and traffic violations.
Models of Criminal Justice: Crime Control vs. Due Process
Comparative Analysis:
Crime Control Model:
Primary Goal: Repression of criminal conduct.
Core Value: System efficiency.
System Process: Administrative.
Major Decision Point: Police investigations and pretrial screening processes.
Primary Decision-Making Mechanism: Official discretion.
Operational Philosophy: Emphasizes rapid, efficient case processing and punishment likened to an "assembly line"; accepts the risk that some innocent individuals may be wrongly convicted in exchange for systemic efficiency.
Due Process Model:
Primary Goal: Preservation of individual rights and civil liberties.
Core Value: System reliability and accuracy.
System Process: Adversarial proceedings.
Major Decision Point: Formal courtroom adjudication.
Primary Decision-Making Mechanism: Strict application of law.
Operational Philosophy: Prioritizes upholding justice by protecting individual constitutional rights through an "obstacle course" design; accepts the risk that some guilty defendants may go free to prevent improper government overreach.
Race, Disparity, and Discrimination in Criminal Justice
Distinction Between Disparity and Discrimination:
Disparity: Differences in outcomes or treatment between demographic groups defined by age, gender, or race; can originate from either neutral, fair practices or unfair practices.
Discrimination: Differential treatment directed against specific groups based on age, gender, or race resulting strictly from unfair practices.
Three Theoretical Explanations for Racial Disparities:
Explanation 1: People of Color Commit More Crimes:
Science-based research does not support the premise that race causes criminal behavior.
Criminal conduct relates directly to social contexts and socio-economic disadvantages rather than racial identity.
Media portrayals significantly skew public perceptions regarding race and crime relationships.
Explanation 2: The Criminal Justice System is Racially Biased:
Systemic bias manifests through law enforcement practices such as racial profiling, where police act on race-based assumptions rather than reasonable suspicion.
Law enforcement agencies heavily target low-income communities with minor traffic citations and arrests to generate local municipal revenue.
Explanation 3: American Society is Racially Biased:
Explicit Bias: Overt expressions of prejudice, such as police officers utilizing racial slurs.
Implicit Bias: Unconscious mental associations linking specific demographic groups to negative stereotypes, stemming from broader societal influence and conditioning.