Notes on Punctuation by Lewis Thomas

Notes on Punctuation by Lewis Thomas

Introduction to Punctuation

  • Punctuation lacks precise rules, reflecting the complexity of English prose.

  • Fowler provides general advice regarding punctuation, acknowledging its intricacies.

  • English prose includes only four "stops":

    • Comma: one of the most commonly used stops.

    • Semicolon: indicative of a connection between clauses.

    • Colon: often used for lists or to introduce explanations.

    • Period: signifies the end of a thought.

  • Question mark and exclamation point are not classified as stops but indicate tone.

  • Greeks used the semicolon as a question mark, leading to an unusual reading experience with Greek questions (e.g., "Why weepest thou;").

  • Parentheses complicate punctuation by requiring a balance of opening and closing marks, impacting overall clarity.

Commas

  • Utility: Considered the most useful punctuation mark.

  • Advice: It is crucial to insert commas while composing, rather than retroactively, to avoid chaotic punctuation that resembles swarming minnows.

  • Recommendation: Use commas sparingly, with care and affection, at moments when their necessity is clearly felt.

Semicolons

  • Thomas has developed a fondness for semicolons over the years.

  • Function: They suggest lingering questions about the preceding sentence, indicating that additional information or clarification is forthcoming.

  • Semicolons establish a sense of expectancy in the reader; they signal that there is more to explore beyond the current statement.

Colons

  • Disadvantage: Colons are perceived as less attractive for a couple of reasons:

    • They create a sense of being directed or ordered by the writer.

    • Relay the implication that the writer believes the reader needs assistance in keeping track of their points.

  • The inconsistency in lists or sequences (e.g., first, second) can leave readers confused when expectations are not met.

Exclamation Points

  • Described as the most irritating punctuation mark.

  • Effect: They demand attention to the statement, likening their use to a child behaving in an attention-seeking manner.

  • Critique: Significant statements require no extra markings for emphasis, while mundane sentences become more trivial when accompanied by exclamation points.

Quotation Marks

  • Usage: Should be used honestly and sparingly, reserved for genuine quotations.

  • Ethical Consideration: When omitting parts of a quote for brevity, ellipses (three dots) should be included to indicate omissions clearly and ethically.

  • Clarification: Quotation marks should not be utilized for disclaimed ideas or clichés, which should be fully embraced by the speaker or writer.

  • Advertising Misuse: Quotation marks often appear misleadingly in advertising, lacking credible attribution or authenticity.

Dashes

  • Function: Dashes serve as an informal and playful tool to signal a shift in thought while maintaining a connection to the existing ideas.

  • Recommendation: If a dash is used, it should be concluded with another dash or transitioned with a period at the end of the sentence.

Punctuation in Poetry

  • Caution: In poetry, punctuation should be used economically, as if the marks themselves carry meanings.

  • Advice: Avoid unnecessary marks (e.g., dashes, extra periods) that clutter and obscure the intended message.

  • Exclamation Points: Their presence can detract from the impact of the entire poem.

  • Admiration for T.S. Eliot: Thomas appreciates the use of semicolons in Eliot’s "Four Quartets" for their ability to subtly connect complex ideas, enhancing the fluidity of the reading experience.

  • Role of Commas: Commas serve a functional purpose in organizing thoughts but do not provide moments of rest or contemplation for the reader, unlike semicolons.

Conclusion

  • Punctuation is an essential element of writing that influences clarity, effectiveness, and emotional tone. Understanding and using punctuation judiciously can enhance one’s writing style and communication proficiency.

  • Reference: Lewis Thomas from "The Medusa and the Snail: More Notes of a Biology Watcher (1979:103-6)".