Ethics and Aesthetics Notes

Chapter 5: Ethics and Aesthetics

What is Morality? (Page 2, 134)

  • Morality deals with basic concepts like good vs. bad, right vs. wrong, duty, and obligation.

  • Moral theories vary in their interpretations and emphasis on these concepts.

  • Early views, like those of Plato and Aristotle in ancient Athens, linked the good person and the good society.

  • Their discussions covered goodness, right and wrong, justice, injustice, and character virtues/defects (courage, cowardice etc.).

  • Morality now extends to personal behavior and global concerns.

  • The capacity to see issues in moral terms may originate with the philosophical question, "What ought I to do?"

  • Infants first encounter morality unconsciously when making choices based on needs.

  • Awareness of others' interests acts as a constraint, leading to moral development.

  • Moral philosophy explores the source of moral life and grounds it theoretically.

  • Morality can be equated with established codes of behavior (Ten Commandments, Sermon on the Mount, Islamic Sunna).

  • Etymology: "ethics" (Greek ethos) and "morals" (Latin mores) are connected to customs and behavior.

  • Moral codes can be subject to moral criticism; morality searches for something with inherent substance and standing.

  • In Plato's Republic, Thrasymachus argues justice is in the interest of the strongest; similar to Marx, Nietzsche, and postmodernists.

  • Socrates argues common morality aligns with human nature, connecting morality and personal happiness.

Morality and Religion (Page 2, 134)

  • Modern secular philosophers often say religion cannot provide a basis for morality.

  • Religion depends on the moral judgment of God's goodness.

  • Founding morality on religion is seen as circular: to account for God's goodness requires prior moral conception.

  • Major religions are closely associated with systems of morality.

  • Religion involves "following" and "believing"; ethical codes are vital.

  • The question is whether individuals should follow faith precepts.

  • In a world divided by religion, people seek moral answers that cut across cultures and religions.

Plato's Republic and Moral Skepticism (Page 3, 135)

  • Plato's Republic features Socrates in fictional debates about the ideal state.

  • Thrasymachus: Justice is in the interest of the strongest, enforced by law.

  • Socrates' interlocutors suggest people would commit immoral acts if they could avoid punishment.

  • Socrates questions these assumptions, arguing justice is essential to happiness.

  • He argues moral rules align with human nature, so people don't need to choose between morality and happiness.

Sense and Reason (Page 4, 136)

  • In 18th-century England, the debate was about whether morality came from “sentiment” or “reason.