W1, L1

Introduction and Personnel Changes

  • The lecture begins with a humorous greeting to recapture audience attention and welcomes students to the "continuing delights of public law."

  • Personnel Change: Dr. John Hopkins Tenney (Ahurangi, Professor of Law) informs the class that he is taking over the course lectures from Professor Joseph.

  • There are three clues provided as to why Professor Joseph is no longer lecturing:

    • The lecturer's "dashing good licks."

    • The fact that the lecturer is "follically challenged" (bald).

    • The lecturer will not attempt to sell his own book to the students.

  • Professor Joseph has retired to "spend more time with his book."

  • Dr. John Hopkins Tenney identifies himself as a professor of public law and mentions his previous involvement in the course Laws 01/2010Laws\,01/2010.

  • Upcoming Lecturers: Dr. Tenney will be the main lecturer until the end of the year, with Jono Falwell taking a section in between.

Course Roadmap and Structure

The remainder of the course is divided into distinct sections as outlined on the updated Learn site:

  • The New Zealand Executive (Current Section): Conducted over the first 33 weeks of Term 33. This section includes a study of local government, which in New Zealand is legally considered part of the executive branch.

  • Rights: Conducted during the second 33 weeks of Term 33. Jono Falwell will lead this section, focusing on the New Zealand Bill of Rights Act and the Human Rights Act.

  • Break: A scheduled period between Term 33 and Term 44.

  • Administrative Law (Term 4): Divided into two parts:

    • Administrative Justice (Approx. 33 weeks): Focusing on non-court elements such as the Ombudsman and various tribunals.

    • Judicial Review (Final 33 weeks): The process by which courts review government actions, primarily those of the executive branch. Historically, statutes cannot be challenged in New Zealand; most legal cases discussed in public law fall under judicial review.

  • The Examination: Follows the completion of these modules.

Defining the Executive Branch and Governance

  • The lecturer asks the students to define "government" from a layperson's perspective.

  • Interaction/Question: A student suggests the government is "The Prime Minister and the Cabinet Ministers."

  • Critique: While laypeople refer to this "political executive" as the government, Dr. Tenney clarifies that the actual system of governance is much broader.

  • Etymology: The word "government" derives from the verb "to govern." The government constitutes the "people that do the governing."

  • In public law, governance is an action performed by more than just politicians; it encompasses a complex set of institutions and officials.

Baron de Montesquieu and the Theory of Separation of Powers

  • Source Material: Baron de Montesquieu’s famous book, Les Pris de Lois (The Spirit of Laws), written in the 1750s1750s.

  • Historical Context: Montesquieu, a Frenchman, opposed the absolute monarchy in France, where all power rested in the King. He argued that having too much power in one hand was dangerous and led to the oppression of civil liberties and the stifling of economic development.

  • The Three Branches of Government: Montesquieu identified three distinct sorts of power within every government:

    • The Legislative: Where the prince or magistrate enacts temporary or perpetual laws and amends or abrogates existing ones.

    • The Executive (in respect to things dependent on the law of nations): Where the leader makes peace or war, sends or receives embassies, establishes public security, and provides against invasions. Montesquieu called this the "executive power of the state."

    • The Judiciary (or executive in matters of civil law): Where the leader punishes criminals or determines disputes between individuals. Montesquieu used the term "judiciary power" for this branch.

  • Purpose of Separation: Montesquieu’s central thesis is that "All would be lost" if the same man or body (nobles or the people) exercised all three powers. Power must be separated to prevent its abuse.

The US Model vs. The New Zealand Model

  • United States Model (Classic Separation):

    • The US Constitution (the first modern written constitution) was heavily influenced by Montesquieu.

    • It features strict rules barring one branch from controlling others.

    • Members of the Legislature (Congress/Senate) cannot simultaneously be members of the Executive. If an MP is appointed to an executive role, they must resign their seat.

    • The Executive (President) is appointed through a separate process (the Electoral College). Dr. Tenney refers to the election of "a crazy orange guy" as an example of this system's outcome.

  • New Zealand Model (Fusion of Powers):

    • Based on the "Westminster model" from the United Kingdom.

    • Irony of History: Montesquieu looked to the United Kingdom as his inspiration for the separation of powers, yet he misunderstood the British system, which is actually a "fusion of powers."

    • In New Zealand, the Executive and Legislature are fused. To be a Minister or a member of the Cabinet, one must be a Member of Parliament (MP).

    • Unlike the UK, which has an unelected House of Lords to appoint outside experts as ministers, New Zealand abolished its Legislative Council in 19521952. Consequently, ministers must be chosen exclusively from the House of Representatives.

Power Dynamics and Parliamentary Sovereignty

  • Source of Power: Parliament is the ultimate source of power in New Zealand, adhering to the principle of "Parliamentary Sovereignty." The constitution can essentially be summarized in one sentence: "Parliament can do anything."

  • Reality of Power: Although Parliament is the legal source of power, the Executive is the most powerful branch in practice because it controls Parliament.

  • Public Focus: The media and public focus on the Executive (e.g., Prime Minister Luxon, Winston Peters, and David Seymour) rather than daily parliamentary proceedings. Decisions like Free Trade Agreements (e.g., with India) or navigation in the China Sea are executive decisions.

  • Parliamentary Control: Because the Executive has "the numbers" (a majority or coalition support) in Parliament, it effectively dictates what Parliament does.

Functions of the Executive

Dr. Tenney outlines three primary roles of the Executive:

1. Providing Direction
  • Using Llewellyn’s "law jobs" framework, the Executive provides the "direction" for the state (New Zealand Inc).

  • It decides policy and what the state will do on the international and domestic stage.

  • This is performed by the Political Executive (elected officials like Ministers and the Prime Minister) who are indirectly accountable to the public through Parliament.

2. Making Laws (Secondary Legislation)
  • While Parliament is the "Legislature," most laws in New Zealand are actually made by the Executive through secondary legislation.

  • Government Bills: Most statutes (primary legislation) are originally drawn up by the Executive as government bills before going to Parliament.

  • Regulations: The Executive makes regulations under the authority of a statute. In pure numbers, there are far more regulations than statutes.

  • Royal Prerogative: Residual powers of the Crown that now reside with the Executive. This allows the Executive to make decisions or laws (like treaties or war efforts) without reference to Parliament.

  • Deemed Regulations / Standards: Rules made by technical or professional bodies (e.g., building standards, fire extinguisher requirements). These were historically called "deemed regulations" because a select committee would deem them to have the impact of law even if not formally called regulations.

3. Executing Public Policy
  • The Executive implements and actions government policy.

  • This is primarily the work of the Administrative Executive, which includes:

    • Public servants (The Public Service).

    • State-Owned Enterprises (SOEsSOEs).

    • Crown entities.

    • Universities and other state bodies.

  • These entities administer the complex elements of public policy on a daily basis.