ACR assignment structure

Cover Page

  • Title: Fair Value Accounting: Relevance to Financial Reporting and Corporate Decision-Making

  • Student Name/ID

  • Module Title and Code

  • Submission Date


Introduction

  1. Context and Importance:

    • Introduce the concept of fair value accounting (FVA) and its significance in contemporary financial reporting.

    • Briefly highlight the growing emphasis by standard setters, such as IASB and FASB.

  2. Purpose:

    • Explain the aim of the essay: to critically assess the relevance of FVA in financial reporting and its implications for corporate decision-making.

  3. Thesis Statement:

    • Provide a balanced perspective, acknowledging both advantages and criticisms of FVA.

  4. Structure Overview:

    • Outline what will be covered in the essay: key debates, advantages, challenges, and implications.


Main Discussion

1. The Concept and Principles of Fair Value Accounting (Knowledge and Understanding)
  • Definition:

    • Fair value as per IFRS 13: "the price that would be received to sell an asset or paid to transfer a liability in an orderly transaction between market participants."

  • Historical Evolution:

    • Transition from historical cost accounting to fair value.

    • Key milestones in adoption by IFRS and GAAP.

  • Framework:

    • Levels of fair value measurement (observable vs. unobservable inputs).

2. Relevance of Fair Value Accounting (Knowledge and Understanding)
  • Advantages:

    • Up-to-date valuation:

      • Reflects current market conditions, enhancing relevance.

      • Cite Adwan et al. (2020): better alignment with market consensus.

    • Improved comparability:

      • Enables cross-entity comparison in globalized financial markets.

    • Investor perspective:

      • Greater transparency and decision-usefulness.

  • Critiques:

    • Volatility:

      • Income statements become less stable, reducing earnings persistence (DeFond et al., 2020).

    • Complexity:

      • Subjectivity in Level 3 measurements (McDonough et al., 2020).

    • Manipulation:

      • Management discretion in valuing illiquid assets can lead to earnings management (Landsman, 2007).

3. Fair Value Accounting During Economic Crises (Quality of Critique)
  • Case Study: The 2008 Financial Crisis

    • Role of FVA in amplifying financial instability.

    • Criticisms of “fire sale” pricing and its effect on banking sector stability (Adwan et al., 2020).

    • Counterarguments: Advocates argue FVA merely reflects underlying market weaknesses.

  • Post-crisis reforms:

    • Changes to IAS 39 and introduction of IFRS 9.

4. Implications for Corporate Decision-Making (Quality of Critique)
  • Strategic Decisions:

    • Influence of fair value adjustments on managerial performance evaluations (DeFond et al., 2020).

    • Real options: How asset valuations drive M&A and investment decisions.

  • Stakeholder Communication:

    • Enhanced clarity for investors versus potential confusion from frequent valuation changes.

  • Ethical Concerns:

    • Potential for bias and over-reliance on models in absence of active markets.

5. Broader Implications and Future Perspectives
  • Need for enhanced disclosure:

    • Suggested improvements to increase reliability and transparency (Mora et al., 2019).

  • Technological advances:

    • The role of AI and big data in refining fair value estimations.

  • Research gaps:

    • Further empirical analysis on long-term value relevance and investor behavior.


Conclusion

  1. Summary of Key Points:

    • Recap the dual-edged nature of FVA: relevance and transparency versus volatility and subjectivity.

  2. Critical Insights:

    • Balanced view on the role of FVA in financial reporting and its impact on decision-making.

  3. Future Outlook:

    • Need for evolving standards that mitigate risks without undermining relevance.


Reference List

  • Use Harvard referencing style.

  • Include all cited sources (e.g., Adwan et al., 2020; DeFond et al., 2020; Landsman, 2007; Mora et al., 2019; McDonough et al., 2020).


Key Critiques to Incorporate

  1. Volatility:

    • Frequent revaluations lead to income volatility, which can confuse investors focused on earnings stability.

  2. Subjectivity:

    • Level 3 inputs introduce managerial discretion, risking bias or manipulation.

  3. Crisis Amplification:

    • During downturns, reliance on fair value can exacerbate financial distress (e.g., fire sale pricing during 2008).

  4. Practical Limitations:

    • Difficulty in determining fair value for illiquid or specialized assets.

  5. Policy and Ethical Issues:

    • Balancing transparency with market stability.


Professional Presentation Tips

  • Formatting:

    • Use a formal font (e.g., Times New Roman, 12 pt) and consistent headings.

    • Include page numbers and 1.5 line spacing.

  • Figures/Tables:

    • Incorporate tables or graphs where relevant, properly labeled and referenced.

  • Clarity:

    • Avoid jargon and explain technical terms.

  • Word Limit:

    • Keep the essay concise, adhering to the 2,000-word limit.

This structure ensures your essay meets the marking criteria, balances knowledge with critique, and maintains professional presentation.

Case Study of FVA During Economic Crises

The case study of the 2008 financial crisis is a critical examination of how fair value accounting operates under stress. This section shows:

  • Negative Aspects:

    • FVA was criticized for amplifying financial instability because “fire sale” prices (distressed market valuations) were used to value assets. This led to:

      • Depressed valuations of financial assets.

      • Erosion of investor confidence.

      • Liquidity crises for institutions holding these assets.

  • Counterarguments:

    • FVA proponents argue it merely reflects underlying economic realities and does not create instability itself.

    • Highlight reforms made post-crisis to address these issues (e.g., IFRS 9).

This section is pivotal because it examines how FVA interacts with market dynamics, providing a nuanced critique.

Revised Structure Overview

To clarify, the revised structure would look like this:

1. Advantages of FVA
  • Relevance to investors.

  • Reflects market conditions.

  • Enhances comparability in global markets.

2. Critiques of FVA
  • Income volatility and reduced earnings persistence.

  • Complexity and subjectivity in valuation (e.g., Level 3 inputs).

  • Risk of manipulation by management.

3. FVA During Economic Crises
  • Case study of 2008 crisis to illustrate criticisms and responses.

  • Counterarguments defending FVA as a reflection of market realities.

  • Post-crisis reforms to mitigate the impact of distressed valuations.

4. Implications for Corporate Decision-Making
  • How FVA influences:

    • Strategic decisions (e.g., investments, M&A).

    • Managerial performance evaluations.

    • Stakeholder communication and ethical considerations.


This structure ensures:

  • Each point is given adequate depth and critical discussion.

  • There is no redundancy between sections.

  • The case study is used effectively to illustrate specific criticisms and counterarguments.

By organising the essay in this way, you can maintain coherence and provide a balanced critical perspective on fair value accounting.


main body: advantages and disadvantages

  • advantages?

    • what has FVA done well?

    • how well has it done those things?

    • how does this contribute to FVA’s relevance to financial reporting and corporate decision making

  • disadvantages:

    • what are the limitations of FVA? where has it fallen short?

    • are these issues caused by the method itself or could it be fixed with better rules/practices?

advantages and disadvantages?

Advantages of FVA

  1. Reflecting Market Conditions:

    • Landsman (2007) emphasizes that FVA provides real-time financial information, making it relevant and reliable for capital markets, as it reflects current market conditions better than historical cost accounting.

    • Adwan et al. (2020) argue that during crises, FVA helps maintain transparency by updating the valuation of equity book value and net income, aiding decision-making.

  2. Investor Decision Usefulness:

    • Hitz (2007) highlights FVA’s superiority in supporting investor decisions by offering relevant and comparable financial data.

    • DeFond et al. (2020) note that fair value enhances the performance evaluation role of earnings, ensuring that financial reports align more closely with investor expectations.

  3. Global Standardization:

    • Barlev and Haddad (2007) suggest that FVA supports international harmonization of accounting standards, which improves comparability across borders.

  4. Applicability to Financial Instruments:

    • McDonough et al. (2020) detail that FVA is particularly well-suited for valuing financial instruments like derivatives, where historical cost is irrelevant.


Disadvantages of FVA

  1. Earnings Volatility:

    • Adwan et al. (2020) critique FVA for increasing income volatility, which can make earnings less predictable and reduce their reliability as a valuation metric.

  2. Subjectivity and Managerial Bias:

    • Landsman (2007) raises concerns about Level 3 measurements, which rely on unobservable inputs and management assumptions, increasing the risk of bias or manipulation.

    • McDonough et al. (2020) similarly point out the limitations of fair value in illiquid markets where observable prices are unavailable.

  3. Practical Challenges:

    • Sellhorn and Stier (2019) argue that implementing FVA is costly and complex, particularly for non-financial assets.

    • Maroun and van Zijl (2022) discuss resistance to FVA due to epistemic challenges, especially when hypothetical market values clash with operational realities.

  4. Impact During Financial Crises:

    • Mora et al. (2019) highlight that FVA can amplify the effects of financial crises by forcing asset write-downs based on distressed market prices.

  5. Limited Reliability for Non-Financial Assets:

    • McDonough et al. (2020) critique FVA's applicability to non-financial assets, as these often lack active markets to provide reliable fair value measures.

Connections Between Advantages and Disadvantages

  1. Reflection of Market Conditions ↔ Earnings Volatility:

    • The advantage of reflecting current market conditions (Adwan et al., Landsman) is directly linked to the disadvantage of earnings volatility (Adwan et al.). Real-time updates enhance transparency but can destabilize reported earnings, especially during market fluctuations or crises.

  2. Investor Decision Usefulness ↔ Subjectivity and Bias:

    • The decision-usefulness of FVA (Hitz, DeFond et al.) is sometimes undermined by subjective inputs in Level 3 valuations (Landsman, McDonough). While investors benefit from relevant data, the reliability of this data can be questioned when observable market data is unavailable.

  3. Applicability to Financial Instruments ↔ Crises Amplification:

    • FVA's strength in valuing financial instruments (McDonough et al.) is also tied to its role in amplifying crises (Mora et al.). During financial downturns, marking assets to distressed market values can exaggerate losses, impacting stakeholders.

  4. Global Standardization ↔ Practical Challenges:

    • The push for global comparability (Barlev and Haddad) increases the implementation complexity (Sellhorn and Stier). Establishing fair value measures for diverse asset classes globally is resource-intensive and faces resistance in regions with different market dynamics.

point 1.2 - earnings volatility

How the Points Are Related

Fair Value Accounting (FVA) reflects current market conditions by updating asset and liability valuations to match real-time prices. This transparency is highly beneficial as it gives stakeholders a clear picture of a company’s financial health. However, this same feature can lead to earnings volatility. Since FVA values assets and liabilities based on fluctuating market prices, these changes can cause dramatic swings in reported earnings. For instance, in a market downturn, asset values may drop sharply, reducing earnings significantly, even if the company’s operational performance remains stable.

What is Earnings Volatility and Why is it Bad?

Earnings volatility refers to the degree to which a company’s reported profits vary over time. *insert quote to back* Under FVA, this can happen frequently because market prices constantly change due to external factors like interest rates, inflation, or investor sentiment. “which is influenced by the economic and operational risk."

  • "Bank earnings calculated using fair value estimates of investment securities gains and losses are significantly more volatile than earnings calculated using historical cost securities gains and losses. The standard deviation in earnings computed using fair values is 26 percent greater than that of historical cost earnings for the median bank over the 20-year sample period."

Why It’s Problematic:

  1. Unpredictability: Investors and analysts prefer stable earnings as they signal consistent performance. Volatile earnings make it harder to assess a company’s true financial health and future prospects.

    1. "High earning volatility in a firm infers uncertainty about the business future and shows a high risk for creditors. Creditors refrain from allocating credits for firms whose operations are accompanied by high volatility."

  2. Misleading Representation: Volatility might not reflect operational performance but rather temporary market fluctuations. This could mislead stakeholders about a company’s core stability.

  3. Impact on Decision-Making: Frequent changes in earnings due to FVA might lead investors and management to make short-term decisions to counteract the appearance of instability.


Can Earnings Volatility Be Fixed?

Earnings volatility is partly innate to FVA, but better rules and practices can mitigate its impact:

  1. Innate Aspects of FVA:

    • Volatility stems from FVA’s reliance on real-time market prices, which are inherently unstable. This means some level of earnings fluctuation is unavoidable.

    • Financial instruments like derivatives are particularly susceptible to price swings, amplifying the effect.

  2. Fixable Aspects Through Rules/Practices:

    • Improved Disclosures: Providing more detailed breakdowns of valuation methods (e.g., Levels 1, 2, and 3) can help users understand which values are market-based and which are estimates.

    • Earnings Smoothing Techniques: Adjusting accounting practices to segregate temporary market swings from core operational earnings can make reports less volatile.

    • Use of Mixed Measurement Models: Allowing some assets to remain at historical cost while others are marked to fair value could reduce unnecessary volatility.

Sources Supporting These Points:

  1. Adwan et al. (2020):

    • Highlights how FVA’s real-time updates provide transparency but also result in earnings instability during crises.

    • Source: Fair value accounting and value relevance of equity book value and net income for European financial firms during crisis.

  2. Landsman (2007):

    • Discusses how FVA reflects market conditions but cautions about the impact on earnings due to market price volatility.

    • Source: Is fair value accounting information relevant and reliable? Evidence from capital market research.

  3. Benston (2008):

    • Examines how FVA-induced earnings volatility can misrepresent a company’s performance and lead to investor confusion.

    • Source: The Shortcomings of Fair Value Accounting According to SFAS 157.

  4. Linsmeier (2011):

    • Argues for improved FVA disclosures to address volatility concerns and enhance transparency for users.

    • Source: Financial Reporting and Financial Crises: The Case for Measuring Financial Instruments at Fair Value.

point 2

This misleading representation of a company’s operational performance might lead investors and managers to make decisions that aren’t in the best interest of the organisation.

  1. Investor Decision Usefulness ↔ Subjectivity and Bias:

    • The decision-usefulness of FVA (Hitz, DeFond et al.) is sometimes undermined by subjective inputs in Level 3 valuations (Landsman, McDonough). While investors benefit from relevant data, the reliability of this data can be questioned when observable market data is unavailable.

investor decision usefulness:

What is Decision Usefulness?

Decision usefulness is a fundamental objective of financial reporting. It means providing information that helps users—like investors, creditors, and other stakeholders—make informed decisions about allocating resources. For financial information to be decision-useful, it must be relevant, reliable, comparable, and understandable. Decision usefulness is central to accounting frameworks such as the IFRS Conceptual Framework and U.S. GAAP.


How Has FVA Achieved Decision Usefulness?

Fair Value Accounting (FVA) achieves decision usefulness by:

  1. Relevance:

    • FVA ensures financial statements reflect current market conditions by valuing assets and liabilities at their fair market prices. This provides real-time data that is more meaningful to users compared to historical cost accounting, which relies on outdated purchase prices.

      • FVA serves as a vital tool to accurately value assets and liabilities, ensuring financial stability and enhancing investor confidence by providing stakeholders with transparent and relevant financial information essential for decision-making.” (p. 343)

      • For example, financial instruments like derivatives are highly sensitive to market conditions, and FVA ensures their valuations reflect actual risks and potential returns. [PUT INTO CHATGPT]

  2. Reliability:

    • Although critics argue that unobservable inputs (Level 3 valuations) may reduce reliability, FVA includes robust frameworks for disclosures about valuation methods. This transparency increases user confidence in reported figures.

    • “The findings underscore the positive impact of FVA on EQ in both the banking and real estate sectors of Jordan, particularly in EQ measurement. This indicates that firms using FVA techniques in these industries enhance the accuracy and reliability of their EQ.” (p. 359)

      Comparability and Consistency:

    • By adhering to standardized fair value measurement levels (Level 1, 2, and 3), FVA enhances comparability across companies and industries, aiding stakeholders in making consistent evaluations.


Why is Decision Usefulness Good?

  1. Improved Investment Decisions:

    • Investors rely on decision-useful data to evaluate a company's performance, risks, and future potential. FVA helps them assess whether a company is overvalued or undervalued based on market realities.

  2. Enhanced Risk Assessment:

    • By incorporating real-time market data, FVA allows stakeholders to understand a company’s exposure to risks like interest rate changes, credit defaults, or market downturns. This supports informed resource allocation.

  3. Transparency:

    • Decision-useful information aligns with stakeholders’ needs for transparency. FVA provides clarity on financial conditions, particularly in dynamic markets or economic crises.


How Does Decision Usefulness Contribute to FVA's Relevance?

  1. Relevance to Financial Reporting:

    • Financial reports that incorporate fair value are more relevant because they provide an accurate snapshot of a company’s current economic standing. This is essential for stakeholders needing up-to-date information to make time-sensitive decisions.

    • For example, during financial crises, FVA reflects market downturns in real time, giving regulators and investors a clearer understanding of the situation (Adwan et al., 2020).

  2. Relevance to Corporate Decision-Making:

    • For internal decision-making, FVA enables management to base strategic plans on actual market conditions. This could involve better capital allocation, pricing strategies, or risk mitigation efforts.

    • Transparent reporting also builds trust with investors and other stakeholders, improving access to capital and reducing uncertainty in corporate decision-making.


Summary

Decision usefulness is at the heart of why FVA is considered an improvement over traditional accounting methods like historical cost. By providing timely, relevant, and reliable information, FVA aligns with the needs of both external users (like investors) and internal decision-makers (like corporate managers). This makes FVA highly relevant to modern financial reporting and ensures it remains a cornerstone for evaluating corporate performance and guiding resource allocation.

point 2:

subjectivity and bias:
What is Subjectivity Bias?

Subjectivity bias arises when judgments or decisions are influenced by personal opinions, preferences, or assumptions rather than objective facts or data. In financial reporting, this bias often manifests when individuals (e.g., management or valuers) rely on their own estimates or models to determine values in the absence of observable data.

This bias can lead to variability in valuations because different individuals might interpret or estimate the same scenario differently. It is particularly problematic in areas where significant judgment is required, such as Level 3 valuations under Fair Value Accounting (FVA).


How is Subjectivity Bias Related to Investor Decision Usefulness in FVA?

In the context of FVA, subjectivity bias is directly related to investor decision usefulness because it impacts two critical components of financial information:

  1. Relevance: FVA is praised for providing timely, market-reflective information that enhances decision-making. However, when subjectivity bias influences valuations, it can reduce the relevance of the information for investors if the estimates do not accurately reflect economic reality.

  2. Reliability: Investors rely on financial statements to make informed decisions. Subjectivity bias undermines this reliability because valuations may reflect managerial discretion, assumptions, or errors rather than verifiable market data.

For example:

  • In Level 3 valuations, where unobservable inputs like discounted cash flows or growth assumptions are used, the absence of external checks introduces significant room for subjectivity bias.

  • This bias can lead to over- or underestimation of asset values, distorting key financial ratios and leading investors to make decisions based on potentially flawed information.

Thus, while FVA's goal is to enhance decision usefulness, subjectivity bias can compromise the reliability of the reported figures, making decisions riskier or less informed.


Why is Subjectivity and Bias Bad?

Subjectivity and bias are problematic in FVA for several reasons:

  1. Decreased Reliability: Financial information that lacks reliability cannot be trusted by stakeholders, undermining their ability to compare or analyze data across companies or periods.

  2. Manipulation Risk: Subjectivity allows for potential manipulation of financial outcomes, where management might adjust assumptions to meet targets or present a more favorable financial position.

  3. Market Inefficiencies: When investors base their decisions on biased or subjective information, it can lead to misallocations of capital, contributing to market inefficiencies and potentially increasing systemic risks.

  4. Stakeholder Distrust: Persistent subjectivity reduces confidence in financial reporting, damaging the credibility of companies and the accounting profession.


Is Subjectivity and Bias Innate to FVA, or Can It Be Fixed?

Subjectivity and bias are not inherently innate to FVA but are inherent to its application when observable data is unavailable. The framework itself emphasizes the use of market-based inputs (Level 1 and Level 2) and only resorts to subjective inputs (Level 3) when necessary. However, there are ways to mitigate these issues:

Mitigating Subjectivity and Bias:
  1. Enhanced Disclosures: Requiring detailed disclosure of valuation methods, assumptions, and sensitivity analyses (as FVA standards do) reduces opacity and provides investors with insights into the valuation process.

  2. Auditor Scrutiny: Independent audits can help ensure that assumptions are reasonable and consistent with industry practices, reducing the risk of bias or manipulation.

  3. Standardized Assumptions: Industry-wide guidelines for unobservable inputs (e.g., discount rates) can limit variability and introduce consistency.

  4. Technology and Models: Advanced valuation models, machine learning, or AI could minimize human error and subjective discretion by applying consistent algorithms across firms.

  5. Regulatory Oversight: Close monitoring by regulatory bodies ensures compliance with fair value standards and prevents opportunistic behavior.


Conclusion

Subjectivity and bias in FVA can challenge its decision-usefulness for investors, particularly in Level 3 valuations. While these issues are not intrinsic to FVA itself, they are inherent to the use of unobservable inputs in financial reporting. The extent of these challenges can be mitigated through transparency, independent verification, standardized practices, and technological advancements. However, fully eliminating bias in subjective judgments may remain impractical, making it essential for investors to critically assess the robustness of disclosed assumptions


point 4:

Merged Point Title:

FVA's Role in Financial Crises: Applicability and Amplification

Content Structure for the Paragraph:
  1. Introduction:

    • Briefly introduce FVA's applicability to financial instruments, emphasizing its strength in providing market-reflective valuations.

    • Transition into the potential downside: its role in amplifying crises during economic downturns.

  2. Case Study of the 2008 Financial Crisis:

    • Use the 2008 crisis as a concrete example to demonstrate how marking assets to market values during distress amplified financial losses and instability.

    • Highlight Mora et al.'s argument that distressed market values exaggerated asset devaluations, causing systemic impacts.

  3. Criticism of FVA:

    • Explain stakeholder concerns, including the impact of downward spirals caused by distressed valuations on capital adequacy and market confidence.

    • Introduce the criticism that FVA amplifies crises by perpetuating "fire sales" and asset undervaluations.

  4. Counterarguments in Defense of FVA:

    • Present McDonough et al.'s defense that FVA reflects market realities and ensures transparency during financial instability, enabling more informed decision-making.

    • Argue that market volatility exists regardless of accounting standards, and FVA simply highlights existing risks.

  5. Post-Crisis Reforms:

    • Discuss how reforms, such as additional disclosures and guidance for distressed asset valuations, were introduced to mitigate FVA's impact during crises.

    • Show how these changes maintain FVA’s benefits while addressing criticisms.

introduction:

Fair Value Accounting (FVA) is widely recognised for its strength in valuing financial instruments, offering market-reflective valuations that enhance transparency and decision usefulness for stakeholders. For instance, when considering instruments like derivatives, which derive their value from other assets such as stock prices or commodities, FVA ensures their valuation accurately reflects their current market worth. On the other hand, illiquid instruments, which lack an active market, rely on valuation models such as discounted cash flows to estimate their value.

for example, if we were to consider instruments like derivatives, as they depend on the values of other assets [e.g. stock prices or commodities], FVA ensures their valuation mirrors their current market worth. illiquid instruments, however, have no active market and therefore use models like discounted cash flows to estimate their value.


By aligning asset values with current market conditions, FVA provides a dynamic approach to financial reporting that is particularly relevant in volatile markets. However, this same characteristic can become a potential weakness during economic downturns. Critics argue that marking assets to market in distressed conditions can amplify financial crises, as depressed asset prices may lead to exaggerated losses, eroding stakeholder confidence and destabilising the broader financial system.


The 2008 Financial Crisis serves as a critical example of how marking assets to market values during economic distress can amplify financial losses and systemic instability. Under Fair Value Accounting (FVA), financial institutions were required to mark assets, such as mortgage-backed securities, to distressed market prices, reflecting fire-sale conditions rather than intrinsic value. This practice led to significant devaluations on balance sheets, triggering capital adequacy concerns and forcing further asset sales, which perpetuated a downward spiral in asset prices and market confidence. Mora et al. (2012) argue that these distressed valuations exaggerated losses and created feedback loops that destabilized the financial system. Bowen et al. (2010) further emphasize that FVA's transparency was questioned during illiquid market conditions, as it failed to provide reliable valuations under extreme stress.


Despite these criticisms, proponents of Fair Value Accounting (FVA) argue that its benefits outweigh its potential drawbacks, particularly in its ability to provide a transparent and market-aligned reflection of financial realities. McDonough et al. (2024) argue that FVA provides a realistic portrayal of financial positions by aligning asset values with market conditions, enabling stakeholders to make informed decisions based on transparent and relevant data. Moreover, critics of FVA often conflate market volatility with accounting standards; however, as highlighted by Venky Nagar et al. (2023), such volatility is intrinsic to financial markets and would persist irrespective of the accounting framework. Proponents contend that FVA does not create instability but rather reveals underlying risks, helping investors and regulators identify and address financial weaknesses more effectively.


Despite these criticisms, proponents of Fair Value Accounting (FVA) argue that its benefits outweigh its potential drawbacks, particularly in its ability to provide a transparent and market-aligned reflection of financial realities.McDonough et al. (2024) assert that FVA enables stakeholders to better assess financial risks and opportunities by aligning asset values with actual market conditions, even during periods of instability. This perspective challenges the notion that FVA amplifies volatility, instead emphasizing its role in revealing inherent market risks that would exist regardless of the accounting framework.