Study Notes for Lesson 3: Get Attention

Lesson 3: Get Attention

Outline

  • Getting Attention

    • General Lessons

    • Attracting Traditional Media

    • Better Attention – Not All Attention is Golden

    • Connecting – and Disconnecting – Issues

    • Separable and Non-Separable Preferences

Many Posts; Few Go Viral

  • There are social media stars, including:

    • Political social media stars

    • Social media stars who provide political and non-profit/social change commentary

  • In the United States, some candidates have gained prominence by crafting biographical videos that attract national attention.

  • Few social media stars enter politics as established stars; running for office often raises their social media visibility.

  • Most “stars” in social media also enjoy visibility in traditional media outlets.

Need a Good Story

  • Attention, particularly sustained attention, hinges on a compelling narrative.

    • A narrative must be engaging and easy to follow.

  • Some argue that issue dimensions previously discussed depend on whether the competing dominant narratives emphasize ideological perspectives.

  • “Virtue-signaling identity politics” suggests a narrative about politics and politicians that tends to yield strong narratives.

Good Story, Good News!

  • The media require campaigns to boost readership, clicks, or viewership; they provide opportunities to share stories without charge.

  • Media is particularly attracted to stories that are:

    • New/Novel/Unusual

    • Involve conflict

    • Narratives highlighting a problem that the government creates or exacerbates

    • Include celebrities

Media Are Their Own Players

  • The media strives not to appear manipulated nor to show bias towards any side (with a few exceptions in tabloid journalism).

  • Journalistic norms maintain a separation between news and editorial decisions.

  • It is critical to note:

    • Nothing is considered off the record.

    • Reporters face strict limitations regarding story length and deadlines.

  • Follow-up coverage may occur.

  • Creative approaches can be newsworthy and attract attention.

Gains to Being Creative

  • Creativity leads to:

    • Original story coverage

    • Attraction of follow-up story coverage and discussions (i.e. “water cooler” conversations)

    • Even negative media coverage can function as an asset

Understand the Media Cycle

  • Important to know:

    • Newspaper deadlines for next-day stories or online articles

    • When listeners tune into radio news

    • Viewing patterns for television news

    • When live TV news coverage typically occurs

    • When reports are due from journalists

Just Plain Attention Is Not Golden

  • Attention must not be superficial; for example:

    • Referring to the mayoral candidate, Sarah Thomson, who was on horseback.

  • It is essential to make a winning issue dimension salient or to strategically (un-)link two dimensions for benefit.

Question I:

  • Who supports building a subway connecting Scarborough and Downtown?

Question II:

  • Who desires to live in an area that is quiet, sunny, and features ample green spaces?

Subways and Green Spaces

  • Consider the scenario where a cost-effective subway requires dense residential and/or commercial development near the subway line.

    • This is almost always the case:

    • Subways necessitate a high volume of riders for cost-efficiency

    • Proposals for public-private partnerships to finance subways generally assume the private sector will fund the subway to stimulate demand for new high-rise developments.

  • How might proponents of the subway be convinced that it is a poor idea?

Warren Magnuson

  • What was the issue at stake?

  • Who opposed the issue as it was initially framed?

  • What was the anticipated outcome of the voting process?

  • What actions did Magnuson take? How did he redefine the debate?

  • Who supported Magnuson’s stance after he reframed the debate?

Learning from Magnuson

  • Magnuson made certain concerns or attributes relevant that had not previously been considered.

  • In essence, Magnuson increased the salience of various dimensions by rephrasing the question.

  • He also connected two issues that were not previously viewed as associated.

Context

  • Evaluating specific attributes can be easier with comparisons.

  • The context (isolation vs. comparison) can render certain choice attributes more salient or relevant (in the manner of Magnuson).

    • Example: EnergyStar/EnerGuide (link to: http://oee.nrcan.gc.ca/energuide/home.cfm)

  • Similar to candidates’ efforts to highlight differences with their opponents or underscore particular strengths from their biographies.

Graphical Theory

  • Two issues of equal importance:

    • Represented with concentric circles stemming from an ideal point (or concave indifference curves moving away from maximization).

  • If one issue is deemed more important, minor deviations from the ideal prompt a much greater dissatisfaction than equivalent shifts in the other issue dimension.

    • These are illustrated with ellipses rather than circles.

  • The ellipses tilt when preferences are non-separable.

Two Issues, Equal Importance

  • Indifference curves depicted with the ideal point at the origin (center).

  • As you move further from the origin, overall satisfaction decreases.

  • Choice presentation:

    • Do you prefer A or B?

    • Options: A, B

Two Issues, Horizontal Dimension More Important

  • In a scenario where the horizontal dimension is prioritized,

    • A is preferred over B simply because A is closer to the ideal curve.

    • Visual representation:

    • A

    • B

Separable Preferences

  • A situation where one desires a balanced budget while also advocating for increased educational spending.

    • In voting behavior, one can vote for a balanced budget AND support increased educational expenditure.

    • The order of preferences does not affect the outcome.

Non-Separable Preferences

  • An individual wanting both a balanced budget and more funding for education illustrates non-separable preferences.

    • If the legislature first enacts a tax cut, this individual may oppose increased educational spending.

    • Conversely, if educational funding is increased first, they may oppose the tax cut.

    • The order of policy enactment MATTERS significantly.

Tilt the Curves for Non-Separable Preferences

  • Assume the vertical dimension is fixed at -1.

    • At which level of horizontal policy will this individual find maximum happiness when vertical is set to -1?

    • Identified at the blue star position, indicating the lowest indifference curve (closest to the ideal point).

Summary

  • Understanding media dynamics is crucial for garnering attention.

  • Creativity and an awareness of the news cycle are essential tools.

  • Not all forms of attention are beneficial.

    • The optimal attention amplifies a dimension’s salience (particularly for challengers) or strategically links/unlinks dimensions.

  • When multiple dimensions are linked, actors exhibit non-separable preferences.