Study Notes for Lesson 3: Get Attention
Lesson 3: Get Attention
Outline
Getting Attention
General Lessons
Attracting Traditional Media
Better Attention – Not All Attention is Golden
Connecting – and Disconnecting – Issues
Separable and Non-Separable Preferences
Many Posts; Few Go Viral
There are social media stars, including:
Political social media stars
Social media stars who provide political and non-profit/social change commentary
In the United States, some candidates have gained prominence by crafting biographical videos that attract national attention.
Few social media stars enter politics as established stars; running for office often raises their social media visibility.
Most “stars” in social media also enjoy visibility in traditional media outlets.
Need a Good Story
Attention, particularly sustained attention, hinges on a compelling narrative.
A narrative must be engaging and easy to follow.
Some argue that issue dimensions previously discussed depend on whether the competing dominant narratives emphasize ideological perspectives.
“Virtue-signaling identity politics” suggests a narrative about politics and politicians that tends to yield strong narratives.
Good Story, Good News!
The media require campaigns to boost readership, clicks, or viewership; they provide opportunities to share stories without charge.
Media is particularly attracted to stories that are:
New/Novel/Unusual
Involve conflict
Narratives highlighting a problem that the government creates or exacerbates
Include celebrities
Media Are Their Own Players
The media strives not to appear manipulated nor to show bias towards any side (with a few exceptions in tabloid journalism).
Journalistic norms maintain a separation between news and editorial decisions.
It is critical to note:
Nothing is considered off the record.
Reporters face strict limitations regarding story length and deadlines.
Follow-up coverage may occur.
Creative approaches can be newsworthy and attract attention.
Gains to Being Creative
Creativity leads to:
Original story coverage
Attraction of follow-up story coverage and discussions (i.e. “water cooler” conversations)
Even negative media coverage can function as an asset
Understand the Media Cycle
Important to know:
Newspaper deadlines for next-day stories or online articles
When listeners tune into radio news
Viewing patterns for television news
When live TV news coverage typically occurs
When reports are due from journalists
Just Plain Attention Is Not Golden
Attention must not be superficial; for example:
Referring to the mayoral candidate, Sarah Thomson, who was on horseback.
It is essential to make a winning issue dimension salient or to strategically (un-)link two dimensions for benefit.
Question I:
Who supports building a subway connecting Scarborough and Downtown?
Question II:
Who desires to live in an area that is quiet, sunny, and features ample green spaces?
Subways and Green Spaces
Consider the scenario where a cost-effective subway requires dense residential and/or commercial development near the subway line.
This is almost always the case:
Subways necessitate a high volume of riders for cost-efficiency
Proposals for public-private partnerships to finance subways generally assume the private sector will fund the subway to stimulate demand for new high-rise developments.
How might proponents of the subway be convinced that it is a poor idea?
Warren Magnuson
What was the issue at stake?
Who opposed the issue as it was initially framed?
What was the anticipated outcome of the voting process?
What actions did Magnuson take? How did he redefine the debate?
Who supported Magnuson’s stance after he reframed the debate?
Learning from Magnuson
Magnuson made certain concerns or attributes relevant that had not previously been considered.
In essence, Magnuson increased the salience of various dimensions by rephrasing the question.
He also connected two issues that were not previously viewed as associated.
Context
Evaluating specific attributes can be easier with comparisons.
The context (isolation vs. comparison) can render certain choice attributes more salient or relevant (in the manner of Magnuson).
Example: EnergyStar/EnerGuide (link to: http://oee.nrcan.gc.ca/energuide/home.cfm)
Similar to candidates’ efforts to highlight differences with their opponents or underscore particular strengths from their biographies.
Graphical Theory
Two issues of equal importance:
Represented with concentric circles stemming from an ideal point (or concave indifference curves moving away from maximization).
If one issue is deemed more important, minor deviations from the ideal prompt a much greater dissatisfaction than equivalent shifts in the other issue dimension.
These are illustrated with ellipses rather than circles.
The ellipses tilt when preferences are non-separable.
Two Issues, Equal Importance
Indifference curves depicted with the ideal point at the origin (center).
As you move further from the origin, overall satisfaction decreases.
Choice presentation:
Do you prefer A or B?
Options: A, B
Two Issues, Horizontal Dimension More Important
In a scenario where the horizontal dimension is prioritized,
A is preferred over B simply because A is closer to the ideal curve.
Visual representation:
A
B
Separable Preferences
A situation where one desires a balanced budget while also advocating for increased educational spending.
In voting behavior, one can vote for a balanced budget AND support increased educational expenditure.
The order of preferences does not affect the outcome.
Non-Separable Preferences
An individual wanting both a balanced budget and more funding for education illustrates non-separable preferences.
If the legislature first enacts a tax cut, this individual may oppose increased educational spending.
Conversely, if educational funding is increased first, they may oppose the tax cut.
The order of policy enactment MATTERS significantly.
Tilt the Curves for Non-Separable Preferences
Assume the vertical dimension is fixed at -1.
At which level of horizontal policy will this individual find maximum happiness when vertical is set to -1?
Identified at the blue star position, indicating the lowest indifference curve (closest to the ideal point).
Summary
Understanding media dynamics is crucial for garnering attention.
Creativity and an awareness of the news cycle are essential tools.
Not all forms of attention are beneficial.
The optimal attention amplifies a dimension’s salience (particularly for challengers) or strategically links/unlinks dimensions.
When multiple dimensions are linked, actors exhibit non-separable preferences.