Theories of Consciousness
Consciousness is hard to measure and define.
Many theories try to explain consciousness, but none fully capture all its aspects.
Integrated Information Theory of Consciousness
Consciousness can be described as having different levels.
IIT proposes that consciousness arises from integrating information in the brain.
The more interconnected and complex brain activity is, the “higher“ the level of consciousness.
Are awake, dreaming, deep sleep, and drug-induced states different levels of one thing?
IIT suggests these states have different degrees of consciousness:
Awake: high integration → vivid experience.
Dreaming (REM): some integration → vivid, but disconnected from reality.
Deep sleep (non-REM): low integration → minimal or no conscious experience.
Drug-induced: altered integration → psychedelics increase connectivity, or anesthesia decreases connectivity.
It’s hard to measure integration directly.
Doesn’t fully explain why some brain networks produce consciousness while others don’t.
Global Workspace Theory of Consciousness
Changes in consciousness involve alertness and wakefulness.
GWT compares consciousness to a “theater stage“ where only certain information is “in the spotlight“ at any time.
Examples:
Awake: Information is shared efficiently. → clear consciousness.
Sleep/dreaming: limited workspace access → fragmented or altered consciousness.
Drugs: disrupts workspace communication → loss or distortion of consciousness.
Doesn’t fully explain subjective experience.
Focuses more on access to information than on the nature of consciousness itself.
Key Differences Between the Two Theories
Integrated information (IIT): consciousness = complexity of brain connections.
Global workspace (GWT): consciousness = information sharing in the brain.
Default Mode Network
The brain is active even when it’s not actively doing anything.
When daydreaming or letting your mind wander, your brain isn’t “off,“ it’s running the DMN.
The DMN is the brain’s baseline rate when not engaged externally.
Unlike task-focused networks (e.g., solving math problems), the DMN is most active during restful introspection.
Functions:
Mind-wandering and creativity.
Reflecting on yourself and others.
Consolidating memories, such as replaying the day’s events during rest.
Default Mode Network Brain Regions
Prefrontal cortex: self-referential thoughts (“what do I think about this?“) and future planning (“what should I do tomorrow?“).
Posterior cingulate cortex: memory integration (linking past experiences to the present) and emotional processing (reflecting on personal feelings).
Angular gyrus: language (understanding metaphors) and mental time travel (imagining past/future scenarios).
Bremer’s Work
Sleep is a behavior, not the absence of behavior.
Before Bremer, some scientists thought this, similar to a computer turning off.
Bremer’s research showed that the brainstem actively generates sleep.
By studying cat brains, lesions between the spinal cord and brainstem displayed a normal sleep-wake cycle.
While lesions disconnecting the forebrain from the brainstem put the cat into a permanent sleep-like state (no wakefulness).
Sleep Function #1: Memory Consolidation
While sleeping, the brain organizes and solidifies new information, transferring it from short-term to long-term storage.
When songbirds sleep, their brains reactivate the same neural patterns from when they practiced songs while awake.
Sleep isn’t passive, it’s offline practice.
Real-world examples:
Cramming vs Sleep: Pulling an all-nighter? Without sleep, the brain cannot consolidate the material effectively.
Skill Mastery: Athletes and musicians improve faster with quality sleep because of “neural rehearsal.“
Disorders: Poor REM sleep is linked to memory deficits such as Alzheimer’s Disease.
Hippocampal activity spikes during REM.
The hippocampus “replays” the day’s events for storage.
More learning = more REM sleep.
For example, medical students in exam periods show longer REM phases.
Wake: Learn song → Hippocampus encodes
↓
Sleep: Neural replay → Strengthen connections
↓
Next day: Better performance
Sleep Function #2: Energy Conservation
Humans sleep to conserve energy; sleep reduces energy use by lowering metabolism when activity is inefficient.
Species that sleep more have higher metabolic rates:
Elephants → slow metabolism → very short sleep duration.
Bats → high metabolism → very long sleep duration.
As we age, metabolism goes down, so does the amount of sleep.
Children → high metabolism → more deep sleep.
Elderly → slow metabolism → less deep sleep, more fragmented sleep.
Other Proposed Functions
Brain development in children and teens.
Sleep may be a safe place to discharge emotions and relieve stress.
Possibly needed for physical health.
Deep sleep is when human growth hormone is released in children and teens.
Stages of Sleep
Slow Wave Sleep Stage 1:
Stage 1: transitional phase.
Alpha wavjes: when eyes are closed and relaxed.
Theta waves: when you start to drift off.
Beta waves.
Jerks and twitches, easily awakened, muscle tone relaxes.
Slow Wave Sleep Stage 2:
Stage 2: true sleep begins.
Theta waves.
K complexes in stage 2 (high-voltage spikes).
Response to environmental stimuli, such as filtering noise.
Slow Wave Sleep Stages 3-4:
Stages 3-4: deep sleep.
Mostly delta waves.
Hard to awaken, growth hormone release, body repair occurs.
REM Sleep:
Beta waves: similar to wakefulness.
Theta waves: hippocampal activity.
Muscle atonia (paralysis), dreaming, and memory consolidation.
The Progression Of Sleep Stages At Night
The first 4 hours of sleep are slow-wave sleep-dominated for physical restoration.
The second 4 hours of sleep are REM-dominated for memory and emotional processing.
Each REM episode occurs every 90-120 minutes.
Locus Coeruleus (Pons)
Lower-level structure.
Linked to norepinephrine network.
Activity linked to wakefulness.
Acts as the brain’s alarm system.
Raphe Nuclei (Pons)
Lower-level structure.
Serotonergic network—linked to serotonin.
Activity seems to be linked to slow-wave sleep.
For example, SSRIs increase deep sleep.
Gigantocellular Tegmental Field (Pons)
Acetylcholine-based.
Activity linked to REM sleep.
Originates PGO waves (Ponto-Geniculo Occipital) that occur with eye movements.
Preoptic Area Of The Hypothalamus
Higher level structure.
Receives serotonin (increases deep sleep) from the raphe nuclei.
Releases GABA to inhibit wakefulness structures.
Initiates sleep.
Posterior Hypothalamus
Higher level structure.
The area inhibited by the preoptic area that initiates sleep.
Stimulates cortical arousal; keeps you awake.
Suprachiasmatic Nucleus (SCN)—Circadian Rhythms
The SCN is the likely center of circadian rhythms, the body’s 24-hour biological clock.
Retinohypothalamic tract sends information to the SCN.
This allows for light to play a role.
Light exposure resets the SCN, aligning sleep/wake cycles with day and night.
This explains why bright light at night delays sleep, such as phone screens.
SCN transplants transfer rhythms.
Normal hamsters with 24-hour rhythms were given SCNs of hamsters bred with 20-hour cycles.
The recipient hamsters adopted the 20-hour cycle of the donor hamsters!
Suprachiasmatic Nucleus (SCN)—Internal Clock
The SCN is active during the day in diurnal and nocturnal animals.
It seems to tell animals whether it is day or night, but does not directly drive wake-sleep behaviors.
Linked to the pineal gland.
Secretes melatonin → promotes sleepiness.
Genetic links to SCN:
Light triggers the fluctuation of some proteins.
Increasing and decreasing various proteins lead to sleep/wake cycles.
Homeostatic Debt
Sleep pressure builds while you’re awake until you need sleep.
Sleep pressure decreases while asleep.
Glycogen produces ATP, which is an energy source as well as a reserve.
As the brain uses energy, ATP breaks down into adenosine.
Increased adenosine levels lead to slow-wave sleep.
Adenosine inhibits wakefulness structures.
Glycogen levels build up during slow-wave sleep.
Insomnia
A persistent disorder characterized by difficulty falling asleep, trouble staying asleep, and non-restorative sleep.
Usually treated with GABA agonists (Benzodiazepines) or melatonin agonists.
Sleep Apnea
A disorder characterized by repeated interruptions in breathing during sleep.
Obstructive Apnea: physical obstruction of the airway during sleep.
Overweight, alcohol/sedative use, anatomical issues.
Central Apnea: brain fails to send signals to breathe, causing pauses in respiratory effort.
Narcolepsy
Excessive daytime sleepiness, cataplexy, paralysis, and hallucinations.
Cataplexy: sudden, brief loss of voluntary muscle tone, ranging from mild drooping to full-body collapsing.
Enters REM sleep at inappropriate times.
Both throughout the day and nighttime cycles.
Causes Of Narcolepsy
Low hypocretin levels are possibly due to autoimmune issues.
Hypocretin promotes wakefulness.
Genetic link is possible.
Brain injuries to REM and wakefulness areas.
Circadian Rhythm Disorders
When the SCN’s timing doesn’t match societal/work schedules (night shifts) or natural light-dark cycles (jet lag).
Advanced Sleep-Wake Phase Disorder
When the SCN runs shorter than 24 hours → body clock is ahead of the environment.
When one falls asleep topo early and wakes up too early.
Delayed Sleep-Wake Phase Disorder
When the SCN runs longer than 24 hours → body clock is behind environment.
Falls asleep and wakes up too late.