Diagnosis Notes
Diagnosing: Why It Matters
- Focus on the informational part of diagnosing and diagnostic case formulation.
- Diagnosis is a tool, not an identity; it aids in selecting a framework and intervention.
- Diagnosis should be used thoughtfully.
The DSM
- DSM stands for the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, published by the American Psychiatric Association (APA).
- It's the primary tool for classifying and diagnosing mental health conditions in the U.S. and standardized writing.
- Currently in DSM-5 TR (text revision of DSM-5), which updates language, clarifies, and expands sections.
- The DSM provides criteria lists, descriptions, guidance on severity, and cultural/developmental considerations for each diagnosis.
Role of DSM in Practice
- Standardization: Ensures uniform language across different settings and interdisciplinary teams.
- Practical uses: Required by insurance companies for reimbursement; used by researchers, schools, courts, and disability services for decisions and accommodations.
Limitations of DSM
- Can be reductionistic, categorizing complex human experiences into boxes.
- Shaped by a Western worldview, necessitating critical use.
Differential Diagnosis
- Essential process for determining which diagnosis best fits a person's presentation.
- Involves examining overlapping symptoms and possibilities based on observation, patient information, and data.
- Example: Symptoms like feeling down, disconnected, and fatigued could indicate depression, bipolar II, or PTSD.
- Components:
- Assessment: Data gathering via interviews, observation, and history.
- Rule-outs: Determining what doesn't fit.
- Clinical judgment: Integrating training, intuition, and gathered data.
Why Differential Diagnosis Matters
- Misdiagnosis is common, leading to ineffective or harmful treatments.
- Differential diagnosis acknowledges the complexity of human experience, understanding that individuals with the same diagnosis can have different stories and needs.
- Promotes critical thinking by connecting dots, asking questions, and challenging assumptions.
- Ethical consideration: Ensures treating the person, not just the label.
Relevance Beyond Therapy
- Understanding diagnosis enhances trauma-informed and culturally sensitive practice.
- Improves collaboration with other clinicians in various settings (schools, hospitals, etc.).
- Reduces stigma by promoting understanding over judgment.
- Encourages a reflective, person-centered approach, even without direct assessment.
Key Takeaways
- Diagnosis is a tool to guide care, not a permanent label.
- The DSM is a helpful guide but has limitations.
- Differential diagnosis involves clinical reasoning and understanding someone's story.
- Diagnostic literacy is beneficial across various roles (clinical, advocacy, education, etc.).
Diagnosing Jordan
- Jordan is a 23-year-old biracial, nonbinary individual presenting with low mood, isolation, academic issues, mild paranoia, prior self-injury, cannabis use, family invalidation, and systemic stress.
- Appearance: Disheveled, minimal eye contact.
- Speech: Limited, soft, slow.
- Mood/Affect: Numb, flat.
- Thought Process: Tangential, slow.
- Cognition: Oriented times three, poor concentration, partial insight, cannabis as coping mechanism.
- Symptomology:
- Emotional/Psychological: Numbness, disconnection, feeling overwhelmed, passive thoughts of escape, heightened anxiety, mild paranoia under stress.
- Behavioral: Withdrawal, decline in academic performance, disrupted sleep patterns.
Initial Diagnosis
- Major Depressive Disorder, moderate with anxious distress.
- ICD-10 Code: F32.1
Major Depressive Disorder Criteria
- Five or more symptoms during the same two-week period, including:
- Depressed mood.
- Loss of interest or pleasure.
- Symptoms cause distress or impairment of functioning.
- Not due to substances or medical conditions.
- Specifier: Anxious distress.
Differential Diagnoses
- Generalized Anxiety Disorder (GAD)
- Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD)
- Cannabis Use Disorder
GAD Rule Out
- Symptoms are reactive and not pervasive or generalized over the last six months.
- Generalized Anxiety Disorder:
- Excessive anxiety for more than 6 months
- At least three of the following symptoms are present:
- Restlessness
- Feeling keyed up
- Fatigue
- Difficulty concentrating
- Irritability
- Muscle Tension
- Sleep disturbance
PTSD Considerations
Preoccupied with being criticized or rejected (distrust of others, social withdrawal, fear of judgement).
Not Present: Long standing pattern of persuasice interpersonal avoidance. Behavior seems situational and reactive.
Cannabis Use Disorder
Cannabis is often token in large amounts over a larger period of time.
Persistent desire or unsuccessful effort to cut down.
Craving or a strong desire to use or continued use despite social interperonsal problems or negative effect, using hazardous situations, tolerance, or withdrawal issues.
Fits: uses marijuana three to five times a week acknowledges it, sometimes increases paranoia. No mention of attempts to cut down or any withdrawal symptoms at all.
Likely qualifes for a provison diagnosis, but not the primary diagnosis.
Conclusion - Mild
Cultural and Systemic Influences (Z Codes)
- Identity-based trauma and rejection.
- Invalidation of mental health and identity impacting engagement and trust.