Chapter 7 AP Gov, The Bureaucracy
Bureaucrat → an official who works within a government or large corporate administrative system. Some believe the system is too elite and violates separation of powers
The federal bureaucracy is the vast, hierarchical organization of executive branch employees- ranges from members of the president’s cabinet to accountants at the Internal Revenue Service- that take care of the federal government’s business.
Structure of the Bureaucracy
Governing bodies headed by professional bureaucrats. These include departments, agencies, commissions, and a few private-public organizations known as government corporations.
Cabinet Secretaries
Appointed by President with Senate confirmation
Helps manage the bureaucracy
consist of 2000 upper-level management positions, deputy secretaries, and bureau chiefs
most tend to be in the president’s party and have experience in a relevant field of government or the private sector.
Ex: JF Kennedy appointed his brother, Robert, as the Nation’s attorney general.
Departments
15 different departments
How the president oversees the executive branch
includes energy, veterans affairs, and homeland security.
departments have been renamed and divided.
largest is department of defense.
cabinet secretaries direct the departments.
all of these cabinet secretaries are paid the same
Agencies
Departments contain agencies that divide the department’s goals and workload.
also known as divisions, bureaus, offices, services, administrations, and boards.
Ex: Within the department of security, there is the Immigration and Customs enforcement, the Coast Guard, and the Transportation Security.
There are 100s of agencies
The head of each agency is the director (appointed by the president)
Usually the director serves while the president is serving, but they sometimes serve longer terms as defined in the statute that created the agency.
Task performed by the Bureaucracy
The legislature gives the departments broad goals, as they administer several agencies and a large number of bureaucrats within those departments. Agencies have more specific goals, and independent regulatory agencies have even more specialized responsibilities in their administrative mission. This includes:
Writing and Enforcing Regulations → independent regulatory agencies and commissions have greater leeway and power to shape and enforce national policies than others.
Enforcement and Fines → can impose fines or other punishments. Targets companies, not individuals. One key aspect is compliance monitoring (making sure the firms and companies that are subject to industry regulations are following those standards and provisions.
Testifying Before Congress → cabinet secretaries and agencies (often experts in their field) frequently appear before congressional committees to provide expert testimony.
Iron Triangles and Issue Networks
The relationship among these three entities- an agency, a congressional committee, and an interest group.
The three-way independent relationships are strong.
they join forces and create policy
Issue networks → include committee staffers, academics, advocates, leaders of think tanks, interest groups, and/or the media
Multiple actors and institutions interact to produce and implement possible policies.
The spoils system
The bureaucracy became known as a place to reward loyal party leaders with federal jobs → patronage.
Presidents appointed regional and local postmasters in the many branch offices across the nation expecting loyalty in return. This became known as the spoils system.
Civil Service Reform
Came from the desire for the best government rather than a government of friends and family.
altered how a bureaucrat is dismissed, limited preferences for veterans in hopes of balancing the genders in federal employment and put upper-level appointments back into the president’s hands.
Congress passed a law that authorized the president to create rules and regulations for a civil service.
Pendleton Civil Service Act → to prevent the constant reward to loyal party members. This law created the merit system → competitive, written exams for many job applicants.
Civil Service Commission → oversees the process and prevented officials from requiring federal employees to contribute to political campaigns.
Also improving the Effectiveness of the Bureaucracy
Office of Personnel Management (OPM) → runs the merit system and coordinates the federal application process for jobs and hiring.
The National Performance Review (NPR) → became Clinton’s key document in assessing the federal bureaucracy. The review was organized to identify problems and offer solutions and ideas for government savings. The group responsibility with the agencies.
Delegated Discretionary authority → the power to interpret legislation and create rules- to executive departments and agencies.
The Administrative Procedures Act → Made the bureaucratic rule-making process more formalized to make it fair and transparent.
Congressional Responsilbility in Rule Making
Congress members choose to delegate authority to the buraucracy.
3 conditions that increase authority:
politicians need more info than voters
bureaucrats must be reliable
Politicians must care more about problem solving than popularity
Code of Federal Regulations
This is where the final print of the law is placed
The federal register prints the record of how the regulation started, how it developed, and how it ended.
Independent Regulatory Agencies
enforces and regulates issue fines and other punishments.
some are structured with a director and assistants, and some are headed by a board of commission led by a chairperson, such as the Federal Elections Commission.
The president is involved but has less influence than other departments and agencies
Congressional Oversight
Done through Committee Hearings and Power of the Purse
Is essentially a check and balance on the agencies themselves and competes with the president for influence over them
It investigates problems, questions government officials, reviews documents, and hold agencies accountable.
These hearings can be routine updates or investigations into serious issues.
Power of the purse
congress controls gov. funding by deciding how much money agencies can recieve and what they can spend it on. Agencies need congressional approval to spend public funds.
Authorization of spending: states the max amount the agency can spend in certain programs.
The President and the Bureaucracy
The president influences federal agencies to carry out their policies.
The Office of Information and Regulatory Affairs (OIRA) → reviews regulations to ensure they align with the president’s goals, sometimes changing or eliminating rules.
Compliance Monitoring
Making sure the firms and companies that are subject to industry regulations are following those standards and provisions. The Environmental Protection Agency, for example, monitors for compliance by assessing documents → requiring permits for certain activities.
It collects measurable scientific evidence by taking water on air samples near a factory to test the amount of pollutants.
Competing Interest
The federal bureaucracy is enormous, and it’s day to day functions involve thousands of people among hundreds of agencies. This keeps the “4th branch” working properly.
Congress and The Final Say
Committee Clearance → developed to sort out any overlap
Legislative veto → controls executive agencies. Is a requirement that certain agency decisions must wait for a defined period of either 30 or 90 days. This was used during conflict with Vietnam and it put limits on military activity
Competition in the Executive
The different beliefs or approaches of executive departments can create friction between them when the US must state a position or make a decision.
The Departments of State and Defense was example because it has differences on foreign policy.
These differing perspectives can make the development of coherent goals challenging
Upper-level bureaucrats get caught between their boss and the many people who work for them
The presidents’s goals may not take into account some of the practical constraints of the bureaucracy and as a result may be too difficult to achieve.
Whistleblower protection act → prohibits a federal agency from retaliating or threatening an employee for disclosing acts that he or she believes were illegal or dishonest
The courts and the Bureaucracy
Bureaucratic agencies interact with courts in variety of ways. The implementation of some rules can result in prosecution of ann offender in a criminal trial.
Supreme court can shape how congress can interact with agencies and has generally empowered agencies.
Courts and Accountability → the courts are involved when citizens challenge federal bureaucratic decisions.
U.S Circuit Courts of Appeals → Most judicial hearings challenge agency decisions and regulatory punishments are looking for a complicated interpretation of a law, its application, or its constitutionality.
Trends in Bureaucratic Authority → Appeals courts are more likely to protect and uphold independent commission’s decisions than general executive branch department and agency decisions