2.2 - corporate responsibility, stakeholder theory & CSR

lecture overview

this lecture explores corporate responsibility, who corporations should be responsible to, and how they act upon these responsibilities. the key areas covered are:

  • stakeholder theory - who corporations are responsible to

  • corporate social responsibility [CSR] - what corporations are responsible for

  • motivations for corporate responsibility - why corporations should act responsibly

  • critiques of stakeholder capitalism - examining the ethical and practical challenges of CSR

part 1 - stakeholder theory - who are corporations responsible to?

rejecting the separation thesis

the separation thesis argues that business and ethics are separate entities, meaning ethical considerations should not interfere with business decisions. this idea aligns with shareholder primacy, which claims that corporations exist primarily to maximise profits for shareholders

however, stakeholder theory, introduced by R. Edward Freeman, challenges this view. it argues that:

  • values are a fundamental part of business - companies cannot operate in an ethical vacuum

  • corporations must consider all stakeholders, not just shareholders

  • rejecting the separation thesis means acknowledging that business decisions inherently involve ethical concerns

who is a stakeholder?

a stakeholder is any individual or group affected by a corporation’s actions. this includes:

  • shareholders - investors who own part of the company

  • employees - workers whose livelihoods depend on the company

  • suppliers - businesses that provide goods/services to the company

  • customers - people who buy the company’s products/services

  • competitors - other companies in the same industry

  • government - regulatory bodies and policymakers

  • civil society - local communities, activists, NGOs, and the general public

stakeholder capitalism

stakeholder capitalism emphasises creating value for all stakeholders rather than focusing solely on profit maximisation. according to Freeman, corporations create value by:

  • producing goods/services that customers want

  • offering jobs that employees find fulfilling

  • establishing strong relationships with suppliers

  • acting as responsible corporate citizens

challenges in stakeholder management

  • not all stakeholders have equal importance - a company may prioritise some stakeholders over others

  • trade-offs between stakeholders - conflicts arise when benefitting one stakeholder harms another [e.g. increasing wages for employees may reduce shareholder profits]

  • difficulty in legislating corporate governance - laws struggle to enforce ethical business practices


part 2 - corporate social responsibility [CSR] - what are corporations responsible for?

CSR is a framework for how businesses operate ethically and contribute to societal well-being. a key model for understanding CSR is Carroll’s Four-Part Model, which divides corporate responsibility into 4 layers:

1 - economic responsibility [profit-making]

  • foundational responsibility - businesses exist to generate profit

  • responsibility to shareholders [return on investment], employees [fair wages and working conditions], and customers [quality products/services]

  • economic responsibility can cut both ways - for example, the concept of “too big to fail“ suggests that some corporations must be bailed out to prevent economic collapse

2 - legal responsibility [obeying laws]

  • corporations must operate within legal frameworks

  • laws represent a codification of society’s moral expectations

  • following the ‘rules of the game‘ ensures fair competition and protects consumers

3 - ethical responsibility [doing what is right]

  • businesses are expected to act fairly, justly, and respect stakeholders’ moral rights

  • ethical responsibilities often go beyond legal requirements

    • e.g. tax avoidance is legal but can be seen as unethical

    • avoiding harm includes paying fair wages, ensuring safe working conditions, and protecting the environment

4 - philanthropic responsibility [giving back to society]

  • corporations are expected to engage in voluntary initiatives that promote social welfare

  • examples:

    • supporting the arts, education, and charities

    • investing in community programs to enhance the quality of life

  • philanthropy is not legally required but is expected as good corporate citizen


part 3 - why be responsible - motivations for corporate responsibility

corporations act responsibly for 2 main reasons:

1 - ethical responsibility

  • businesses and society are mutually dependent - corporations rely on society, and vice versa

  • companies have a moral obligation to protect and support their stakeholders

  • businesses must account for externalities [unintended consequences of their actions], such as:

    • pollution

    • worker exploitation

    • supply chain ethics [e.g. avoiding child labour]

2 - enlightened self-interest [the business case for CSR]

  • companies that act responsibly benefit in the long run

  • positive impact on revenue:

    • ethical businesses attract loyal customers

    • employees prefer working for socially responsible companies, leading to higher productivity

  • risk management:

    • avoiding scandals, lawsuits, and protests

    • protecting against government regulation by voluntarily adopting ethical practices

  • cost savings:

    • reducing waste and energy usage lowers operational costs

    • sustainable practices lead to long-term efficiency gains


part 4 - critique of stakeholder capitalism

while stakeholder theory and CSR present ethical business frameworks, they face criticism

is enlightened self-interest truly ethical?

  • ethical frameworks differ:

    • consequentialist ethics [utilitarianism/egoism] - justifies CSR if it leads to good outcomes

    • deontological ethics [kantian justice/virtue ethics] - argues that CSR should be done because it is the right thing to do, not because it benefits business

Milton Friedman’s critique

  • economist Milton Friedman famously argued that CSR is unethical:

    • social issues should be handled by the government, not corporations

    • CSR is undemocratic because it redistributes wealth without shareholder consent

    • ethical spending by corporations results in:

      • lower profits for shareholders

      • lower wages for employees

      • higher prices for customers

the unethical ends of CSR

  • some scholars CSR is a facade for corporate power:

    • Banarjee [2008] - CSR is primarily designed to legitimise corporate power, not genuinely improve society

    • Costas & Karreman [2013] - CSR can be used for employee control

    • Hanlon & Fleming [2009] - CSR is a way for corporations to expand profit motives into social issues


conclusions

  • stakeholder theory argues that businesses have ethical responsibilities beyond shareholders

  • CSR provides a framework for corporate responsibility, incorporating economic, legal, ethical, and philanthropic duties

  • the motivations for CSR include both ethical duty and self-interest

  • critics argue that CSR is flawed, with concerns about its genuine impact, ethical implications, and potential to serve corporate interests over social good

the debate on corporate responsibility continues. should businesses act ethically because it benefits them, or because it is simply the right thing to do? stakeholder theory and CSR provide frameworks, but the practical application remains contested