lesson 1

In an essay entitled "Buddhist Economics," E.F. Schumacher uses religious and moral principles to the question of human flourishing. He opens the essay with the lines; "Right Livelihood" is one of the requirements of the Buddha's Noble Eightfold Path. It is clear, therefore, that there must be such a thing as Buddhist economics... Spiritual health and material well-being are not enemies: they are natural allies" (Schumacher 2014, p. 421). There exists a misunderstanding in traditional Western economics, says Schumacher, when it is preoccupied with a type of self-righteousness, which puts premium on goods over people or utility over creativity. Looking back at our own vision of human flourishing, are these visions and our justification and criteria a preoccupation of value based on goods or utility? Or are these visions, justifications, and criteria based on people and creativity? Schumacher further explains that some social scientists, economists to be precise, think that their science is absolute; they suffer from a certain blindness when they treat their field as a positive science and not as a social science with a certain set of assumptions. If we think that human flourishing is an objective reality based on an objective criteria, it is not. It is more complicated than mere physical and mechanical movements. When we understand our flourishing as mechanical, we reduce ourselves to robots, to machines, or even reduce ourselves to objects. From this sensibility stems the negative thinking toward work and the difficulty of experiencing satisfying work (that is, one that is perfectly aligned to our sense of purpose and mission). If all that we do is focused on the acquisition of wealth and of becoming rich, we see ourselves pushing too much and exerting unnecessary effort to be someone we are not. It is undeniable, says Schumacher, that the source of wealth is human labor. Quite interestingly, modern economies have somehow understood labor from two opposing perspectives. On the one hand, from the perspective of the employer, it is understood as a cost in the process, which can be removed by automation. On the other hand, from the perspective of the workforce, it is understood as a "disutility" By "disutility," Schumacher refers to labor as a letting go of leisure and comfort; in relation to this, wages are understood as a kind of compensation for the sacrifices made. When understood in relation to these two, the employers envision "an output without employees," while the work force envisions an "income without employment" (Ibid.). If these perspectives confront us when we consider our understanding of human flourishing, what then are the consequences of these differing views? If work is treated as something to escape and run away from, then every attempt to reduce workload is always preferable. The more we are able to make processes that decrease labor, the better. This explains why companies tend to automate; but because automation is costly and expensive, companies engage in the process of dividing labor. The division of labor is also the introduction of specialization. Not that workers were not specialized before (as if we were not working nor creating since time immemorial), what we mean here by the division of labor refers more to the splitting of processes into smaller parts. Such that crafts that previously engage a laborer are now subdivided into four or five subprocesses with specifically assigned laborers. What this does is to produce efficiency of labor. Products are produced faster and accountability in the pipeline is easier. As this involves efficiency, it is often understood as progress; or better yet, this is what is often misunderstood as human flourishing.


Schumacher challenges this understanding of human flourishing using a Buddhist point of vien, In the Butchs perspective, labor Is understood as: to give a man a chance to the and develop his he Bladis perspective, to overcome his ego-centeredness by joining with other people in a common task; and to bring forth the goods and services needed for a becoming extence" (Supra, . 422). If we understand work negatively, Schumacher argues that it is criminal because it focuses on goods rather than people; this lacks compassion and reduces the soul to a worldly existence that is inhumane, In the same way that to favor leisure than work is to forget the complementarity of work and leisure in living and to destroy "the joy of work and the bliss of leisure." In the perspective above, we can draw two types of automation/mechanization. The first enhances the skill and power of humanity, and the second reduces human work to a mechanical slave. The former constitutes the Buddhist vision for human flourishing, whereas the latter leaves humanity to the position of serving the slave. If our understanding of human flourishing simply constitutes automation/mechanization, then we become victims of the slave; this is not the vision of human flourishing, we intend to push forward. Similar to Gandhi, Schumacher further distinguishes Buddhist economics with the economics of modern materialism. The distinction is based on the perspective that civilization is not about the duplication of wants and desires as it is "the purification of human character" For the Buddhist, character is formed, as well as it is a consequence, of human labor. Since it is human labor that is concerned here, it is determined by the condition of human dignity and freedom, and "blesses those who do it and equally their products" (Supra, p. 422). It is worth nothing that this different and more Eastern disposition does not propose a denial and a departure of the material world; instead, it pushes forward human integration. The materialist perspective is concerned merely with the production of goods and the accumulation of wealth. The Buddhist perspective is all about a type of liberation that is not against physical well-being. Having said that, it is not technology or money that hinders and prevents the way of salvation from this perspective; instead, it is the attachment to money and wealth that is the enemy of salvation. It is not wrong to enjoy pleasurable things; it is wrong to live craving for them. Schumacher's claim in Buddhist economics, therefore, highlights two things: nonviolence and simplicity. From his economist perspective, the beauty of this way of life lies in its utter rationality— that is, that human flourishing does not entail big or huge things, but tiny or small means that lead to satisfactory results. It is no surprise that this is difficult, or even impossible, for an economist from a consumerist culture. Why? Because a culture that prioritizes productivity over presence considers it as a standard to determine development by means of consumption. The presumption is simple— the more one consumes, the better they are from those who do not. This is considered weird by the Buddhist economist who considers consumption only as an indicator and means to human well-being, but is not the sole determinant for well-being (Supra, p. 423). Human flourishing, then, cannot be understood vis-à-vis consumption. This is not the mark of what it means to be human. However, economics looks at consumption as the "sole end and purpose of all economic activity" and considers the many factors of production only as a means. What economics do is to maximize the human drive by stimulating the desire for consumption (Supra)


When considering human flourishing Buddhist-style, It seems like the best manner of consumption entails producing optimal human satisfaction while utilizing a relatively low rate of consumption-nonviolence and simplicity. These Buddhist principles allow people to live their fe without pressure and strain or without the need to be something or someone. This mindset represents the central injunction of Buddhism: "Cease to do evil; try to do good." As physical resources are scarce, the people's drive to modestly satisfying their needs are more sustainable than people who voraciously depend upon a high rate of consumption and use. Speaking of nonviolence and simplicity, local communities that are self-sufficient are less involved in large-scale violence. Issues of sustainability are concerns of human flourishing. Shumacher explains: "From the point of view of Buddhist economics... production from local resources for local needs is the most rational way of economic life, while dependence on imports from afar and the consequent need to produce for export to unknown and distant peoples is highly uneconomic and justifiable only in exceptional cases and on a small scale," (Supra, p. 423). If we are to flourish as a specie, it needs to be based on life styles that are locally sustainable. Going back to the discussion of science and technology, Schumacher concludes by referring to the enduring value of Buddhist economics: *It is in the light of both immediate experience and long-term prospects that the study of Buddhist economics could be recommended even to those who believe that economic growth is more important than any spiritual or religious values. For it is not a question of choosing between "modern growth" and "traditional stagnation." It is a question of finding the right path to development, the Middle Way between materialist heedlessness and traditionalist immobility, in short, of finding "Right Livelihood,"'' (Supra, p. 424).