Evidence for Evolution

History of Evolutionary Thought

  • Charles Darwin (1809-1882)
    • Initially studied medicine, then theology, before becoming a naturalist.
    • Traveled the world on the HMS Beagle.
    • Observed species relationships and distributions.
    • In 1859, presented the first concrete evidence and mechanism for evolution in "On the Origin of Species."

Darwin's Journey on HMS Beagle

  • The journey included stops at various locations around the world, including:
    • Azores
    • Canary Islands
    • Cape Verde Islands
    • Bahia
    • Rio de Janeiro
    • Montevideo
    • Falkland Islands
    • Tierra del Fuego
    • St. Helena
    • Ascension
    • Mauritius
    • King George Sound
    • Hobart
    • Sydney
    • New Zealand
    • Tahiti
    • Cocos Islands
    • Galapagos Islands
    • Callao
    • Valparaiso

Evidence Collected by Darwin

  • Artificial Selection
  • Fossil Records
  • Comparative Anatomy
  • Comparative Embryology
  • Biogeography
  • Taxonomy

Artificial Selection

  • Breeding for desired traits.
    • Examples: hens with more eggs, varieties of dogs, large vegetables.
    • Directly contradicts the belief that species do not change.
  • Dog Breed example
    • Wolf is the ancestor of all modern dog breeds
    • Bloodhound
    • Dalmatian
    • Airedale
    • Border Collie
    • Pekingese

Vegetables from One Species

  • Many vegetables are derived from one species, Brassica oleracea, through artificial selection for different traits.
    • Cabbage: Selection for terminal buds.
    • Cauliflower: Selection for flower clusters.
    • Brussels sprouts: Selection for lateral buds.
    • Broccoli: Selection for stems and flowers.
    • Kohlrabi: Selection for stem.
    • Kale: Selection for leaves.

Fossil Record

  • Fossils are evidence of past life forms and are formed in various ways:
    • Mineralization
    • Trapped in amber/tar
    • Footprints in soft soil
    • Soft vs. hard tissues

Archaeopteryx

  • Archaeopteryx is an example of a fossil record of a species.

Transitional Fossils

  • Tiktaalik roseae
    • A 375-million-year-old fish.
    • Exhibits characteristics of both fish and tetrapods.

Comparative Anatomy

  • Similarities in structure of functionally different organisms.
  • Example: Bones in Human arm, Dolphin fin, Bat wing, Bird wing
    • Humerus
    • Radius
    • Ulna
    • Carpals
    • Metacarpals
    • Phalanges

Comparative Anatomy: Homologous vs. Analogous Structures

  • Homologous Structures
    • Different species with similar underlying structure but different function.
    • Example: Bones of vertebrate legs, wings, and fins.
  • Analogous Structures
    • Unrelated species with similar features and function but different underlying structure.
    • Example: Insect wings and bird wings.
  • Convergent Evolution
    • Independent evolution of similar features or functions in unrelated species.
    • Example: Eye of cephalopods and vertebrates.

Convergent Evolution: The Eye

  • The eye of humans and octopuses are examples of convergent evolution.
  • Human eye components:
    • Eyelid
    • Cornea
    • Pupil
    • Iris
    • Ciliary muscle
    • Lens
    • Retina
    • Optic nerve
  • Octopus eye components:
    • Optic ganglion

Vestigial Organs

  • Nonfunctional, reduced parts.
    • Examples: appendix, wisdom teeth, coccyx in humans, vestigial pelvis in whales.
    • Common ancestry explains them as unused parts.
  • Example: Baleen whales
    • Vestigial hip and thigh bones
  • Example: Toothed whales, dolphins, and porpoises
    • Vestigial pelvis

Comparative Embryology

  • Features in embryos that do not show up in adults:
    • Pharyngeal pouches
    • Tail
    • Tubular heart
  • Suggests common ancestry.
  • Examples: Reptile, Bird, Pig, Human
    • All have gill pouches and a tail in the embryo stage

Biogeography

  • Study of the distribution of species.
  • Distinct species groups on different continents.
  • Example: Marsupials in Australia
  • Nearctic Species
    • Gray fox
    • Moose
    • Agouti
    • Beaver
  • Palearctic Species
    • Argali
    • Brown Bear
    • Black Bear
    • Snow Leopard
    • Chamois
    • Aoudad
  • Neotropical Species
    • Tapir
    • Jaguar
    • Sloth
    • Anteater
  • Ethiopian Species
    • Zebra
    • Lion
  • Oriental Species
    • Tiger
    • Indian Boar
    • Indian Elephant
  • Australian Species
    • Koala
    • Thylacine
    • Platypus
    • Kangaroo

Evidence Collected by Darwin (Recap)

  • Artificial Selection
  • Fossil Records
  • Comparative Anatomy
  • Comparative Embryology
  • Biogeography
  • Protein and DNA Sequence Data

Darwin's Conclusions from Evidence

  • Many species have existed before that no longer exist.
  • Species show relatedness in the fossil record and other forms of evidence.
  • Species have changed over time to their current state.
  • All life is related through descent with modification.

Natural Selection

  • Darwin proposed natural selection as a mechanism for how these changes arose.
    1. Capacity for overproduction.
    2. Yet few survive due to limited resources.
    3. Individuals vary in traits.
    4. Those that survive are those whose traits allow them to obtain resources and reproduce successfully.

Darwin's Publications

  • 1838-43: Zoology of the Voyage of H.M.S. Beagle
  • 1838: Part 1 No. 1 Fossil Mammalia, by Richard Owen (Preface and Geological introduction by Darwin)
  • 1838: Part 2 No. 1 Mammalia, by George R. Waterhouse (Geographical introduction and A notice of their habits and ranges by Darwin)
  • 1839: Journal and Remarks (The Voyage of the Beagle)
  • 1842: The Structure and Distribution of Coral Reefs
  • 1844: Geological Observations on the Volcanic Islands visited during the voyage of H.M.S. Beagle
  • 1846: Geological Observations on South America
  • 1849: Geology from A Manual of scientific enquiry; prepared for the use of Her Majesty's Navy: and adapted for travellers in general., John F.W. Herschel ed.
  • 1851: A Monograph of the Sub-class Cirripedia, with Figures of all the Species. The Lepadidae; or, Pedunculated Cirripedes.
  • 1851: A Monograph on the Fossil Lepadidae, or, Pedunculated Cirripedes of Great Britain
  • 1854: A Monograph of the Sub-class Cirripedia, with Figures of all the Species. The Balanidae (or Sessile Cirripedes); the Verrucidae, etc.
  • 1854: A Monograph on the Fossil Balanidæ and Verrucidæ of Great Britain
  • 1858: On the Tendency of Species to form Varieties; and on the Perpetuation of Varieties and Species by Natural Means of Selection (Extract from an unpublished Work on Species)
  • 1859: On the Origin of Species
  • 1881: The Formation of Vegetable Mould through the Action of Worms

Darwin's Last Book

  • The Formation of Vegetable Mould through the Action of Worms was published 138 years ago (in Oct. 1881).
  • Darwin's health was failing, and he wanted to complete this book before he died.

Modern Synthesis

  • Darwin did not know how traits were inherited.
  • Gregor Mendel's work was published in 1866 but was not noticed until 1900.
  • Modern synthesis (neo-Darwinism) recognizes:
    • Mutations as the source of variations.
    • A change in allele frequency as a measure of evolution.