Critique of 'Precolonial Africa' in African Studies

Rejection of 'Precolonial' Epithet
  • The term 'precolonial' is theoretically vacuous, racist, and misrepresents African history.

  • It homogenizes African peoples and their history, obscuring complexity and diversity.

  • The epithet should be expunged from all aspects of African studies.

Problems with the 'Precolonial' Concept
  • Exclusive Application: Almost exclusively applied to Africa, implying a peculiar and undifferentiated representation rooted in racist philosophies (e.g., Hegel's 'Africa outside of Time').

  • Temporal Distortion: Fails to describe effectively a period from the beginning of time to modern European colonialism, granting it mythological status rather than historical fact.

  • Ignores Prior Colonialisms: Overlooks significant earlier European-inspired colonial presences (Roman, Byzantine/Ottoman) and internal African colonial forms and empires (e.g., Mali, Ọ̀yọ́, Ethiopia).

  • Disregards African Colonizers: Conceals the history of African polities as colonizers beyond the continent's borders (e.g., Moorish rule in Iberia, Mohammed Ali's Egypt).

Impact on African History and Scholarship
  • Colonialism as Sole Axis: Reduces African history to an 'episode' relative to modern European colonialism, hindering understanding of intrinsic African developments and continuities.

  • Marginalizes African Intellectualism: Silences rich African intellectual contributions to philosophy, science, and governance, forcing them into a 'traditional' or 'uncontaminated' framework.

  • Limits Understanding of Complexity: Obscures sophisticated African political formations, constitutional innovations (e.g., Fanti confederacy in the 19th19^{th} century), and diverse social dynamics.

  • Inadequate Historical Framework: The three-period schema (precolonial, colonial, postcolonial) is unproductive for generating serious, in-depth African history, especially for the long past.

Towards a More Accurate Understanding of African History
  • Alternative Periodization: Adopt frameworks that place African history within global 'Ancient, Medieval, Modern' timelines, as exemplified by Ladipo Solanke, without using colonialism as the primary axis.

  • Focus on Internal Dynamics: Study African societies for their own coherent principles of governance, evolution, and philosophical contributions, acknowledging both endogenous and exogenous influences.

  • Acknowledge Global Connections: Recognize Africa's uninterrupted participation in the global exchange of ideas, goods, and peoples from ancient times to the present.

  • Broaden Disciplinary Approaches: Apply diverse disciplines (archaeology, palaeoanthropology, linguistics, etc.) to gain a deeper understanding from material artifacts and long-term historical processes.

  • Elevate African Thinkers: Integrate individual African thinkers and their contributions into global intellectual history and philosophy, broadening the scope beyond traditional 'Western' canons.