1a. Is economics a science

Yes, Economics is a science

  • Like other sciences, economists deal with large scale issues and require large scale experiments to truly test ideas
  • Basic challenges researchers face are not different from the challenges in other fields of study
  • Challenges faced by economists are not necessarily different to scientists in other fields. Challenges are overcome through developing tools that obtain answers through experimentation
  • Economics tests old theories and formulates new ones that have been adapted based on findings
  • Economics is a study of people and decision making which is often backed by maths and data and uses analytical methods

\
No, Economics is not a science

  • Economics is more concerned with making predictions and does not necessarily follow laws in the same way physical science might
  • Models used involve people, therefore the need for approximating is much stronger
  • Economists ability to carry out experiments is severely limited by the need to do it on such a wide scale and the potential impact it would have on peoples livelihoods
  • There tends to be multiple people in the same field who have opposing ideas. People can interpret data differently and propose different policies based on the same information
  • There may be a political bias in information and might not always be fact based

\