Lecture 9 - Ethics (student version)
LECTURE 9 - ETHICS
AIM OF THE SESSION
Objectives of the Session:
Describe the history of ethics in research
Discuss the BPS Code of Human Research Ethics
Understand the BPS Code of Ethics and Conduct
HISTORY OF ETHICS
Burke and Hare
Mass Murders:
At least 15 cases involved selling bodies to Professor Robert Knox’s anatomy school.
Ivan Pavlov (1849-1936)
Classical Conditioning:
Learned to associate two objects together, explored behavioral responses.
Nuremberg Code
Key aspects designed to protect research participants:
Informed Consent: Participants must be aware and agree to their involvement.
Beneficial Results: Outcomes should be valuable for society.
Avoid Unnecessary Harm: Risk must not exceed benefit.
Right to Withdraw: Participants can leave the study at any time.
Tuskegee Syphilis Study
Conducted:
From 1932 to 1972, involving untreated syphilis among farm workers.
Participants received free medical care, meals, and burial options, yet were not treated for syphilis.
Influence of LSD on Elephants (West et al., 1962)
Study Findings:
Investigated musth (aggressive state) in male elephants.
Notable that two elephants survived both low and high dosages of LSD, leading to dramatic behavioral changes.
BPS CODE HUMAN RESEARCH ETHICS
Social Responsibility
Key Principles:
Respect human subjects and communities.
Evaluate risks versus benefits effectively.
Aim to maximize benefits while minimizing harm.
Maintain scientific integrity.
Respect
Safety and Rights of Participants:
Ensure dignity by treating individuals equally.
Acknowledge the researcher’s perceived authority.
Respect rights, privacy, and self-determination.
Scientific Integrity
Research Standards:
Design high-quality research to build knowledge.
Avoid wasting participant time and misleading findings.
Maximising Benefit and Minimising Harm
Ethical Guidelines:
Minimize risks related to well-being, privacy, and dignity of participants.
Protecting Participants
Key Measures:
Informed consent as a primary ethical safeguard.
Establish exclusion criteria for participants.
Provide information sheets and debriefing.
Select measures carefully to protect participant welfare.
BPS CODE OF ETHICS AND CONDUCT
Respect
Dignity and Worth:
Sensitive to perceived authority or influence.
Uphold the rights of individuals in research.
Competence
Development and Knowledge:
Continuing professional development is essential.
Acknowledge knowledge and skills limitations.
Responsibility
Ethical Accountability:
Value responsibilities to individuals and society.
Avoid misuse or abuse of professional contributions.
Integrity
Professional Standards:
Engage in honest, clear, and fair interactions.
Promote integrity in scientific and professional practices.
CONCLUSION
Key Ethics Highlights:
The BPS Code of Human Research Ethics emphasizes respect, scientific integrity, maximising benefits, and social responsibility.
The BPS Code of Ethics and Conduct focuses on respect, competence, responsibility, and integrity.