Lecture 9 - Ethics (student version)

LECTURE 9 - ETHICS

AIM OF THE SESSION

  • Objectives of the Session:

    • Describe the history of ethics in research

    • Discuss the BPS Code of Human Research Ethics

    • Understand the BPS Code of Ethics and Conduct

HISTORY OF ETHICS

Burke and Hare

  • Mass Murders:

    • At least 15 cases involved selling bodies to Professor Robert Knox’s anatomy school.

Ivan Pavlov (1849-1936)

  • Classical Conditioning:

    • Learned to associate two objects together, explored behavioral responses.

Nuremberg Code

  • Key aspects designed to protect research participants:

    • Informed Consent: Participants must be aware and agree to their involvement.

    • Beneficial Results: Outcomes should be valuable for society.

    • Avoid Unnecessary Harm: Risk must not exceed benefit.

    • Right to Withdraw: Participants can leave the study at any time.

Tuskegee Syphilis Study

  • Conducted:

    • From 1932 to 1972, involving untreated syphilis among farm workers.

    • Participants received free medical care, meals, and burial options, yet were not treated for syphilis.

Influence of LSD on Elephants (West et al., 1962)

  • Study Findings:

    • Investigated musth (aggressive state) in male elephants.

    • Notable that two elephants survived both low and high dosages of LSD, leading to dramatic behavioral changes.

BPS CODE HUMAN RESEARCH ETHICS

Social Responsibility

  • Key Principles:

    • Respect human subjects and communities.

    • Evaluate risks versus benefits effectively.

    • Aim to maximize benefits while minimizing harm.

    • Maintain scientific integrity.

Respect

  • Safety and Rights of Participants:

    • Ensure dignity by treating individuals equally.

    • Acknowledge the researcher’s perceived authority.

    • Respect rights, privacy, and self-determination.

Scientific Integrity

  • Research Standards:

    • Design high-quality research to build knowledge.

    • Avoid wasting participant time and misleading findings.

Maximising Benefit and Minimising Harm

  • Ethical Guidelines:

    • Minimize risks related to well-being, privacy, and dignity of participants.

Protecting Participants

  • Key Measures:

    • Informed consent as a primary ethical safeguard.

    • Establish exclusion criteria for participants.

    • Provide information sheets and debriefing.

    • Select measures carefully to protect participant welfare.

BPS CODE OF ETHICS AND CONDUCT

Respect

  • Dignity and Worth:

    • Sensitive to perceived authority or influence.

    • Uphold the rights of individuals in research.

Competence

  • Development and Knowledge:

    • Continuing professional development is essential.

    • Acknowledge knowledge and skills limitations.

Responsibility

  • Ethical Accountability:

    • Value responsibilities to individuals and society.

    • Avoid misuse or abuse of professional contributions.

Integrity

  • Professional Standards:

    • Engage in honest, clear, and fair interactions.

    • Promote integrity in scientific and professional practices.

CONCLUSION

  • Key Ethics Highlights:

    • The BPS Code of Human Research Ethics emphasizes respect, scientific integrity, maximising benefits, and social responsibility.

    • The BPS Code of Ethics and Conduct focuses on respect, competence, responsibility, and integrity.