Forensic Science Disciplines – Comprehensive Notes (Transcript)
Forensic Chemistry and Toxicology
Forensic chemistry focuses on substances outside the human body.
- At a crime scene, a sample like a white powder could be cocaine, baking soda, baby powder, etc.
- A forensic chemist in a lab uses instrumentation to identify unknown substances.
- Common instrument mentioned: gas chromatography–mass spectrometry, abbreviated GCMS. It identifies the substance (e.g., cocaine vs. other powders).
- Forensic chemist vs toxicologist:
- Forensic chemist: analyzes unknown substances outside the body.
- Toxicologist: analyzes chemistry of the human body—poisons, drugs, alcohol; determines concentration and whether it could cause death.
- Instrumentation in chemistry/toxicology is expensive but highly capable for substance identification.
Forensic toxicology
- Focuses on poisons, drugs, and alcohol within the human body.
- Key questions: How much of a substance is in the system? What is the concentration? Was it enough to kill?
Forensic Photography
- Forensic photography is an essential skill in crime scene investigation.
- Purpose: provide the best visual record of what a crime scene looked like so that a jury can evaluate it.
- Practical considerations:
- How to photograph in different lighting (dark, bright, fluorescent light).
- How to adjust exposure settings (e.g., f-stop).
- Use of flash, alternate light sources, and filters when needed.
- Note: While photography is critical, some test questions may not focus heavily on it.
Biological Evidence Collection
Biological evidence includes any material of biological origin: blood, semen, saliva, urine, sweat, hair, etc.
When evidence with a stain arrives in the lab, the first step is visualization of the stain (sometimes visible, sometimes requires visualization techniques).
Serology is used to:
- Determine what the stain is.
- Determine whether it is human.
- Decide whether the stain is important enough to send to DNA analysis.
Reason for selective DNA testing:
- DNA testing is expensive and time-consuming, so not every stain is tested.
- Example: in a sexual assault case with a bed sheet, if the stain is semen and relevant to the assault, it is prioritized for DNA; if it’s sweat, it may be less informative for linking to a perpetrator and may be deprioritized.
DNA: used to identify a specific individual.
- Important foundational statement:
DNA: Nuclear vs Mitochondrial
Nuclear DNA (nDNA)
- Located in the nucleus; can identify an individual to the exclusion of all others except identical twins.
- Can be obtained from suitable samples; hair can yield nuclear DNA if the root (follicle) is present.
- If you only have the hair shaft, identification is not possible, but inclusions/exclusions may still be possible with nuclear DNA when root is present.
Mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA)
- Located in mitochondria; maternally inherited.
- All individuals from the same maternal lineage share the same mtDNA sequence.
- More useful when samples are degraded or mtDNA is all that remains, but it cannot distinguish between individuals in the same maternal line.
Practical example of mtDNA utility:
- When only skeletal remains or degraded tissue is available, mtDNA can connect remains to a maternal lineage, not to a specific individual.
Important note about DNA databases:
- CODIS stands for the Combined DNA Index System.
CODIS: Combined DNA Index System
CODIS has three components:
- Offender (felony) database: individuals with a felony charge have a swab of the mouth collected and their DNA entered.
- Arrestee database: in some states, arrestees (those merely arrested) have DNA profiles entered.
- Forensic/Casework (crime scene) samples: DNA from crime scenes is uploaded and searched against offender/arrestee profiles.
How CODIS operates in practice:
- If a crime scene sample yields a DNA profile and there is a match to an offender, it links a crime to that offender.
- If there is no match at a local level, the sample is stored in the system and re-searched as new offender data is added.
- Geographic workflow (example from Oklahoma): local databases (e.g., Oklahoma City, Tulsa) -> state database (Oklahoma State Bureau of Investigation) -> National DNA Index System (NDIS) at the FBI.
- If a sample from a local jurisdiction like Edmond or Norman lacks a local DNA unit, it may go straight to the state database.
- If no hits at the state level, the sample can be submitted to the National DNA Index System (NDIS) for a federal-level search.
CODIS statistics (as cited in the lecture):
- Offender profiles:
- Arrestee profiles:
- Labs participating:
Practical implications:
- CODIS can exonerate individuals as well as convict them; it is a powerful tool for justice.
Notable case tied to DNA exoneration:
- Kirk Bloodsworth (referred to in the transcript as Kirk Bludsworth): the first American on death row to be exonerated by DNA.
- Timeline:
- 1984: Body of a nine-year-old girl found; Bloodsworth was convicted of homicide/sexual assault and sentenced to death.
- 1992: DNA from preserved semen samples tested, proving innocence and leading to release from death row.
- 2003: The actual murderer was identified and arrested.
- Broader context: Bloodsworth’s case highlighted the potential for DNA to overturn wrongful convictions and prompted broader adoption of DNA testing in the justice system.
- The narrative includes firsthand reflections on the emotional impact of the case on victims’ families and the accused, illustrating the high stakes of forensic science in real-world outcomes.
Additional DNA exoneration context presented:
- Earl Fuller case (mtDNA context is mentioned): involved a shift from initial eyewitness identification to DNA testing (nuclear vs. mitochondrial context) leading to revision of the conviction.
- Key point: DNA testing can contradict earlier, less reliable forms of evidence (e.g., certain eyewitness identifications or non-DNA evidence).
Broader reflection on DNA testing:
- DNA is a powerful tool that can identify individuals but also raises questions about privacy, ethics, and the possibility of wrongful convictions if not interpreted carefully.
Trace Evidence
- Definition and scope:
- Trace evidence includes very small materials such as human hairs, fibers, soil, glass, paint chips, and similar remnants observed under a microscope.
- Hair analysis specifics:
- With hair: nuclear DNA can be obtained only if the hair root (follicle) is present.
- If only the hair shaft is available, DNA identification to an individual is usually not possible; the hair shaft can provide inclusions/exclusions but not definitive identifications.
- Historical note: FBI analyses and other investigations have shown that hair analysis was not reliable for positive identifications; modern practice is more conservative about identifications from hair.
- Mitochondrial DNA in trace evidence:
- Hair without a root can sometimes be used for mtDNA analysis, which reflects maternal lineage rather than an individual.
- Example: Russell Jordan case (mtDNA usage)
- A missing California high school student, Russell Jordan, left behind bones with no usable nuclear DNA.
- mtDNA from the bones was used to connect to the maternal lineage and identify that the remains belonged to someone in Jordan’s maternal family.
- The analysis allowed narrowing down to a male aged roughly 14–18 within that maternal lineage, guiding authorities to request a sample from the family to confirm identity.
Firearms, Tool Marks, and Trace Impressions
- Firearms examination (and tool marks) basics:
- A firearm examiner often also performs tool-mark analysis.
- Forensic firearms work involves matching bullets to suspected firearms and analyzing cartridge cases.
- Procedure: collect a bullet from the crime scene and a bullet fired from a suspect’s weapon (often retrieved from a water tank to slow the bullet).
- Compare the two bullets to determine if the ammunition component came from the suspect’s firearm.
- Firearm/tool-mark work also includes analysis of gunshot residue (GSR) and determining the distance at which a shot was fired.
- Evidence and limitations:
- In some cases, damage to the evidence or operational constraints may limit the ability to perform a comparison.
- Some agencies are shifting toward civilians specialized in laboratory tasks for efficiency and safety; not every crime scene or lab task requires a police officer.
- Additional trace-evidence categories:
- Shoe and tire impressions: use microscopy to identify characteristics.
- Distinguish class characteristics vs. individual characteristics:
- Class characteristics identify the type of shoe or tire (e.g., pattern, brand insignia like Converse/Nike).
- Individual characteristics include wear patterns, unique defects, and other idiosyncratic marks that may link a specific shoe to a crime scene.
- Practical note: It is often not possible to identify a person from a shoe alone; a positive link typically requires additional evidence (e.g., a matching item worn by a suspect).
- Latent prints (fingerprints):
- Latent prints are hidden prints that require special methods (powders or chemicals) to visualize.
- Once visualized, latent prints can be used for identification if the print is clear and of sufficient quality.
- Context matters: identification from a fingerprint on a knife does not prove guilt if the person used the knife for other purposes previously (e.g., cooking).
The Shoe Bomb Case and Aviation Security Context
- December 2001: Shoe bomb incident on American Airlines Flight 63 (flight from Italy to Miami; landing in Boston).
- The bomber was Richard Reed, who wore shoes with an improvised explosive device embedded in the sole.
- He attempted to light a fuse six times; the attempts were hindered by sweaty feet and moisture.
- Passengers and crew restrained him; the plane landed in Boston.
- FBI demonstration experiments:
- The Bureau built a replica of the same explosive device and demonstrated the potential impact by using an identical bomb setup in a controlled setting.
- They also tested the effects inside a pressurized airplane to understand what would have happened if the device had detonated mid-flight.
- Policy and practice implications:
- The incident contributed to changes in security practices, including periods when footwear removal was common in airports; later changes reduced the burden of shoe removal as security measures evolved.
Evidence Collection and Preservation; The Gatekeeper Role of the Crime Scene Investigator
- Evidence response and preservation are critical:
- Crime scene investigators (CSIs) must avoid contaminating evidence and ensure proper collection and preservation so that lab analyses are valid.
- CSIs act as gatekeepers, deciding what is evidence, what is important, and what should be collected in a real-world environment like a home or apartment.
- Real-world impact:
- The extensive work of CSIs enables laboratory analyses to occur and supports or refutes hypotheses in investigations.
- Kosovo mass graves example:
- The Evidence Response Team was involved in recovering mass grave sites and assisting families in identifying remains following the Kosovo conflict.
Ethical, Practical, and Foundational Implications
- DNA as both a convicting and exonerating tool:
- DNA testing can convict individuals and also exonerate the innocent, highlighting the need for careful interpretation and verification of results.
- Use of databases and privacy considerations:
- Large-scale databases like CODIS enable powerful matching but raise ethical questions about privacy, consent, and potential misuse.
- Reliability and evolution of methods:
- Historical methods (e.g., certain hair analyses) have evolved; some evidence types (like hair identifications) no longer support definitive individual identifications.
- Real-world relevance and education:
- The material connects foundational forensic science principles to high-stakes cases, policy changes (e.g., airline security), and the everyday gatekeeping work of first responders and crime scene teams.
Summary of Key Concepts to Remember
- Distinct roles:
- Forensic chemist vs toxicologist; chemistry focuses on substances outside the body; toxicology focuses on substances inside the body.
- DNA fundamentals:
- Nuclear DNA identifies individuals (except identical twins); mtDNA traces maternal lineage and is useful when nuclear DNA is unavailable or degraded.
- CODIS structure and hierarchical workflow (local → state → national).
- Trace evidence disciplines:
- Hair, fibers, soils, glass, paint; root presence determines nuclear DNA viability for individual identification.
- mtDNA can connect to maternal lineage when nuclear DNA is not available.
- Imaging and impression evidence:
- Photography quality and context, as well as shoe/tire impressions and latent fingerprints, are core to linking evidence to suspects in context.
- Practical case studies:
- Bloodsworth/Bloodsworth case as a landmark DNA exoneration; the role of DNA in exonerations and ongoing reforms.
- Russell Jordan mtDNA case illustrating how skeletal remains can be identified via maternal lineage.
- Shoe bomb and TSA-era security implications showing how forensic insights can influence public policy.
- Crime scene integrity:
- The CSI’s gatekeeping role underscores the importance of contamination prevention and careful evidence handling.