Chapter 11 - Behavioral & Cognitive-Behavioral Family Therapies

Major Theorists

  • Richard Stuart

  • Neil Jacobson

  • Norman Epstein

  • Gerald Patterson

  • Robert Weiss

  • Gayola Margolin

  • Albert Ellis

  • Albert Bandura

  • Walter Mischel

  • William Masters

  • Virginia Johnson

  • Frank Dattilio

  • John Gottman

  • Joseph Wolpe

  • Donald Meichenbaum

  • Ed Katkin

  • Aaron Beck

  • Helen Singer Kaplan

Premises of the Theory

  • behavior is maintained or eliminated by consequences

  • maladaptive behaviors can be unlearned or modified

    • adaptive behaviors can be learned

  • not everyone in the family has to be treated for change to occur

  • cognitions are either rational or irrational

    • they can be modified

    • can bring about a change in couple or family behaviors and interactions

Types of Behavioral & Cognitive-Behavioral Family Therapies

  • behavioral parent training

  • functional family therapy

  • behavioral treatment of sexual dysfunctions

  • cognitive-behavioral family therapy

Treatment Techniques

  • in BFT the focus is on parent training, interpersonal family functioning, the treatment of sexual dysfunctions, and working with the family sometimes as a whole. Cognitive–behavioral family therapy also emphasizes working with those under stress but emphasizes thoughts and behaviors.

  • dyads and individuals are seen more than families with these approaches - the emphasis is on dyadic interactions, except in functional family therapy

  • in BFT, the emphasis is to bring about behavioral changes by modifying the consequences

    • emphasis is on elimination of undesirable behavior and acceleration of positive behavior

    • teaching social skills and preventing problems from recurring are stressed too

    • promoting competence and fostering an understanding of the dynamics of behavior are highlighted

  • in CBFT, the focus is on modifying irrational or unproductive beliefs and the behaviors that go with them

  • behaviorists and cognitive-behaviorists rely primarily on

    • operant conditioning

    • classical conditioning

    • social learning theory

    • cognitive-behavioral strategies

  • general behavioral and cognitive-behavioral approaches include the following

    • education

    • communication and problem-solving strategies

    • operant conditioning

    • contracting

  • specific techniques include but are not limited to

    • classical conditioning

    • coaching

    • contingency contracting

    • extinction

    • positive reinforcement

    • quid pro quo

    • reciprocity

    • shaping

    • systematic desensitization

    • time-out

    • job card grounding

    • grounding

    • charting

    • premack principle

    • disputing irrational thoughts

    • thought stopping

    • self-instructional training

    • modeling and role playing

Role of the Therapist

  • the therapist is a teacher, collaborator, coach, expert

    • presenting problems provide the focus

    • modeling, giving corrective feedback, and learning new behaviors are part of the process

  • the anatomy of intervention model (AIM) delineates five phases in therapy - introduction, assessment, motivation, behavior change, and termination

  • cognitive-behavioral family therapists concentrate on modifying family members’ cognitions, as well as their interactions

  • therapists are active in designing and implementing specific strategies to help families

Process and Outcome

  • family members learn to modify, change, or increase or decrease certain behaviors and thoughts in order to function more effectively

    • they increase their skills in specific areas such as parenting, interpersonal functioning, and sexual behaviors

  • family members eventually are able to modify their behaviors and cognitions without the aid of a therapist

Unique Aspects of Behavioral and Cognitive-Behavioral Approaches

  • use of learning theory and research

  • evolution from a focus primarily on parenting skills to a focus on the family as a system

  • teaching new social skills and cognitions and elimination of dysfunctional ones

  • short-term treatment and rejection of the medical model

  • treatment of a variety of presenting symptoms and problems

Comparison with Other Theories

  • some behaviorists operate from a linear perspective and work on individual rather than system concerns

  • the exceptions are functional family therapy and cognitive-behavioral therapy, which are more systemic

  • behaviorism does not focus attention on affective responses or deal with emotional problems

    • cognitive behaviorism is more attuned to affect and emotion but emphasizes that affect is dependent on thoughts

  • some behavioral and cognitive-behavioral procedures may be at times more mechanical than experiential in practice

  • behaviorism and cognitive-behavioral disregard the use of historical data in the treatment of families

  • some critics of behavioral and cognitive-behavioral family therapies claim that there is too much emphasis on action in these approaches and not enough attention to family dynamics

  • a promising aspect is that cognitive-behavioral famly theraopy has integrated many concepts and methods from other therapies