A Catholic Body? Miracles, Secularity, and the Porous Self in Malta
The Pentecostal and Catholic Sensoria in the Anthropology of Christianity
Pentecostalism and Modernity in the Anthropology of Christianity:
Within the anthropology of Christianity, Pentecostalism represents the most researched and documented tradition.
It is globally recognized as the fastest-growing religious movement and, alongside reformist Islam, is frequently cited as a primary vehicle for the substantive re-enchantment or desecularization of the contemporary world.
Scholarship highlights the compatibility between Pentecostalism and modernization, noting that its theological teachings harmonize directly with contemporary socio-economic shifts, including individualization and capitalist accumulation.
Josh Brahinsky conceptualizes a distinct Pentecostal sensorium, identifying the experiential dimension of Pentecostal practice as an integral component of its modernism.
This sensorium situates the physical body at the operational center of efforts to cultivate the direct presence of the Holy Spirit, configuring specific relationships between bodily experience, empirical evidence, and spiritual discernment.
Historical origins of this sensorium are traced through the Assembly of God, a United States movement originating in the Midwest before expanding to California in the early 1900s:
Early worship practices centered on concentrated, multi-week sessions of prayer and singing—running all day and occasionally all night—to induce glossolalia (speaking in tongues) as the physical manifestation of the Holy Spirit.
The foundational operating maxim was that physicality reveals spirit.
By the early twenty-first century, this dynamic persisted across diverse scales of worship, from small Bible school gatherings to mass stadium assemblies.
Practitioners rely on empirical, embodied sensory events (e.g., sensations of tingling, warmth, heat, or visceral perceptions of spiritual presence) as confirmation of divine reality.
Pentecostal body logics accommodate scientific materialism by adopting empiricist rhetoric, explicitly describing glossolalia as the initial evidence of the Holy Spirit.
Defining the Catholic Sensorium:
A Catholic sensorium operates through bodily and material logics that initially appear nonmodern or countermodern, but which can be structurally reconciled with modern frameworks under specific conditions.
The alignment between the Catholic sensorium and secular modernity depends primarily on historical and sociological factors—specifically the presence or contestation of elite expert testimony—rather than an absolute ontological difference.
Where secular and scientific expert testimony validates the Catholic sensorium, its logic is accepted as modern; where such expert corroboration is absent, contested, or fractured, it is stigmatized as retrograde or premodern.
Secularity, the Buffered Self, and the Porous Catholic Body
Charles Taylor's Three Levels of the Secular:
First Level: The institutional retreat or withdrawal of religion from public and social life.
Second Level: The quantifiable decline of religious beliefs, commitments, and practices among populations.
Third Level: A fundamental reconfiguration of the conditions of belief, specifically altering the human experience and understanding of selfhood.
The Buffered Self versus the Porous Self:
The Buffered Self: The dominant mode of selfhood within secular modernity. It is an individualized, mind-centered subjectivity enclosed within strict cognitive and bodily boundaries, functionally insulated from external spiritual incursions, powers, and occult forces.
The Porous Self: A mode of subjectivity characterized by vulnerability and openness to external spiritual agents, powers, and environmental forces. Taylor associates the porous self primarily with premodern or nonmodern worldviews.
Comparative Porosity: Pentecostal versus Catholic Models:
Pentecostal Porosity: Centers on the human body being directly and unmediatedly entered by the Holy Spirit during heightened ritual moments. However, this porosity remains largely disconnected from the surrounding material environment; material objects are treated as buffered and do not serve as enduring conduits of divine agency.
Catholic Porosity: Extends beyond somatic vulnerability to forces of good and evil. The physical boundaries of the human body are transgressed sensorially, meaning ordinary human senses (vision, hearing, touch, smell) perceive extraordinary spiritual presence distributed within the physical environment.
The Extended Catholic Sensorium and Distributed Cognition:
Catholic materiality—including statues, holy images, relics, and rosaries—functions as active media of presence, serving as porous conduits through which spiritual forces flow.
Spiritual power within Catholicism is potentially immanent in all physical matter; the sensorium is therefore not bound by the skin, but is distributed across the surrounding material world.
David Howes theorizes religion as a sensory process based on distributed cognition and the extended mind:
Sensory perception is not restricted to internal neural processing within the brain.
Perception occurs via a continuous looping process operating across mind, body, and material environment.
Cultural practices and material artifacts mediate these loops, directly framing relationships between the self, society, idea, and object.
Mario Perniola characterizes this framework as an enchanted world wherein divine power lurks inside physical matter, establishing sensory and material engagement with the world as a structural necessity of Catholic practice.
Socioreligious Landscape and Neo-Traditionalism in Malta
Geopolitical and Historical Positioning:
Malta occupies a strategic position at the geographical center of the Mediterranean, situated on the cultural frontier between Christian Europe and Islamic North Africa.
Despite using the Semitic term Alla for God, Maltese religious identification has historically remained firmly Roman Catholic.
The island's history reflects successive phases of external rule: de facto colonization by the pan-European Knights of Saint John (1530–1798), British colonial rule (1800–1964), and eventual accession to the European Union (2004).
This trajectory has fostered an ambivalent posture toward Europe, particularly where European identity is equated with secularization.
Evaluation of Malta under Taylor's Secular Metrics:
Public Sphere: The Roman Catholic Church remains deeply integrated into public institutional life; Catholicism is constitutionally established as the official religion of Malta.
Belief and Practice: While certain devotional practices have declined, institutional affiliation remains exceptionally robust. Surveys conducted by the church-affiliated sociological research unit DISCERN (Institute for Research into the Signs of the Times, established in the early 1990s) reveal that commitment to foundational sacraments—christening, First Holy Communion, confirmation, and marriage—encompasses of the Maltese population.
Subjectivity: The continued prevalence of bodily and material porosity positions Maltese society outside conventional secularization trajectories.
Neo-Traditional Modernity:
Sociologist Anthony Abela categorizes Malta neither as strictly traditional nor fully secular-modern, but as neo-traditional.
Malta incorporates modern institutional and civic forms while retaining traditional Catholic structures, using its historical Catholicism to assert its rightful status within Europe while contesting secular homogenization.
Southern Italian Humoral Antecedents: Vitality, Moisture, and Grace
Historical and Devotional Linkages:
The somatic logic of Maltese Catholicism shares deep historical roots with the traditional body concepts of southern Italy (encompassing regions from Abruzzo to Sicily from the 1861 Italian unification to World War II), as documented by Per Binde.
Ecclesiastically, Malta formed part of the Diocese of Sicily until the early nineteenth century.
Malta shares extensive devotional practices with southern Italy, including parish lay confraternities (which historically doubled as trade guilds), village patronal feasts (festi), and intense cultic devotion to regional saints such as Saint Agatha, Saint Lucy, and Saint Rita.
Humoral Vitality as a Limited Good:
Traditional body logics conceptualize the physical body as an open conduit of life force, or vitality, fundamentally linked to classical humoral medicine.
Bodily vitality is intrinsically associated with moisture and humidity.
This vital humidity is treated as a limited good; every human being is born with an allotted, finite quantity of moisture.
Aging is conceptualized as an irreversible process of progressive drying; physical death and deceased bodies are defined by absolute dryness.
The Porous Economy of the Body:
Because the body is an open system, its internal moisture balance is subject to external disruption and depletion:
Dry, thirsty supernatural entities, such as witches and demons, are understood to actively prey upon living bodies to suck up or drain vital moisture.
Depleted vitality can be replenished through the consumption of moisture-rich foods, close physical contact with living animals or animal parts, bathing in natural bodies of water (dew, rivers, lakes, the sea), or direct devotional contact with saints.
Grace (Grazia) as Spiritual Vitality:
Grazia (grace) is understood as an unlimited, divine life force embodied by the saints.
Grace functions as a direct complement to, and under certain circumstances a substitute for, somatic vitality.
When physical vitality declines, grace enters the porous body to fill the resulting void. This structural substitution underpins the logic of Catholic asceticism, wherein ascetics voluntarily mortify or sap their physical vitality to facilitate an inflow of divine grace.
Bodily suffering is inherently virtuous because it empties the person of somatic vitality, generating the necessary interior void to receive divine grazia.
Unlike the finite humidity of mortal humans, the spiritual grace held by saints is inexhaustible.
Saints—having attained holiness through earthly self-mortification, enduring intense bodily suffering, or dying as martyrs—possess an infinite reserve of grazia in the heavenly realm, which they dispense back to the physical world via intercessory action in response to human devotion, prayers, and votive commitments.
Saintly Presence (Praesentia) and Sacred Materiality
The Genealogy of Presence in Catholicism:
Catholic theology and practice have maintained an enduring concern with the immediate, earthly manifestation of the sacred (praesentia).
Peter Brown traces this phenomenon to late antiquity (third and fourth centuries CE), during which major pilgrimage centers formed around the physical tombs of Christian martyrs and living ascetics (holy hermits).
These locations functioned as spatial contact zones where pilgrims experienced the unmediated power and grazia of the saints through physical proximity to their praesentia.
Transmissibility Through Relics and Images:
Praesentia is not spatially confined to primary burial sites; it is fully retained within the smallest bodily relic or personal possession of a holy person.
Furthermore, holy images and statues are understood not as passive signifiers, but as active ontological conduits of presence.
Affirmed through theological councils and reiterated in post–Vatican II doctrine (and the Catechism of the Catholic Church, art. 2132), the honor paid to an image passes directly to its heavenly prototype.
Reciprocally, the divine grazia radiating from the prototype flows downward through the physical artifact directly into the venerating devotee.
Medicine, Surgery, and Bodily Porosity in Contemporary Malta
The "Irruption of the Sacred" in Clinical Spaces:
In 2009, anthropologist Jean-Paul Baldacchino observed this dynamic inside Malta's modern general hospital, Mater Dei Hospital.
While observing the high-tech, clinical environment, the secular routine was interrupted by a ringing bell signaling the arrival of a woman in a clinical white laboratory coat accompanied by a hospital orderly, carrying a chalice and the Eucharist to administer Holy Communion to inpatients.
Despite its state-of-the-art biomedical character, the institution is dedicated to Mater Dei (Mother of God) and is thoroughly populated with Catholic physical paraphernalia, including crucifixes, statues, and shrines.
Maltese Amputees and Sacramental Suffering:
Victoria Sultana's clinical ethnography of Maltese amputees highlights how biomedical procedures are integrated into Catholic understandings of bodily loss, vitality, death, and resurrection.
Initial anxieties that the new, sterile architecture of Mater Dei would purge religious iconography were dispelled when hospital wards and corridors were systematically repopulated with sacred images.
Four months post-inauguration, a large seventeenth-century antique crucifix that had historically hung in Malta's prior hospitals was transferred to Mater Dei, symbolically reuniting the Son with the Mother.
Amputees interpret physical limb loss through the framework of redemptive suffering: physical pain is consciously unified with the Passion and death of Jesus Christ to accumulate merits in heaven.
Case of Louisa: A bilateral amputee who lost her limbs to meningitis. Upon a bedside recovery visit from the Archbishop of Malta and the hospital chaplain, the Archbishop refrained from offering an ordinary blessing and instead asked Louisa to pray for him, formally acknowledging the extraordinary state of grazia she had attained through radical bodily suffering and somatic depletion.
The experience of bodily illness and surgical mutilation functions sacramentally: because Catholic sacraments rely on physical matter, gestures, and corporeal presence, the mutilated or suffering body mirrors the wounded bodies of canonical saints and Christ depicted in devotional art.
The Dynamics of Saintly Negotiation and Reciprocity:
Amputees and patients maintain reciprocal, contractual relationships (negotiations) with specific saints, who specialize in targeted anatomical regions or clinical pathologies:
Saint Agatha: Invoked for breast diseases and afflictions, linked to her martyrological torture involving breast excision.
Saint Blaise: A physician turned bishop, invoked for laryngeal and throat ailments.
Saint Lucy: Invoked for ocular illnesses and blindness.
Saint Anthony: Specialized in locating lost items, frequently petitioned for general deliverance.
The Economy of Vows (Weghda): Petitioners promise specific sacrifices or devotional exchanges in return for intercession:
One cardiac patient paid to Saint Anthony after his cardiologist determined that he no longer required surgical intervention.
Devotees make a weghda to walk completely barefoot in annual penance during the national procession of Our Lady of Sorrows (Id-Duluri), honoring Mary's suffering at the Crucifixion.
Votive Offerings (Ex-voto): Tangible manifestations of gratitude delivered to shrines, traditionally taking the form of silver replicas of healed organs/limbs (legs, eyes, hearts, chests), paintings, jewelry, or textiles.
In contemporary biomedical contexts, ex-voto offerings include clinical artifacts: orthopedic casts, splints, crutches, accompanied by photographs and letters of thanksgiving detailing the medical turnaround.
Within the hospital space, the body is not experienced as a bounded, closed Cartesian mechanism, but as an open, porous site directly linked through prayer and intercession to divine agencies.
Institutional Verification: The Canonization of Saint Gorg Preca
Dun Gorg Preca (1880–1962):
Canonized in 2007, Dun Gorg Preca is the first recognized Maltese saint.
During his life, he operated as a reforming priest who founded the Society of Christian Doctrine (known locally as the MUSEUM), a lay apostolate aimed at providing free religious instruction and Maltese-language catechism to working-class children.
He was celebrated across opposing factions of the polarized Maltese political spectrum as a "man of the people" and an "apostle of the workers," positioning his figure as a symbol of national unity during intense colonial-era educational disputes with British authorities.
The Qualifying Retinal Miracle (1964):
The first of two Vatican-approved miracles required for Preca's canonization involved Charles Zammit Endrich, a myopic Maltese man suffering from severe retinal detachment.
Endrich underwent corrective ophthalmic surgery performed by Dr. Censu Tabone—a distinguished ophthalmic surgeon who later served as the President of Malta. The surgical intervention failed, resulting in a recurrence of the detachment, and a second operation was scheduled.
Prior to the subsequent surgery, a member of the MUSEUM visited Endrich and brought a shoelace that had been worn by the late Dun Gorg Preca.
The shoelace relic was placed underneath Endrich's pillow (or directly against his cheek, according to variant accounts) while prayers were made requesting Preca's divine intercession.
Upon clinical re-examination, Dr. Tabone discovered that the detached retina had spontaneously and completely reattached without surgical intervention.
Dr. Tabone provided formal medical testimony confirming that in his extensive professional career and across the peer-reviewed medical literature, he had never documented a case of spontaneous retinal recovery under identical pathology, affirming the occurrence of an inexplicable healing attributed to Dun Gorg's intercession.
The Role of the Vatican's Consulta Medica:
Evidence of the cure was subjected to rigorous empirical evaluation by the Consulta Medica (the Vatican's specialized medical council charged with assessing claimed miracles for beatification and canonization).
The Church's miracle-adjudication apparatus functions through hyper-rationalist, empiricist, and materialist scientific protocols: it applies deductive reasoning, biomedical causation, and rigid scientific falsification to confirm that an event defies all known natural explanations.
Rather than existing as polar opposites, Catholic modernity oscillates continuously between empirical scientific rationalism and deep somatic mysticism.
Because Preca was an uncontroversial, venerated national icon whose miracle was authenticated by an elite medical authority who became the head of state, his saintly porosity was fully embraced as harmonious with modern national identity.
Visionary Phenomenology and Contestation: Angelik Caruana at Borg-in-Nadur
The Lacrimation of the Marian Statue (2006):
Angelik Caruana, a working-class southern Maltese man from a dock-working background, had belonged to Preca's MUSEUM movement in his youth before marrying his wife, Catherine, and settling in the coastal village of Birzebuggia.
In January 2006, Catherine purchased a commercial statue of Our Lady of the Immaculate Conception from a local shop for , paying in installments while purchasing kitchen paint.
Within days of being situated in the family home, the statue began weeping apparent tears of blood.
The local ecclesiastical authorities (the Curia) confiscated the statue for laboratory analysis. While forensic testing affirmed that the liquid was real blood, the weeping abruptly ceased while the statue was under ecclesiastical custody, leading authorities to conclude there was no affirmative proof of supernatural etiology.
Upon the statue's return to the Caruana residence, the lacrimations resumed.
Acting on Curia advice, the family sealed the statue inside a glass display case to eliminate the possibility of human tampering.
Months later, the glass box shattered outward from within, accompanied by the spontaneous exudence of salt and oil from its base.
In Catholic somatic logic, weeping statues represent physical leaks of excessive grazia; when an object cannot contain the volume of grace channeled from its celestial prototype, it discharges revitalizing and curative bodily fluids.
Visions and the Establishment of Borg-in-Nadur:
In April 2006, Angelik experienced his first vision: while displaying a photograph of the weeping statue to domestic visitors, he lost consciousness and perceived a brilliant light containing a heavenly woman who implored him to promote conversion through the recitation of the Rosary.
Visions subsequently manifested during meetings of Mir (the Croatian word for "peace"), a Catholic Charismatic Renewal prayer group formed following a 2005 pilgrimage to Medjugorje that emphasized continuous spiritual conversion.
In December 2006, Angelik reported that the Virgin Mary instructed him to establish an open-air shrine upon the nearby prehistoric hill-temple site of Borg-in-Nadur, outside Birzebuggia.
Six married couples from the Mir group formed a dedicated lay cenacle designated as Theotokos (the Greek theological title for Mary, "God-bearer").
The cenacle erected a monumental crucifix and altar atop the hill, where recurring, highly publicized apparitions of "Our Lady of Borg-in-Nadur" attracted crowds of up to 1,000 people.
Sensory and Mimetic Markers of the Visionary State:
Sensory Indices of the Holy: Apparitions are signaled by physical markers perceived by both Angelik and attendees, including sudden sensations of intense radiant heat, blinding white light, and a sweet, distinct floral odor.
Sensory Indices of the Demonic: Demonic assaults are preceded by sensations of extreme freezing cold, tactile attacks, and foul odors resembling burning tires.
Mimesis and Trance: During visions, Angelik embodies the physical postures of the crucified Christ or the Virgin Mary; in December 2014, he engaged in prolonged tactile gestures of cradling an invisible infant Christ.
Ecstatic Analgesia: Entering an altered state of consciousness conceptualized as being filled with the spirit (mimli bl'is-Spirtu), Angelik's normal sensory faculties are completely suspended. He experiences total analgesia, displaying no physiological response to external tactile pain or intense light stimulation.
Ecclesiastical Protocols and Initial Investigation:
Under the Vatican's 1978 criteria established by the Sacred Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, alleged apparitions are judged via three core indices:
The moral character and mental stability of the visionary.
The strict theological and doctrinal accuracy of the messages.
The positive spiritual and devotional fruits generated by the occurrences.
If these conditions are preliminarily met, authorities may issue a ruling of pro nunc nihil obstare ("For now, nothing stands in the way").
The Curia informally delegated monitoring of the Borg-in-Nadur events to internal personnel: a local Capuchin friar (the spiritual director of Mir) provided doctrinal guidance, later joined by a Jesuit priest who reported directly to the Curia.
A UK-trained Maltese psychiatrist was appointed as the official scientific investigator for the Theotokos cenacle, tasked with ruling out schizophrenia, dissociative disorders, or delusional states while recording witness testimonies.
The Public Sphere, Scientific Expertise, and Class Politics
Mediatization on Maltese Television (Xarabank):
The Theotokos cenacle publicized Angelik's messages, visionary events, and physical manifestations via a dedicated blog and YouTube.
In May 2007, the national investigative current-affairs television program Xarabank launched the first of three prime-time specials examining the Angelik Caruana controversy.
Structure of Xarabank: Operating as a weekly, two-hour-plus Friday night broadcast, the show blends investigative documentary footage, studio expert debates, dynamic studio audience interventions, and live nationwide telephone and social-media voting. The show reflects Malta's small-scale public sphere, where media, national politics, and face-to-face community networks directly intersect.
Scientific and Forensic Polarities on National Television:
Forensic Segment (Broadcast One): A forensic scientist analyzed the weeping statue and the ruptured glass display box. He concluded that the bloodstains on the face of the Virgin matched the DNA profile of Angelik Caruana himself and appeared to have been manually smeared onto the surface rather than exuding from the porcelain. Furthermore, impact analysis indicated that the glass box had been struck forcefully from the exterior rather than exploding outward from internal pressure. A prominent journalist defended the authenticity of the phenomena, while Angelik refused to appear.
Psychiatric Segment (Broadcast Two): The Theotokos scientific investigator presented clinical evaluations conducted on Angelik during ecstasy. To demonstrate sensory suspension, the broadcast showed video footage of the psychiatrist driving a needle into Angelik's eye and flashing direct lights onto his pupils without eliciting an involuntary reflex. The psychiatrist concluded that there was no evidence of fraud or psychopathology, asserting that the only plausible etiology was supernatural and divine.
The Counter-Expert Reaction: A senior Maltese medical consultant, who was also a prominent national political figure, publicly challenged the Theotokos psychiatrist during the broadcast, diagnosing Angelik's behaviors as psychiatric symptoms and issuing an overt professional warning regarding the reputational damage the psychiatrist risked by attributing them to the divine.
Social Class, Linguistic Prestige, and "Gracelessness":
Public skepticism targeted Angelik's working-class background, southern rural accent, and alleged history of debt and criminality.
Detractors categorized Angelik using the derogatory Maltese class label hamallu (an uncultured, rough, or uneducated working-class person).
Critics questioned his spiritual credibility through the somatic idiom of grace: as one interlocutor articulated, "How can it be . . . he's such a graceless man [ragel bla-grazju]." The underlying logic dictated that an individual in continuous physical communion with the Virgin Mary ought to visibly exude somatic grazia and elite social refinement.
Prominent cultural commentators and journalists attacked the Borg-in-Nadur gatherings as "medieval hysteria," arguing that the crédulous acceptance of such spectacles compromised Malta's reputation as a progressive, modern European nation-state.
The Politics of Porousness
Sociological versus Ontological Divergence:
The divergent public receptions of Saint Gorg Preca's miracles versus Angelik Caruana's apparitions demonstrate that the boundaries of secular modernity are sociological and political rather than purely ontological.
Both cases are fundamentally structured by identical ontological premises of the porous Catholic sensorium: human bodies, physical relics, and devotional objects are treated as vulnerable to external spiritual incursions and capable of channeling divine grazia.
Elite Legitimation and Class Hegemony:
For the porous self to be accepted as compatible with contemporary modernity, it must be legitimized through elite institutional authority and verified by secular, scientific expertise.
The oscillation within contemporary Catholicism between mystical populist religiosity and rigorous empirical rationalism is fundamentally mediated by social class:
Dun Gorg Preca: An elite national historical icon and pioneer of mass education whose qualifying miracle was verified by an eminent medical professor and future national president (Dr. Censu Tabone) and rubber-stamped by the Vatican's prestigious Consulta Medica.
Angelik Caruana: A working-class dockland native defended only by a populist television psychiatrist, who was contested by state forensic experts, senior medical authorities, and the formal ecclesiastical hierarchy.
Modernity and secularity do not mark the absolute extinction of bodily porosity; rather, they function as contested political narratives that communities continuously reconcile with local histories, devotional traditions, and hierarchies of expertise.