(Chapter 7 CLM)Fitting of Rigid Daily Wear Contact Lenses: Complete Study Guide

Historical Evolution of Rigid Contact Lenses

  • Contact lens designs date back over 100 years to A. Eugen Fick, who created a lens made of glass with a radius of curvature of 8.0 mm8.0\,\text{mm}. This was termed a scleral lens because it covered both the cornea and the anterior sclera.

  • In the 1930s, Theodore Obrig introduced the manufacture of scleral lenses using a plastic called polymethylmethacrylate (PMMA).

  • In 1947, Kevin Tuohy designed large-diameter corneal lenses made of PMMA, initiating a new era in contact lens design. PMMA lens fitting achieved broad popularity during the 1960s.

  • Until the early 1970s, standard PMMA contact lens fitting utilized lens diameters between 9.0 mm9.0\,\text{mm} and 10.0 mm10.0\,\text{mm}. These lenses were fitted flatter than the flattest corneal meridian (flatter than "K").

  • Through the mid-1970s, small-diameter, ultra-thin PMMA designs became common, featuring diameters ranging from 8.0 mm8.0\,\text{mm} to 8.8 mm8.8\,\text{mm}.

  • In the late 1970s, gas permeable (GP) lenses were introduced, causing a decline in PMMA usage. Today, gas permeable materials dominate the rigid contact lens field.

  • From the late 1970s through the late 1980s, silicone acrylate materials were primarily used for GP contact lenses.

  • Modern gas permeable lenses predominantly use fluorinated silicone acrylate materials. Current GP materials offer varying DkDk values (oxygen permeability) and wetting angles, enabling customization based on individual patient requirements.

Rigid Contact Lens Fitting Philosophies Overview

  • Modern gas permeable materials allow safe fitting across diverse lens designs.

  • While fitting approaches vary among practitioners, contemporary GP fitting adheres to two main methodologies:

    • Apical Clearance Philosophy

    • Corneal Alignment Philosophy

Apical Clearance Fitting Philosophy

  • Lens/Cornea Relationship: The base curve is designed steeper than the flattest corneal meridian (steeper than "K"), with an overall lens diameter between 8.0 mm8.0\,\text{mm} and 9.0 mm9.0\,\text{mm}.

  • Centration: The lens is designed to center on the cornea and position intrapalpebrally.

The apical clearance fitting philosophy
  • Fluorescein Pattern:

    • Central area: Fluorescein pooling centrally.

    • Transitional zone: Slightly less fluorescein.

    • Peripheral area: Intense fluorescein pooling where secondary and peripheral curves are applied to the posterior side of the lens.

  • Lens Dynamics: Lens movement is produced by blinking, with excursions measuring approximately 2.0 mm2.0\,\text{mm} to 2.5 mm2.5\,\text{mm}. The lens remains relatively central throughout a 4 to 6 second4\,\text{to}\,6\,\text{second} blink cycle.

  • Indications:

    • Patients with extremely small palpebral fissures.

    • Patients with excessively tight upper eyelids.

    • High myopes exhibiting a high-riding lens that encroaches on the sclera.

    • Existing successful wearers of apical clearance lenses requiring replacement due to prescription changes or lens loss.

  • Diagnostic Lens Parameter Selection:

    • Initial diagnostic parameters are established using central keratometric readings based on corneal diameter and corneal toricity.

    • Corneal Diameter Selection Rules (Table 1):

    • Large corneas (≥12.0 mm\ge 12.0\,\text{mm}): Lens diameter 8.8 mm8.8\,\text{mm} to 9.0 mm9.0\,\text{mm} (Table standard: 9.0 mm9.0\,\text{mm}).

    • Average corneas (11.0 mm11.0\,\text{mm} or 11.5 mm11.5\,\text{mm}): Lens diameter 8.3 mm8.3\,\text{mm} to 8.7 mm8.7\,\text{mm} (Table standard: 8.5 mm8.5\,\text{mm}).

    • Small corneas (≤10.5 mm\le 10.5\,\text{mm}): Lens diameter 7.8 mm7.8\,\text{mm} to 8.2 mm8.2\,\text{mm} (Table standard: 8.0 mm8.0\,\text{mm}).

    • Corneal Curvature Diameter Rule: Corneas exceeding 45.00 D45.00\,\text{D} perform better with smaller diameters; corneas flatter than 41.00 D41.00\,\text{D} perform better with larger diameters.

    • Base Curve Selection Rules (Table 2):

    • 0.00 D−0.75 D0.00\,\text{D} - 0.75\,\text{D} corneal cylinder: 0.25 D0.25\,\text{D} STK (Steeper Than K).

    • 0.87 D−1.50 D0.87\,\text{D} - 1.50\,\text{D} corneal cylinder: 0.50 D0.50\,\text{D} STK.

    • 1.62 D−2.50 D1.62\,\text{D} - 2.50\,\text{D} corneal cylinder: 0.75 D0.75\,\text{D} STK.

    • 2.62 D−3.50 D2.62\,\text{D} - 3.50\,\text{D} corneal cylinder: 1.00 D1.00\,\text{D} STK.

    • >3.50 D> 3.50\,\text{D} corneal cylinder: Consider toric base curve.

  • Optical Zone Diameter (OZD) Specifications:

    • OZD is derived from total diameter. Peripheral curves, blends, and edge finishing account for approximately 1.2 mm1.2\,\text{mm} of total lens diameter.

    • Formula: OZD=Total Lens Diameter−Total Width of Peripheral Curves\text{OZD} = \text{Total Lens Diameter} - \text{Total Width of Peripheral Curves}.

    • Example: An 8.5 mm8.5\,\text{mm} overall diameter lens yields a 7.3 mm7.3\,\text{mm} optical zone (8.5 mm−1.2 mm=7.3 mm8.5\,\text{mm} - 1.2\,\text{mm} = 7.3\,\text{mm}).

  • Sagittal Depth and Power Relationships:

A change in radius must accompany a change in diameter if the sagittal depth is to remain the same
  • Changing OZD alters sagittal depth and lens fit.

  • Offset rule: Every 0.1 mm0.1\,\text{mm} change in diameter must be offset by a 0.01 mm0.01\,\text{mm} change in base curve radius to maintain equivalent fitting relationships.

  • Power change conversion: Every 0.05 mm0.05\,\text{mm} change in radius corresponds to approximately 0.25 D0.25\,\text{D} change in power.

  • Worked Example: A lens has a diameter of 8.4 mm8.4\,\text{mm} and a base curve of 7.5 mm7.5\,\text{mm}. If diameter increases to 8.6 mm8.6\,\text{mm} (+0.2 mm+0.2\,\text{mm}), the base curve must be modified to 7.52 mm7.52\,\text{mm} (+0.02 mm+0.02\,\text{mm} radius change). The diameter increase tightens the fit, and the radius increase compensates by loosening the fit.

  • Optical zone maintenance: If an 8.4 mm8.4\,\text{mm} lens has a 7.2 mm7.2\,\text{mm} OZD, increasing total diameter to 8.6 mm8.6\,\text{mm} requires increasing OZD to 7.4 mm7.4\,\text{mm} to maintain proportionate fitting.

    • Lens Center Thickness Rules:

  • Apical clearance lenses perform best with the thinnest center thickness that does not flex on the eye.

  • If lens flexure occurs, increase the manufacturer's suggested minimum center thickness by 0.04 mm0.04\,\text{mm}.

Corneal Alignment Fitting Philosophy

  • Lens/Cornea Relationship: Preferred by many fitters, this design parallels the superior cornea with the peripheral lens tucked under the upper eyelid ("upper lid attachment").

  • Lens Dynamics: Movement is under direct control of the upper eyelid, occurring only upon blinking.

  • Patient Adaptation: Provides less lid awareness, resulting in a more natural blink rate and lid closure compared to intrapalpebral designs.

The corneal alignment fitting philosophy
  • Lens Parameters:

    • Overall diameter: Typically 9.2 mm9.2\,\text{mm} to 9.6 mm9.6\,\text{mm} (Standard starting diameter for average eyes: 9.5 mm9.5\,\text{mm}).

    • Base curve: Fit 0.50 D0.50\,\text{D} to 1.50 D1.50\,\text{D} flatter than "K".

  • Clinical Benefits: Provides stable visual acuity, reduced optical flare, rapid adaptation, and reduced peripheral corneal desiccation.

  • Base Curve Selection Rules (Table 3 - 9.5 mm9.5\,\text{mm} Total Diameter / 8.0 mm8.0\,\text{mm} OZD Standard):

    • 0.00 D−0.75 D0.00\,\text{D} - 0.75\,\text{D} corneal cylinder: 1.00 D1.00\,\text{D} FTK (Flatter Than K).

    • 0.87 D−1.25 D0.87\,\text{D} - 1.25\,\text{D} corneal cylinder: 0.75 D0.75\,\text{D} FTK.

    • 1.37 D−1.75 D1.37\,\text{D} - 1.75\,\text{D} corneal cylinder: 0.50 D0.50\,\text{D} FTK.

    • 1.87 D−2.25 D1.87\,\text{D} - 2.25\,\text{D} corneal cylinder: 0.25 D0.25\,\text{D} FTK.

    • 2.37 D−2.75 D2.37\,\text{D} - 2.75\,\text{D} corneal cylinder: On K.

    • 2.87 D−3.50 D2.87\,\text{D} - 3.50\,\text{D} corneal cylinder: 0.25 D0.25\,\text{D} STK (Steeper Than K).

    • >3.50 D> 3.50\,\text{D} corneal cylinder: Consider toric base curve.

  • Optical Zone Diameter (OZD) Specifications:

    • Designed 1.0 mm1.0\,\text{mm} to 1.5 mm1.5\,\text{mm} smaller than overall lens diameter.

    • Alternative fitting design rule: Set OZD equal to the base curve radius in millimeters (e.g., base curve radius of 7.5 mm7.5\,\text{mm} yields an OZD of 7.5 mm7.5\,\text{mm}).

    • Compensation rules: A smaller OZD than stipulated in Table 3 mandates a steeper base curve; a larger OZD mandates a flatter base curve selection.

  • Center Thickness Rules: Fit with the minimum allowable center thickness for the chosen GP material.

Lens Flexure, Edge Design, and Patient Selection

  • Alignment Fit Evaluation:

    • Fluorescein pattern should show minimal apical clearance. Significant apical pooling negates the benefits of an alignment fit.

    • Base curves fit steeper than necessary cause lens flexure, reducing visual acuity (especially with minimum center thickness lenses).

    • Methods to Detect Flexure:

    1. Keratometry over the contact lens: Observe for changes or distortion in the mire reflections.

    2. Retinoscopy: Observe for dulling or distortion of the reflex immediately after a blink.

    • Methods to Alleviate Flexure:

    • Flatten the base curve by 0.50 D0.50\,\text{D} or 0.75 D0.75\,\text{D}.

    • If flexure persists after flattening, increase center thickness by 0.04 mm0.04\,\text{mm}.

  • Contraindications for Alignment Fitting:

    • Alignment fitting requires the superior lid to position below the limbus, covering the superior cornea.

    • If a patient's upper lid is positioned excessively high and does not cover the superior cornea, alignment fitting is contraindicated.

  • Edge Profile and Recontouring:

    • Edge quality is critical to fitting success. Optimum edge thickness ranges from 0.08 mm0.08\,\text{mm} to 0.12 mm0.12\,\text{mm}.

    • Lens awareness is the primary complaint among GP wearers. Fitters must be capable of polishing and recontouring edge profiles to achieve patient comfort.

  • Patient Selection Criteria:

    • Ideal candidates possess adequate tear film stability and good motivation.

    • GP lenses correct both spherical and astigmatic refractive errors.

    • Advantages over Soft Lenses: Superior visual acuity, longer lifespan, higher durability, ease of handling, and lower risk of pathological tissue reactions.

    • Corneal Astigmatism Neutralization: The lacrimal lens formed beneath a GP lens neutralizes anterior corneal surface cylinder. Highly effective for irregular corneal astigmatism, including keratoconus, traumatized corneas, and corneal dystrophies.

    • Adaptation and Disadvantages: Requires an initial adaptation period due to foreign body sensation. Highly active individuals or athletes may prefer soft lenses to prevent lens dislodgement or debris entrapment.

Optics of Rigid Lenses and Spectacle Rx Transposition

  • Transposition: Spectacle prescriptions must be transposed into minus cylinder form. The liquid tear lens beneath the rigid contact lens neutralizes the minus cylinder, leaving only the spherical component of the spectacle prescription to be incorporated into the contact lens.

  • Worked Example:

    • Spectacle Rx: −3.00−1.00×180-3.00 -1.00 \times 180, Keratometry: 43.00 @ 180/44.00 @ 9043.00\,@\,180 / 44.00\,@\,90.

    • Placing a GP lens with a 43.00 D43.00\,\text{D} base curve on this cornea creates a tear layer with a −1.00 D-1.00\,\text{D} cylinder at axis 180, neutralizing the spectacle cylinder.

    • Contact lens power required: −3.00 D-3.00\,\text{D} sphere.

  • Vertex Distance Compensation:

    • Moving an ophthalmic lens closer to the eye (from spectacle plane to corneal plane) increases its effective minus power (shortens focal length).

    • Spectacle prescriptions moved to the corneal plane must be made more plus. Standard vertex distance conversion tables are utilized for calculations.

Calculated Residual Astigmatism (CRA) and the 25% Rule

  • Definition: Residual astigmatism is the cylindrical error remaining after a spherical GP contact lens is placed on the eye (the difference between spectacle refractive cylinder and corneal cylinder).

  • Etiology: Primarily caused by astigmatism on the crystalline lens (lenticular astigmatism), though aphakic eyes can also demonstrate residual astigmatism.

  • Formula for Calculated Residual Astigmatism:   CRA=Refractive Cylinder−Corneal Cylinder\text{CRA} = \text{Refractive Cylinder} - \text{Corneal Cylinder}

  • CRA Calculation Examples:

    • Example 1:

    • Rx: −3.00−1.75×180-3.00 -1.75 \times 180, K's: 42.00 @ 180/43.75 @ 9042.00\,@\,180 / 43.75\,@\,90

    • Refractive Cylinder: −1.75×180-1.75 \times 180

    • Corneal Cylinder: −1.75×180-1.75 \times 180

    • CRA=−1.75−(−1.75)=0.00 D\text{CRA} = -1.75 - (-1.75) = 0.00\,\text{D}

    • Example 2:

    • Rx: −5.00−2.00×180-5.00 -2.00 \times 180, K's: 42.00 @ 180/45.00 @ 9042.00\,@\,180 / 45.00\,@\,90

    • Refractive Cylinder: −2.00×180-2.00 \times 180

    • Corneal Cylinder: −3.00×180-3.00 \times 180

    • CRA=−2.00−(−3.00)=+1.00×180 D\text{CRA} = -2.00 - (-3.00) = +1.00 \times 180\,\text{D}

    • Example 3:

    • Rx: +4.00−1.50×90+4.00 -1.50 \times 90, K's: 41.00 @ 180/40.00 @ 9041.00\,@\,180 / 40.00\,@\,90

    • Refractive Cylinder: −1.50×90-1.50 \times 90

    • Corneal Cylinder: −1.00×90-1.00 \times 90

    • CRA=−1.50−(−1.00)=−0.50×90 D\text{CRA} = -1.50 - (-1.00) = -0.50 \times 90\,\text{D}

  • Tolerance and The 25% Rule:

    • Residual astigmatism under 1.00 D1.00\,\text{D} is usually tolerated without compromising visual acuity.

    • The 25% Rule Calculation: Multiply calculated residual astigmatism by 4 (4×CRA4 \times \text{CRA}). If the product is less than the spherical power component of the spectacle Rx, the residual astigmatism will not adversely affect visual acuity and can be managed via spherical equivalent modification.

    • Example:

    • Rx: −4.00−1.00×180-4.00 -1.00 \times 180, K's: 43.00 @ 180/44.75 @ 9043.00\,@\,180 / 44.75\,@\,90

    • Refractive Cylinder: −1.00×180-1.00 \times 180

    • Corneal Cylinder: −1.75×180-1.75 \times 180

    • CRA=+0.75×180 D\text{CRA} = +0.75 \times 180\,\text{D}

    • Apply 25% Rule: +0.75×4=3.00 D+0.75 \times 4 = 3.00\,\text{D}

    • Evaluation: Since 3.00 D<4.00 D3.00\,\text{D} < 4.00\,\text{D} (sphere power), the residual error is acceptable.

    • If residual astigmatism exceeds acceptable thresholds, cylindrical contact lens correction (toric base curve/front surface) is indicated.

    • Tolerance of residual astigmatism under 1.00 D1.00\,\text{D} must be confirmed using diagnostic over-refraction in situ.

Determination of Flattest Corneal Meridian and Tear Film Compensation (SAM vs. FAP)

  • Flattest Meridian Principles:

    • The flattest principal corneal meridian directly corresponds to the spherical component of a spectacle Rx written in minus cylinder form.

    • Fitting "On K" (paralleling base curve to flattest meridian) yields a tear lens with plano sphere power; lens power equals spectacle sphere power.

    • Example 1: Rx −3.00−2.00×180-3.00 -2.00 \times 180, K's 45.00 @ 180/47.00 @ 9045.00\,@\,180 / 47.00\,@\,90. Base curve of 45.00 D45.00\,\text{D} ("On K") requires −3.00 D-3.00\,\text{D} sphere lens power.

    • Example 2: Rx +3.00−1.50×175+3.00 -1.50 \times 175, K's 44.50 @ 175/46.00 @ 8544.50\,@\,175 / 46.00\,@\,85. Base curve of 44.50 D44.50\,\text{D} ("On K") requires +3.00 D+3.00\,\text{D} sphere lens power.

  • Tear Film Compensation Rules:

Tear lens power creation with flatter or steeper base curves
  • Deviations from flat "K" induce spherical power in the fluid tear lens:

    • Steeper Add Minus (SAM): Fitting a base curve steeper than flat "K" creates a plus power tear lens. To compensate, add minus power to the contact lens prescription.

    • Flatter Add Plus (FAP): Fitting a base curve flatter than flat "K" creates a minus power tear lens. To compensate, add plus power to the contact lens prescription.

  • FAP Worked Example:

    • Rx: −2.00−1.00×180-2.00 -1.00 \times 180, K's: 41.00 @ 180/42.00 @ 9041.00\,@\,180 / 42.00\,@\,90

    • Selected Base Curve: 40.50 D40.50\,\text{D} (0.50 D0.50\,\text{D} flatter than flat K of 41.00 D41.00\,\text{D})

    • Tear Lens Power Induced: −0.50 D-0.50\,\text{D}

    • Compensation: Add +0.50 D+0.50\,\text{D} to −2.00 D-2.00\,\text{D} spectacle sphere

    • Resultant Contact Lens Power: −1.50 D-1.50\,\text{D} (FAP)

  • SAM Worked Example:

    • Rx: +2.50−1.50×180+2.50 -1.50 \times 180, K's: 43.50 @ 180/45.00 @ 9043.50\,@\,180 / 45.00\,@\,90

    • Selected Base Curve: 44.25 D44.25\,\text{D} (0.75 D0.75\,\text{D} steeper than flat K of 43.50 D43.50\,\text{D})

    • Tear Lens Power Induced: +0.75 D+0.75\,\text{D}

    • Compensation: Add −0.75 D-0.75\,\text{D} to +2.50 D+2.50\,\text{D} spectacle sphere

    • Resultant Contact Lens Power: +1.75 D+1.75\,\text{D} (SAM)

Step-by-Step Power Rules and Parameter Specifications

  • Sequential Steps for Rigid Lens Power Determination (Table 4):

    1. Transpose spectacle prescription to minus cylinder form.

    2. Compensate for vertex distance changes.

    3. Calculate residual astigmatism (CRA).

    4. Determine flattest corneal meridian.

    5. Select base curve based on fitting philosophy.

    6. Compensate for tear film power (SAM vs. FAP).

  • Complete Specification Requirements for Lens Orders:

    • Base curve radius

    • Power

    • Overall diameter

    • Optical zone diameter

    • Center thickness

    • Peripheral curve radius and width

    • Intermediate curve radius and width

    • Blend specifications

    • Edge design profile

    • Lens tint

    • Material type

Diagnostic Lens Sets and Over-Refraction Protocol

  • Diagnostic Set Requirements:

    • Base Curve Range: 7.1 mm7.1\,\text{mm} to 8.6 mm8.6\,\text{mm} in 0.10 mm0.10\,\text{mm} increments.

    • Power Range: Spherical powers of −3.00 D-3.00\,\text{D} and −7.00 D-7.00\,\text{D} to accommodate most myopic requirements, plus high dioptric power options for high myopes and hyperopes.

    • Diameters: 8.5 mm8.5\,\text{mm}, 9.0 mm9.0\,\text{mm}, and 9.5 mm9.5\,\text{mm} (to fit both apical clearance and alignment designs).

    • Thickness Profiles: Standard and ultra-thin options.

  • Over-Refraction Protocol:

    1. Insert diagnostic lens matching targeted parameters.

    2. Perform initial spherical over-refraction.

    3. If optimal visual acuity is not attained, perform sphero-cylindrical over-refraction.

    4. If adequate visual acuity is still unachievable with sphero-cylindrical over-refraction, verify base curve radius accuracy of the diagnostic lens to rule out lens warpage.

    5. Note: Diagnostic lenses that fit excessively flat and undergo significant decentration render over-refraction endpoints invalid.

Refitting PMMA Wearers with Gas Permeable Lenses

  • Etiology of PMMA-Induced Corneal Distortion:

    • Long-term PMMA wear induces corneal distortion due to two factors:

    1. Corneal Hypoxia: Main cause. The average cornea requires approximately 2%2\% oxygen out of the 21%21\% available in ambient atmosphere. PMMA's non-permeability starves the cornea of oxygen, altering corneal metabolism and causing corneal warpage (irregular corneal astigmatism).

    2. Mechanical Pressure: Physical compression from the rigid non-permeable material.

  • Clinical Signs and Symptoms:

    • Distorted or irregular keratometry mires during follow-up exams.

    • Spectacle blur (blurred or fluctuating vision when wearing glasses after contact lens removal).

    • Reduced visual acuity during manifest refraction, accompanied by significant irregular corneal astigmatism.

  • Rehabilitation Protocol:

    • Data Collection: Obtain baseline patient data prior to starting refitting, including original pre-PMMA keratometry ("K"s), prefitting spectacle Rx, and current PMMA lens parameters.

    • Immediate Refitting Requirement: Do NOT abruptly cease contact lens wear without dispensing GP lenses immediately. Corneas exposed to abrupt atmospheric oxygen increases undergo dramatic rebound, worsening corneal astigmatism and leaving the patient with uncorrectable spectacle vision.

    • Initial Parameter Selection: Base initial GP lens parameters on original pre-PMMA corneal measurements to allow corneal topography to recover toward baseline.

    • Follow-up Adjustments: Redesign lenses across multiple follow-up visits to match changing corneal topography. Multiple lens pairs may be necessary.

    • Stabilization Timeline: Corneal stabilization typically requires 3 to 4 weeks3\text{ to }4\,\text{weeks}, but severe warpage recovery can take up to 3 months3\,\text{months}.

    • Endpoint of Rehabilitation: Rehabilitation is complete when corneal topography stabilizes, verified by stable refraction endpoints and clear, crisp, repeatable keratometric mires across consecutive visits.