2/17, Lecture 9 Reading

Introduction to Nodal Signalling in Snails

  • Many animals have left–right (L–R) asymmetry in internal and external features.

  • In vertebrates, Nodal is a key molecular pathway involved in determining this asymmetry.

    • Nodal: Signalling molecule of the transforming growth factor-beta (TGF-β) superfamily.

    • Expression: Occurs in the left lateral plate mesoderm.

    • Function: Loss of Nodal function causes randomization of L–R asymmetry of visceral organs.

  • Nodal orthologues detected in some deutrostomes (e.g., ascidians, sea urchins); not found in Ecdysozoa (flies, nematodes) or Lophotrochozoa (snails, annelids).

  • This study presents the first evidence of a nodal orthologue in a non-deuterostome: snails.

Key Findings

  • Identification of Nodal and Pitx in two snail species:

    • Dextral (right-handed): Lottia gigantea.

    • Sinistral (left-handed): Biomphalaria glabrata.

Gene Expression Related to Body Chirality

  • Nodal and Pitx Expression:

    • In Lottia gigantea, both are expressed on the right side.

    • In Biomphalaria glabrata, both are expressed on the left side.

  • Pharmacological inhibition of the Nodal pathway indicated that Nodal acts upstream of Pitx.

    • Loss of shell chirality observed in some treated animals.

Evolutionary Significance of Nodal Pathway

  • The Nodal pathway's involvement in L–R asymmetry may represent an ancestral feature of Bilateria.

  • Asymmetric Nodal expression is conserved in deuterostomes:

    • Chordates: Nodal and Pitx act on the left side of the embryo.

    • Echinoderms (sea urchins): Act on the right side.

Background on Chirality in Snails

  • Snail Chirality: Body handedness and direction of shell coiling; prevalent forms are dextral and sinistral.

    • Developmental determination linked to a maternal locus controlling chirality.

  • Previous gene analysis indicated critical roles of certain genes in L–R asymmetry but Nodal signaling previously unexamined.

Methodology

  • Study involved two snail species differing in chirality:

    • B. glabrata: Intermediate host for schistosomiasis.

    • L. gigantea: Complete genome sequenced.

  • Isolated and characterized genes related to Nodal and Pitx.

Phylogenetic Analysis

  • Bayesian analyses confirmed Nodal orthologues closely related to deuterostome Nodal, not other TGF-β family members.

  • Identification of a potential Nodal orthologue in the annelid Capitella species I further supports evolutionary continuity.

Expression Patterns of Nodal and Pitx

  • Snail embryos exhibit indirect development: Trochophore -> Veliger larva stages.

  • Trochophore Stage Expression:

    • L. gigantea: Nodal expressed in two ectodermal domains on the right side.

    • B. glabrata: Nodal expressed on the left ectoderm near shell formation site.

  • Pitx Expression:

    • In L. gigantea, expressed on the right side, adjacent to Nodal expression.

    • In B. glabrata, Pitx seen in the left ectoderm, close to nodal-expressing cells.

Early Developmental Stages

  • Asymmetry in nodal transcripts first detected at the 32-cell stage.

    • Bilateral Axis: Established between 32-64 cell stage. - Nodal clearly left–right asymmetric beyond 32-cell stage.

    • Pitx expression initiated at the 64-cell stage in proximity to nodal-expressing cells.

Functional Studies Using Chemical Inhibition

  • Inhibition Method: SB-431542 used to target specific TGF-β receptors affecting Nodal signalling only.

  • Observations Post-Treatment:

    • At low concentrations (5 mM), 8% of gastrulating embryos showed non-coiling shells; at 10 mM, likelihood increased to 43%.

    • Most severe defects occurred when drug administered at the 1-16 cell stage.

  • Treatment at later stages (trochophore or later) led to normal shell coiling.

  • Drug exposure before blastula stage is crucial for L–R asymmetry implications on shell formation.

Results from Additional Drug Testing

  • Employing rapamycin did not yield non-coiled shells, indicating a specific Nodal role.

  • Pitx expression in drug-treated embryos showed significant reduction in asymmetric regions but maintained standard symmetric expression.

Evolutionary Insights

  • Nodal's asymmetric expression is posited to be an ancestral trait within Bilateria.

  • Evidence suggests L. gigantea and B. glabrata share a common ancestor with dextral traits.

Conclusions and Future Directions

  • Nodal and Pitx's relationship could reveal new insights into development and morphology of snails.

  • Future studies needed to further delineate how Nodal operates and regulates chirality and asymmetry during early embryonic development.

Methods Summary

  • Search for TGF-β family members in L. gigantea's genome via NCBI.

  • Phylogenetic analysis employed for relation assessments among identified Nodal genes. - In Situ Hybridization: Techniques for gene expression verification. - Chemical Treatments: Specific inhibitors to test the effects on development.