Edwin E. Wagner’s The Hand Test: Comprehensive Study Notes

Historical Development and Theoretical Foundations of the Hand Test

The Hand Test originated in 1959, developed by Edwin E. Wagner through his professional interest in the projection of aggression responses. Wagner sought a projective medium capable of reflecting action tendencies similar to those found in Rorschach human movement responses but specifically related to interpersonal interactions. He selected pictures of hands as the primary medium for this purpose. The first exploratory research published by Wagner utilized hand drawings to differentiate between normal individuals and those with schizophrenia. In 1962, Bricklin, Pictrowski, and Wagner released a monograph that established the initial scoring system and rationale, specifically applying the test to the assessment of aggressive behavior across diverse demographic groups. Later, a manual was produced featuring a slightly modified and expanded scoring system. The theoretical underpinning of the test is a classification system based on how a human organism interacts with two primary domains: other living things and inanimate objects. Consequently, the test features two major scoring categories: Interpersonal and Environmental. These are further subdivided into specific modes of interaction. Furthermore, if a subject fails to carry through prototypal action tendencies due to internal weakness, it results in a maladjustment score. Severe pathological reactions involving disintegration are expressed through an inability to project appropriate actions. The original monograph noted that clinical inference could link specific responses to defensive systems, such as a hand holding a "poison pellet" indicating obsessional or sadistic traits, a "fearful hand protecting itself" representing phobic reactions, or a "performing hand" suggesting hysterical trends, though Wagner emphasized that these requires verification through research rather than clinical inference alone.

Introduction and Administration Procedures

The Hand Test is a projective technique widely utilized to measure action tendencies, with a specific focus on acting-out and aggressive behavior in both adults and children who are at least 5 years of age. The materials consist of 10 bound cards measuring 3.3×4.53.3 \times 4.5 inches. Nine of these cards feature simple line drawings of a single hand in various positions, while the tenth card is blank. The subject is required to project by describing what the hands in the drawings are doing; for the final blank card, the subject must imagine a hand and describe its action. Administration typically takes only 10 minutes and is considered nonthreatening, making it an ideal starting point for diagnostic personality evaluations. During administration, the examiner records the responses, the initial response time (IRT) for each card, and any other significant behaviors. The test utilizes relatively structured stimuli (hand pictures) in relatively unstructured poses to permit individual variations while restricting responses to definable categories including hand actions and attitudes. This is based on the assumption that the hand is genetically and functionally crucial for interacting with the external world and provides more kinesthetic feedback and intraindividual information than other sensory organs like the eyes or ears. While it can be used with anyone old enough to verbalize, protocols for younger subjects should be analyzed with reservation. Standard rapport-building precautions are recommended, though lengthy preliminaries are rarely necessary as the test elicits little anxiety.

Scoring Category I: Interpersonal Responses (∑INT\sum INT)

Interpersonal responses (INT) involve relations with other people and are viewed as overt behavioral tendencies rather than mere fantasy processes. A lack of INT responses suggests a psychic life devoid of meaningful interpersonal roles. This category is divided into six sub-categories. Affection (AFF) involves interpersonal responses with an interchange or bestowment of pleasure or friendly feelings. Examples include "waving to a friend," "shaking hands," or "a nurse's comforting hand." Dependence (DEP) involves expressed need for succor or subordination to secure care. Examples include "hitchhiker thumbing a ride," "begging," or "saluting your leader." Communication (COM) involves the presentation or exchange of information, such as "giving a speech," "sign language," or "playing rock, paper, scissors." Exhibition (EXH) involves displaying oneself for approval or to stress noteworthy characteristics, exemplified by "showing off a diamond ring," "a ballet dancer's movements," or even "Hitler on the balcony receiving hails." Direction (DIR) involve influencing or dominating others, such as a "policeman saying stop" or "leading an orchestra." Aggression (AGG) involves the giving of pain or hostility, such as a "Judo punch," "wringing a chicken's neck," or "punching someone off a cliff."

Scoring Category II: Environmental Responses (∑ENV\sum ENV)

Environmental responses represent generalized attitudes toward the impersonal world and objects. Normal individuals usually provide a balanced number of INT and ENV responses. Imbalanced ratios suggest varying psychological interest in people versus things. This category includes three sub-categories. Acquisition (ACQ) involves attempts to obtain a goal or object where the outcome is still in doubt, such as "reaching for something on a high shelf" or "trying to catch a football." Active (ACT) responses involve actions designed to constructively manipulate or alter an object where the goal is certain, such as "typing," "threading a needle," or "writing with a pencil." Passive (PAS) responses involve an attitude of rest, relaxation, or withdrawal of energy, such as "just resting," "drying fingernails," or "a sleeping hand."

Scoring Category III: Maladjusted (∑MAL\sum MAL) and Withdrawal (∑WITH\sum WITH) Responses

Maladjusted responses (MAL) represent difficulty in carrying out action tendencies due to inner weakness or external prohibition. Tension (TEN) indicates energy expenditure that accomplishes little, signaling anxiety or suppression, such as "a fist clenched in anger" or "hanging onto the edge of a cliff." Crippled (CRIP) involves projecting psychological insufficiency by perceiving the hand as injured or incapacitated, such as "a dead person's hand" or "bleeding." Fear (FEAR) represents concern with injury to the self or ego, such as "shielding his face" or "being sucked into quicksand." Withdrawal responses (WITH) reflect the abandonment of realistic interaction. Description (DES) is a "safe" reaction involving only acknowledging the hand's presence, such as "just a hand" or "five fingers." Simple DES responses suggest reality shock, while "fabulized" DES include feeling tones like "a gentle hand." Bizarre (BIZ) responses are predicated on delusional or hallucinatory content and ignore the hand's contours, such as "a crocodile creeping along the wall" or "brain that comes from sunflowers." A single BIZ response is pathognomonic of serious disturbance. Failure (FAIL) occurs when no scorable response is given, often indicating organic deterioration or neurotic ambivalence.

Quantitative Computations and Ratios

Following administration, several totals and ratios are computed to estimate personality structure. The Experience Ratio (ER) provides a gross estimate of personality by comparing the four major classes of response.

ER=∑INT:∑ENV:∑MAL:∑WITHER = \sum INT : \sum ENV : \sum MAL : \sum WITH

The Acting Out Ratio (AOR) serves as a measure of the probability of behaving in an overt, hostile, or anti-social manner by comparing socially positive interpersonal responses to socially negative ones.

AOR=(AFF+DEP+COM):(DIR+AGG)AOR = (AFF + DEP + COM) : (DIR + AGG)

The total number of responses (R) is calculated by summing all responses, excluding failures.

R=∑responsesR = \sum responses

The Average Initial Response Time (AIRT) is calculated by totaling the initial response times (in seconds) for each card and dividing by the number of cards that received a response. If a failure occurs, that card is excluded from the dividend.

AIRT=∑initial response times10−number of FAILAIRT = \frac{\sum \text{initial response times}}{10 - \text{number of FAIL}}

The High minus Low (H-L) score is found by subtracting the lowest initial response time from the highest.

H−L=highest IRT−lowest IRTH-L = \text{highest IRT} - \text{lowest IRT}

The Pathological (PATH) score is an index of psychological disturbance, weighted towards withdrawal responses.

PATH=∑MAL+(∑WITH×2)PATH = \sum MAL + (\sum WITH \times 2)