Claw Identification

Overview of Claw Identification

  • Claws are commonly encountered in the wildlife trade.   - Can be found as loose claws, pieces of jewelry, or trinkets.   - Proper identification is crucial for accurate classification.

Features to Identify Claws

  • Loose claws can be identified to their family of origin.

  • Specific identifications include:   - Foot origin: identifying whether from the rear right or left foot.   - Digit identification: determining which digit the claw originates from.   - Class of animal: distinguishing between mammals and birds.

Biological and Functional Aspects of Claws

  • Claws reflect the natural history of the animal they belong to, influencing:   - Feeding habits   - Locomotion   - Habitat preferences

  • Key significance is that mammals and birds occupy similar ecological niches, leading to morphological similarities in claws.

Initial Steps in Identification

  • First confirm the class of the claw (e.g., Mammalia or Aves).

  • Method: Preliminary examination of the claw in the field can help.

Structure of Claws

  • Composition: Claws primarily consist of bone covered by a keratin sheath known as the unguis.

  • To distinguish between classes:   - Mammal Claws:     - Generally incompletely covered by the unguis.     - The margins of the unguis meet partially underneath the claw.   - Bird Claws:     - Fully sheathed with the unguis covering completely on top and on the sides.     - The plantar surface covered by a plate of keratin called the subungus.

Real vs. Fake Claws

  • Differentiating real and imitation claws:   - Imitation claws can be made from:     - Real keratin     - Synthetic materials

  • Keratin:   - A sulfurous protein found in hair, nails, beaks, horns, hooves, turtle shells, whale baleen, talons, and claws.   - Easily carved into pieces resembling animal claws for commercial products.   - Examination with a magnifying lens can reveal distinctions between genuine keratin and synthetic materials.

Initial Examination of Claws

  • Check the shape and color to determine authenticity:   - Genuine bear claws: Scimitar-shaped, silvery brown to blackish on top, lighter underneath.   - Genuine cat claws: Pale yellowish-white, more rounded, almost semicircular.   - Both characteristics are susceptible to imitation.

Detailed Features to Inspect

  • Examine the underside of the claw:   - Genuine mammal claws feature a deep open channel created by the free edges of the lower claw sheath's walls (unguis).   - This channel can be filled with organic debris (dried tissue, dirt, etc.).   - Search for free edges on either side of the subungual groove.   - Eagles and raptors: Have a solid subungus rather than an open channel.

  • Fine structural features:   - Real claws exhibit fine, tiny structural ridges following the natural claw shape, running in an arc from under the bony collar (ungual crest) to the tip.   - Tiny wrinkles represent growth rings in claw keratin.   - Avoid confusing these with random scratches from manufacturing processes.

Differences in Imitation Claws

  • Structural features in carved horn or hoof:   - Imitation joints show small, straight fibrils of keratin with uniformly parallel lines, lacking the arched curvature of real claws.

  • Fake claws:   - The lower edge of a fake subungual groove appears squared-off, contrary to natural tapering.   - Higher magnification shows striations of cutting tools used during fake claw manufacture.

  • Claws made from keratin from other sources:   - May lack a subungual groove or show poorly executed grooves using rudimentary tools.   - Fake claws cast from molds display air bubbles that burst during processing, leading to telltale craters visible under magnification.

Testing for Authenticity

  • Acetone tests can determine if the paint on imitation claws dissolves, revealing synthetic surfaces.

  • Comparative examination:   - Real claw: Displays natural structural characteristics.   - Fake claw: May have machine marks or molded surfaces differing from genuine anatomy.

Examples of Claws

  • Provided specimen examples:   - Imitation bear claw:     - Color fits the description but is identified as resin.     - Uniform imitation groove lacking characteristics of genuine claws.   - Imitation tiger claw:     - Correct pale color, slight indentation observed.     - Lacks lines found in true claw keratin.   - Real raptor claw:     - Example from a red-tailed hawk demonstrating correct bone and keratin structure.

Conclusion

  • Claw identification is complex and requires careful examination of structural, color, and morphological characteristics.   - Many imitation claws closely mimic real ones but lack specific details that reveal their authenticity.