Mexico Unit Notes

Mexican History

I. Rise of the PRI

A. Before the PRI
  • Colonial System:

    • Introduced Catholicism and a class system based on race.

    • Current demographic breakdown: 60% mestizo and 30% indigenous/Amerindian.

  • Mexican Revolution:

    • Triggered by the oppressive regime of Porfirio Diaz, who promoted foreign direct investment (FDI) while exacerbating inequality.

    • Resulted in peasant revolts leading to significant chaos, costing approximately one million lives.

  • Effects of Revolution:

    • Mexican Constitution of 1917:

    • Established a liberal constitution still in use today.

    • Created a federal state and granted rights to the poor.

    • Religion:

    • Implemented anti-clerical laws following a religious rebellion.

    • Church properties were seized, and their political role was limited.

B. Institutional Revolutionary Party (PRI)
  • Non-Ideological Rule (1929-2000):

    • Described as a “Perfect Dictatorship” representing an illiberal democracy.

  • Political System:

    • Sexenio:

    • Established presidential limit to one six-year term to prevent dictatorship; early presidents were mostly generals.

    • El Dedazo:

    • Colloquially known as the “tap of the finger,” where the president chose successors and appointed all government positions, fostering patron-clientelism.

    • Corporatist System:

    • A framework where few interest groups control access to government policy making, including peasant groups, unions, and middle-class businesses through peak associations.

  • Economic System:

    • Mexican Miracle:

    • Focused on land redistribution through ejidos, governmental farms leased and supported for poor farmers.

    • Nationalization of key industries, especially oil (PEMEX), which became a major export.

    • Import substitution industrialization (ISI) promoted national industry with protective measures such as tariffs and subsidies.

    • Experienced high growth driven by the oil sector and sustained low inflation, though marred by corruption and rapid urbanization.

II. Economic Crisis (1970-1994)

A. Causes of Crisis
  • Government reliance on oil revenues led to vulnerability; an oil crash resulted in nationalizing banks and borrowing from IMF and World Bank.

B. Economic Liberalization
  1. Structural Adjustment:

    • IMF mandated reform policies advocating privatization and cessation of subsidies to restore economic health, challenging national sovereignty and disadvantaging the poor through budget cuts.

  2. Technocratic Leadership:

    • New technocratic leaders (Presidents Madrid and Salinas, 1982-1994) embraced neoliberal reforms, diminished union power, privatized ejidos, and joined WTO in 1986.

  3. NAFTA (1994):

    • A free trade agreement with the US and Canada leading to increased economic growth, but benefits were unevenly distributed.

    • Effects:

      • Economic expansion primarily in northern regions, while southern farmers suffered from reduced subsidies and vulnerability to economic fluctuations.

      • Zapatista Uprising:

      • Indigenous leftist group rebellion in Chiapas advocating for better rights and against inequality.

III. Political Reform (1968-present)

A. Political Crises
  1. 1968 Tlatelolco Massacre:

    • A tragic event where 400 protesters were killed, leading to public outrage over leftists who disappeared during the “dirty war.”

  2. 1985 Earthquake:

    • Resulted in tens of thousands of deaths; the poor response by the PRI significantly undermined the party's legitimacy.

B. Political Liberalization
  1. Election Law Changes:

    • Helped form opposition parties and establish free state and local elections, transitioning to a mixed electoral system and ending anti-clerical laws benefiting the PAN.

  2. National Electoral Institute (INE):

    • Independent body that regulates elections, reducing fraud and corruption, ensures public funding, and requires voter IDs.

  3. Rising Pluralism:

    • Diverse interest groups began accessing the government to influence policy, with increased activism from farmers and unions amid privatization and foreign competition.

  4. Presidential Elections:

    • Disputed and fraudulent elections in 1988 and 1994; the PRI lost its legislative majority in 1997; Zedillo marked the end of El Dedazo by allowing internal party primaries; 2000 saw open elections.

C. Fall of the PRI
  • Transition from one-party dictatorship to multiparty democracy:

  1. 2000 - Vicente Fox (PAN):

    • Navigated checks to power due to no majority in Congress, initiated economic and political liberalization.

  2. 2006 - Felipe Calderon (PAN):

    • Faced contested election with Obrador (PRD) leading to massive protests; focused on liberalization and a militarized drug war approach.

  3. 2012 - Enrique Peña Nieto (PRI):

    • Proposed a “Pact for Mexico” aiming for structural reforms like PEMEX competition, legal system adjustments, and legislative reelections; faced public dissatisfaction due to slow economic growth and corruption.

  4. 2018 - Andres Manuel López Obrador (AMLO, Morena):

    • Secured a coalition majority in Congress with a mandate to end neoliberal policies and proposed judicial and electoral reforms.

  5. 2024 - Claudia Sheinbaum (Morena):

    • Continues AMLO’s policies.

Mexican Government Structure

I. Executive Branch

A. President
  1. Election:

    • Elected by direct plurality with no run-off; serves a single six-year term (sexenio).

  2. Role:

    • Acts as the head of government and state.

  3. Powers:

    • Inclusive of military authority, veto power, oversight of international relations, governmental operations, appointments, and legislation introductions.

  4. Informal Power:

    • Through party dominion over other branches and state governments, especially in the PRI era.

  5. Impeachment:

    • Lower house can indict for crimes, followed by a trial in the upper house.

B. Cabinet
  • Appointed by the president with Senate affirmation; heads significant departments, especially the Interior Ministry, which oversees law and order implementations.

C. Bureaucracy/Civil Service
  1. Structure:

    • Comprises a hierarchy of non-political workers assigned to governmental departments, responsible for policy implementation.

    • Encompasses local, state, federal, and parastatal levels; unions persist but with moderate salaries.

  2. Patron-Client System:

    • Relationships guide promotions and loyalty as patrons grant jobs in return for allegiance from clients.

II. Legislative Branch: Congress of the Union

A. Senate (Upper House)
  1. Representation:

    • Represents 31 states plus one Federal District (Mexico City).

  2. Elections:

    • Each state elects three senators: two via first-past-the-post, and one for the first minority; 32 senators are additionally elected through proportional representation, totaling 128 members.

  3. Term:

    • Six-year terms are allowed with recent provisions for two consecutive terms.

B. Chamber of Deputies (Lower House)
  1. Composition:

    • 300 Majority Deputies elected through single-member districts and 200 Party Deputies elected through party lists, with a minimum threshold of 2%.

  2. Term:

    • Elected for three years, with recent amendments permitting four terms.

C. Policy Making
  1. Power Balance:

    • Both houses wield similar powers but different functions—e.g., the Chamber levies taxes while the Senate approves appointments; the president and bureaucracy historically dominate policy-making, influenced by single-party or coalition dynamics.

  2. Civil Society:

    • Policy-making becoming more pluralistic, transitioning away from previous corporatist structures.

III. Judiciary

A. Legal System
  • Based on civil law rather than common law, structured around statutes with a clear amendment procedure; numerous recent changes taking place within the system.

B. Judicial Problems
  • Issues include widespread corruption, lack of civil rights experience, and an abundance of crime that undermines the rule of law.

C. Reforms
  1. System Transition:

    • Shift towards an adversarial system establishing transparency and presumption of innocence; strengthened judicial review has been present in the Supreme Court since 1994.

  2. Judicial Reforms:

    • Efforts from Morena to transition to an elective system for judges, reversing previous appointment methods by the president and Senate.

  3. Concerns:

    • Worries about increased politicization leading to less judicial independence.

IV. State and Local Government

A. Federalism
  • Constitutional division of power distinguishes between central and regional governmental responsibilities (contrast with unitary systems, noting why diverse nations prefer federalism).

B. Government
  • Governors serve six-year terms elected by state constituents; local legislatures have mixed electoral systems and are predominantly unicameral, contributing significantly to democratization.

C. Advantages of Federalism
  • Grants autonomy for local law-making accommodating diverse populational needs, particularly regarding ethnic minorities and contentious societal issues, improving political legitimacy.

D. Disadvantages of Federalism
  • Potential inefficiencies and inconsistencies across policies may exacerbate national cleavages.

E. Centralization Effects
  • Despite federal structure, Mexico experienced significant centralization, especially during PRI rule; a considerable portion of finances remains under central government control (only ~3.5% of revenue is localized).

V. Other Institutions

A. Military
  1. Historical Context:

    • Originally held substantial policymaking power under early caudillos; now typically remains under civilian governmental authority (no coups), with some involvement in quelling leftist protests and an expanding role under AMLO.

  2. Domestic Role:

    • Engaged in internal law enforcement against drugs and uprisings (e.g., Zapatistas); however, often implicated in human rights violations and collateral damage issues.

B. Parastatals
  1. Historical Context:

    • Initially represented a major economic sector until the 1980s with over a thousand state-run entities; significant privatization has occurred due to liberalization, but fewer than 200 remain.

  2. PEMEX:

    • The national oil company retaining government ownership of all mineral rights, presently perceived as inefficient and facing diminishing production; accountability for about 20-25% of state revenues; attempts at privatization encountered resistance but constitutional changes under PRI in 2014 allowed foreign investments—this was countered by AMLO aiming to enhance social services utilization of PEMEX resources.

Politics and Elections

I. Elections

A. Types of Elections
  • Includes local, state, presidential elections (primaries for candidate selection without run-offs), and legislative elections structured around a mixed electoral system.

B. Party System
  • Historically dominated by three primary parties requiring cooperative law-making and potentially forming permanent alliances for governance.

C. INE
  • Oversees election integrity, provides public funding (partially), monitors campaign spending, ensures equitable media coverage, and issues voter ID cards.

D. Laws Related to Elections
  • Voting is mandated (though rarely enforced); regulations require 50% of candidates to represent women.

II. Political Parties

A. PAN (National Action Party)
  1. Ideology:

    • Right-center, neoliberal, embraces privatization and global integration along with social conservatism (pro-Catholic themes).

  2. Recent Presidents:

    • Vicente Fox:

      • Faced limitations in power due to minority status in Congress; collaborated with PRI on economic liberalization and democratization.

    • Felipe Calderon:

      • Controversial election sparked significant protests; maintained liberalization focus along with a heavy emphasis on drug war militarization.

B. PRI (Institutional Revolutionary Party)
  1. Ideology:

    • Traditionally viewed as the party of power, currently leaning centrism with restrained neoliberal aspects; split generally into Politicos (politicians) and Technicos (technocrats).

  2. Recent President:

    • Enrique Peña Nieto (PRI):

      • Initiative entitled “Pact for Mexico” aimed to introduce structural reforms in collaboration with other parties, focusing on PEMEX, taxation, and educational reform; met with discontent amid economic stagnation, crime, and corruption.

C. Morena
  1. Ideology:

    • Adopts a leftist stance advocating for social programs, nationalization, and protectionist policies alongside a nationalist framework.

  2. Recent President:

    • Andres Manuel López Obrador:

      • Garnered majority with a coalition supporting a mandate aimed at dismantling neoliberal policies; succeeded by Claudia Sheinbaum continuing AMLO's focus.

    • Populism:

      • A political philosophy that supports the common people's interests against elites; can stem from either the left or right, occasionally exhibiting illiberal characteristics by empowering a singular leader.

D. Other Parties
  • PRD (Democratic Revolutionary Party):

    • Leftist party that has been eclipsed by Morena.

  • Labor Party:

    • Coalition partner with Morena.

  • Green Party

  • Indigenous Party

Mexican Society

I. Cleavages

A. Ethnic Cleavages
  • Amerindian Poverty:

    • stark socio-economic disparities as Amerindians face discrimination; federalism has provided greater autonomy post-Zapatista rebellion.

B. Gender Cleavages
  • Shifting Societal Roles:

    • Declining fertility rates and increasing female labor participation along with enhancements in political representation (approximately half of legislators being women); however, domestic violence and drug-related issues persist.

C. North-South Divide
  • Economic Discrepancies:

    • The northern region exhibits greater industrialization through maquiladoras, whereas the southern regions remain impoverished, prompting migration trends toward the north due to NAFTA and economic liberalization.

D. Urban-Rural Divide
  • Population Distribution:

    • Mexico City housing approximately 25% of the national population juxtaposed against rural farmers still dependent on ejidos (over one-third of farm operations).

E. Income Disparities
  • Rich-Poor Gap:

    • Notably wide income gap, with Gini coefficient around 0.5, depicting exacerbated socio-economic inequalities.

F. Religious Influences
  1. Anticlerical Movement:

    • Laws historically restricted Church involvement in governance; many laws repealed (1992), yet religious institutions still hold significant sway (notably with PAN).

  2. Religious Demographics:

    • Over 80% identifying as Catholic, although a rising number of Pentecostal Protestants are noted; high church attendance reflects social conservatism's potent role in political culture.

II. Society

A. Media Landscape
  1. Television Duopoly:

    • Dominated by two major companies (Televisa linked to PRI, TV Azteca) with the introduction of a third channel.

  2. Press Freedom Challenges:

    • Various newspapers exist along with an active internet presence; government restrictions are minimal but under AMLO, some media freedoms have been compromised; threats from corrupt officials and drug cartels render journalism particularly hazardous in Mexico.

B. Civil Society
  1. Interest Groups' Evolution:

    • Shift from corporatist to pluralistic civil society with emerging NGOs addressing various societal concerns, such as Médecins Sans Frontières, Transparency International, and various watchdogs, alongside conservative Catholic organizations.

  2. Protests:

    • Mobilizations against NAFTA, violence tied to drugs, corruption, and alterations to fuel subsidies.

C. Political Culture
  • Exhibits a robust structure with high participation rates and a strong national identity; however, skepticism and pessimism regarding politicians' capabilities to address social issues are prevalent.

Mexican Public Policy

I. The Border

A. NAFTA
  1. Development:

    • Initiated trade facilitation with the US and Canada; major reductions in trade barriers happened across most goods while Mexico decreased agricultural subsidies that the US maintained.

    • Establishment of maquiladoras—factories exempt from taxes catering to foreign export.

  2. Economic Impacts:

    • Positive outcomes included increased FDI and total exports (approximately a $300 billion increase with 80% of Mexico's exports linked to the US), and dissipation of consumer good prices (40% of imports are US-sourced).

    • Adverse results include job losses for farmers, exploitation of maquiladora workers, rising inequality, environmental degradation, economic vulnerability (highlighted during the Great Recession where economic drop was three times greater).

B. Emigration
  1. Demographics and Reasons:

    • Often includes southern farmers (predominantly Amerindian heritage) displaced because of NAFTA and existing economic scarcity.

  2. Societal Effects:

    • Remittances from the US contribute significantly ($25 billion, around 2.5% of GDP); approximately 11 million undocumented Mexican workers reside in the US, with notable cultural and societal repercussions.

C. Drugs
  1. Evolution of Drug Trafficking:

    • Initially intermediaries in Colombian drug trafficking; however, Mexico now dominates manufacturing, transportation, and distribution within the drug trade.

    • The decline of PRI's control correlated with increasing drug cartel relationships; the PAN initiated a war on drugs (notably under Calderon in 2006) which continues under Peña Nieto's administration, albeit with ineffective re-stabilization efforts.

  2. Consequences:

    • Widespread corruption affects approximately 10% of GDP while murder rates for politicians and journalists remain high (only 2% of murders leading to convictions). Vigilante groups emerged due to state failures in law enforcement.

    • Human Rights Impact:

      • Over 100,000 deaths recorded since 2006 with rampant violence; torture and trafficking constitute significant issues with the government adjudicating statistics.

  3. Potential Solutions:

    • Proposals include drug legalization, police force overhauls, investment in impoverished communities, legal reform, and shifting focus toward prevention and investigation as opposed to mere enforcement measures.

II. Public Policy

A. Legal Reform
  1. Historical Framework:

    • Characterized by a lack of independence during the PRI age, high conviction rates, and an Inquisitorial system where the court investigates facts instead of maintaining impartiality.

  2. Recent Reforms:

    • Implementation of constitutional amendments promoting an adversarial system emphasizing presumption of innocence, public testimonials, oral trials, and increased judicial review independence.

  3. Corruption Challenges:

    • Declining rule of law is identified as a critical flaw in Mexican democracy; numerous agencies, constitutional amendments, and civic groups are attempting to mitigate these issues.

B. Economic Policy
  1. Informal Economy:

    • A significant section of the economy operates outside taxation and regulation leading to only 13.6% of GDP in tax revenues; recent attempts to reform taxation agendas have been highlighted.

  2. Labor Reforms:

    • Introduced by Peña Nieto to ease hiring and firing practices, revise pensions and severance standards, and diminish unions' influence (e.g., specifically targeting teacher unions).

C. Social Policy
  1. Anti-Poverty Initiatives:

    • Program named “Prospera” focuses on conditional cash transfers to ameliorate poverty, yet the poverty rate remains marked at 46%.

  2. Healthcare System:

    • Predominantly private, outcomes noted as being the lowest among OECD countries, alongside obesity rates paralleling those in the US; government initiatives pursue increasing taxes on sugary products.

  3. Federalism Impacts:

    • Variation in liberal policy enactments, particularly around abortion and LGBT rights, with Mexico City following a more progressive path compared to more conservative states.

D. Environmental Policy
  1. Major Issues:

    • Existing environmental concerns stem from lax regulations on maquiladoras, with pollution particularly exacerbated in Mexico City due to industrial activity.

  2. Policy Measures:

    • Official commitments to international climate change treaties, though domestic emission regulations have often proven ineffective as PEMEX continues to be prioritized over environmental concerns.