Chapter%2026

Foundations of Medical Law and Society

  • Laws represent the collective body of rules, guidelines, and regulations used to govern conduct within a society. The primary objective of these laws is to protect the welfare, safety, and health of citizens.

  • There are instances where the practice of medicine and the requirements of the law come into conflict with one another.

  • Legal disputes involve two primary parties:

    • Plaintiff: The party bringing the legal action.

    • Defendant: The party against whom the legal action is brought.

  • Litigation refers to the process of taking legal action or the conduct of a lawsuit.

The Patient–Health Care Practitioner Relationship

  • The legal relationship between patients and practitioners was fundamentally defined by the precedent-setting case of Schloendorf v. Society of New York Hospital in 19141914.

  • The ruling established a core legal principle: ‐Every human being of adult years and sound mind has a right to determine what shall be done with his own body, and a surgeon who performs an operation without his patient’s consent commits an assault, for which he is liable in damages.‐

  • The Doctrine of Patient–Provider Relationship serves the following critical functions:

    • It protects the individual autonomy of the patient.

    • It protects the status of the patient as a human being.

    • It serves as a safeguard against fraud and duress.

    • It encourages medical practitioners to deliberate carefully before making decisions.

    • It fosters a environment or rational decision-making for the patient.

    • It involves the general public in the practice of medicine.

Classification and Types of Law

  • Constitutional Law: The supreme law of the land derived from the constitution.

  • Legislative Law: Laws enacted by administrative bodies, which include:

    • Administrative rules.

    • Regulations.

    • Ordinances.

  • Case Law: This is derived from the Common Law of England. It consists of laws determined on a case-by-case basis through judicial decisions.

  • Contract Law: Law relating to legally binding agreements between parties.

Understanding Torts and Legal Liability

  • A Tort is defined as a claim made by a patient stating they have been wronged or have sustained an injury (other than a breach of contract) for which they believe there is cause for legal action to seek damages.

  • Torts arise from the violation of a duty imposed by general law on people involved in a specific situation or transaction.

  • A successful tort action requires proof that a breach of duty occurred.

Specific Intentional Torts: Assault, Battery, and False Imprisonment

  • Assault: An assault claim arises if a patient believes they have been threatened in a way that causes a reasonable fear or expectation of immediate bodily harm.

    • Physical contact is not required for a claim of assault; it may be entirely verbal.

    • Assault can occur if a patient perceives possible harm from comments made by the practitioner.

    • Example: "Hold still or we’ll have to start all over!"

    • Example: "If you don’t swallow these pills, the radiologist will not come in to do the study."

  • Battery: This involves any unlawful or unwarranted touching of a patient, even if no physical injury results.

    • If a patient perceives that a radiologic or imaging professional has touched them in an offensive way, it may constitute battery.

    • When performing palpation or positioning, professionals must obtain patient permission and utilize professional techniques.

    • Rough handling or improper positioning techniques can lead to a charge of battery.

  • False Imprisonment: This occurs when an individual is restrained or believes they are being restrained against their will.

    • The person must be conscious of the confinement and lack a reasonable means of escape.

    • Special care must be taken with pediatric, senile, or incompetent patients; professionals must obtain consent for immobilization or restraint from an authorized personal representative.

Defamation, Fraud, and Information Privacy

  • Defamation involves the disclosure of confidential information that is harmful to a patient. It is divided into two categories:

    • Slander: The spoken word of a defamatory nature.

    • Libel: The written word of a defamatory nature.

    • Social media usage carries a high risk for accidental or intentional disclosure of patient information, which can lead to defamation charges. Strictest standards of privacy regarding patient conditions and medical information must be maintained on all platforms.

  • Fraud: The intentional and willful misrepresentation of facts that may result in the loss of property, loss of individual rights, or physical harm to an individual.

    • Establishment of fraud requires 33 sources of proof:

      1. An untrue statement was made by a party who knew it was false, with the intent to mislead.

      2. The injured party relied upon that statement.

      3. The injured party incurred damages as a result of that reliance.

Health Information Management and HIPAA

  • Privacy Standards: The Patient Care Bill of Rights establishes that health records must be kept confidential and private.

  • Property Ownership:

    • Health records are the physical property of the healthcare provider.

    • The health information contained within those records is the property of the patient.

  • In the context of electronic imaging, it is vital to ensure that all images are secure, accurate, and confidential.

  • HIPAA (Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act of 19961996):

    • Standardizes electronic data interchange.

    • Protects patient confidentiality.

    • Ensures the security of all patient information.

Negligence and the Standard of Care

  • Negligence is defined as the failure to exercise the level of care that a reasonably prudent, comparable person would use in a similar situation.

  • The Standard of Care describes the degree of knowledge, skill (proficiency), and care that members in good standing within the medical profession ordinarily possess and employ.

    • The standard is judged against "reasonable and prudent" actions in similar circumstances.

    • The standard is dynamic and changes as medical technology improves.

    • Courts use standard of care components outlined by the profession for legal guidance.

  • Proof of Negligence: This involves demonstrating injurious or unprofessional treatment, including neglectful actions. It requires 44 established elements:

    1. Duty.

    2. Breach of duty (a deviation from the established duty).

    3. Causation (the breach caused the injury).

    4. Damage (a compensable injury resulted).

Professional Performance and Legal Doctrines

  • The American Society of Radiologic Technologists (ASRT) provides Practice Standards for medical imaging and radiation therapy. These can be found in Appendix A\text{Appendix A} of the text.

    • These ASRT standards define the minimum performance levels for the profession.

    • Compliance with and understanding of these standards is a professional responsibility for all imaging science practitioners.

  • Key Legal Doctrines:

    • Respondeat superior: Translated as "The master speaks for the servant." This implies that a physician or healthcare facility is legally responsible for the negligent acts of its employees.

    • Corporate liability: This involves a facility's duty of reasonable care in selecting and retaining medical staff and employees. It also involves the duty to maintain and use equipment properly and ensure the availability of services and equipment.

    • Res ipsa loquitur: Translated as "The thing speaks for itself." This doctrine shifts the burden of proof to the healthcare practitioner. It applies in situations where the injury would not have happened if not for the negligence of the practitioner.

Principles of Informed Consent and Autonomy

  • Informed Consent is built on a foundation of trust between the patient and provider.

    • Required for all interventional procedures.

    • It assumes the provider acts in the patient’s best interest according to the Standard of Care.

    • Typically not required for routine, simple, or noninvasive studies, where Implied Consent is generally used.

    • Information must be delivered in lay language and the patient’s primary language.

    • The consent form must be signed and witnessed by a disinterested third party.

Components of an Informed Consent Form:

  • Authorization Clause: Permits the professional to perform the exam.

  • Disclosure Clause: Explains the procedure, its benefits, risks, and possible alternatives.

  • Anesthesia Clause: Required if anesthesia is to be used.

  • No-guarantee Clause: Used for therapeutic procedures.

  • Tissue-disposal Clause: Used if tissue removal is necessary.

  • Patient Understanding Clause: States that all information has been carefully explained.

  • Signature Clause: Requires signatures from the patient and a witness.