Land Law Lecture 1

Real vs Personal


Property

  • the thing owned +

  • The right to the possession, use or disposal of a thing


Real and personal property

Real property

  • land and all interests in land (except leasehold interest)

Personal property

  • all property that is not real property

  • Includes moveable objects and rights under a contract


Personal or Proprietary rights

Personal

  • only enforceable by parties to contract or agreement

Proprietary rights

  • have the capacity to bind others.

  • (Could be enforceable upon an new owner)


What is Land

Land of Property Act 1935, s205(1)(ix)

‘Land of any tenure, and mines and minerals… buildings or parts of buildings and other corporeal hereditament; also incorporeal hereditaments and an easement right privilege or benefit in over or derived from land’.

  • land = includes rights to land as well

Extent to which the land-owner has rights in relation to their airspace above the land

Bernstein of Leigh v Skyviews Ltd [1978] QB 479

  • Land owners rights extend above surface.

  • Airspace is divided into two sections

  • Lower and Upper stratum

  • Land owner owns the lower stratum of the land.

    • Plane flying in upper stratum does infringe rights.

How to measure upper and lower stratum?

  • owner owns to such height as is necessary for the ordinary use and enjoyment of land.


Landowners rights beneath surface?

Bocardo v Star Energy (2011) 1 AC 380

  • Drilling under land.

  • HOLs decided that the ownership under the land is largely extensive.

  • Land owner of the surface owns as far down as is possible for human endeavour to be carried out.


What about things on or attached to the land?

  • Can become fixtures


Holland v Hodgson (1872)

  • 2 questions:(annexation test)

  • Degree of annexation

  • Purpose of annexation


Elitestone v Morris (1997)

  • Third category: ‘part and parcel of the land’

  • Chalet built on land.

  • Q was whether land owner could get rid of them and redevelop land.

  • HOLs decided the chalets were part of the land.

    • Parcel of the land.

  • Could not be removed without damage.


Fixtures or chattels

  • Classification of an item as a fixture means that the item cannot be removed after a contract for sale of the land has been made.

  • A mortgage of the land will extend to all fixtures.

TSB Bank plc v Botham (1996)

  • Landowner had defaulted on his mortgage. Bank repossesed his flat and sold it.

  • Argued some items werent fixtures and should not have been sold.


When property is leased, fixtures will pass to the landlord on the termination of the lease.

However the tenant has the right to remove certain types of fixtures

  • Agricultural fixtures (where there is a tenancy of an agricultural holding);

  • Trading fixtures

  • Ornamental and domestic fixtures (Spyer v Phillipson [1931] 2 Ch 183)

  • Must be relived before end of lease.


Found items

  • Idea of relative title

  • When dealing with claims to objects found on land we are concerned with the question of who has the best claim.

  • Factors that feed into this:


Where an item is found more than one party may assert a claim to title to that item

Who might have a claim

  • The true owner- had the strongest title

  • The finder

  • The owner of the land on which the item was found

  • The state if the item qualifies as ‘treasure’

  • Finder employer (found in the course of employment)


Finder has a claim based on possession

Armoury v Delamirie (1772)

  • Chimney sweep boy who found a ring.

  • Took it to a store to value it.

  • They took the jewel out and refused to give it back

  • Boy claimed he had a stronger claim

  • Court held he had the strongest claim other than the actual owner of the item.

Parker v British Airways Board (1982)

  • Found bracelet on airport lounge.

  • Handed it in so Bs could give it to of owner, but gave his numbe run case they did not find it.

  • Court found the finder had stronger claim unless the landowner had taken steps to show intent to control everything found on their land.



  • the finders claim will be

  • As against the true owner, the finders claim will fail.

  • Whether the finder or the landowner has the stronger claim depends on various circumstances

  • If the item could be treasure the finisher is under a duty to report the find


Finder v Landowner

  • When assessing the relative strength of competing claims by finder and landowner consider:

    • To what extent has landowner manifested an intention to control the land and anything found on it (Parker)

      • What is required here is not always clear and will be fact-dependent.

Also consider:

  • The status of the finder on the land

    • Parker v British Airways Board

    • Waverley v Fletcher (1996)

      • Metal detecting in park.

      • made him a trespasser and he did not have the right to dig up his finds.

  • Whether the item was found in the land or on the surface

    • Elwes v Briggs Gas Co (1886)

    • Waverley v Fletcher (1996)


Treasure under the Treasure Act 1996

  • Where an item might be treasure, there’s a duty to report the finds

  • Finds should be reported to the local coroner within 14 days.

  • The Crown will have the stronger claim to items which fall under the definition of ‘treasure’

  • Rewards are paid at the discretion of the Secretary of State

  • The Crown may ‘disclaim’ items, in which the general law will apply.


Definition of ‘treasure’

Section 1(a)

  • Any object other than a coin, at least 300 years old and at least 10% precious metal (by weight)

  • One of at least two coins found together, at least 300 years old and at least 10% precious metal (by weight)

  • One of at least ten coins in the same find which are at least 300 years old at that time.

Section 1(b)

  • any object at least 200 years old when found which belongs to a class designated under section 2(1)


Section 1(C)

  • any object which would have been ‘treasure trove’ if found before the Act came into force.(That would be an object at least 50% gold or silver which had been hidden with the intention of later discovery.)

Section (d):

  • any object which, when found, is part of the same find as-

    • An object within s1(a), (b), (C) found at the same time or earlier; or

    • An object found earlier which would be within s(1) or (b) if it had been found at the same time.


Definition of ‘treasure’ has been added to twice since the Act came into force.

  • Classes of treasure designated under s2(1) are

    • categories of prehistoric objects (treasure(designation) Order 2002) and

    • Any object, any part of which is metal which provides ‘exceptional insight into an aspect of national or regional history, archaeology or culture because of its rarity, location or connection with a person or event (Treasure(Designation) (Amendemnt) Order 2023)



Estates in land: ownership rights

  • Modern landowners hold estates in the land

  • An ‘estate’ in land can be conceptualised as a bundle of rights over the land

  • A person with an estate on the land has the right to use possession of the land.

S.1(1) Law of Property Act 1925(LPA):

  • the only two estates in land which are recognised at law are:

    • An estate in fee simple absolute in possession;

    • A term of years absolute.


The estate in fee simple or freehold estate

  • Equates to absolute ownership

  • Is of indefinite duration

The term of years absolute or leasehold estate.

  • Is time-limited ownership

  • Long leaseholds equate ownership.


Interests in bland

Began describes them as ‘property rights’ which do not confer any rights of ownership’

Another way to explain what we mean is to say that interests in land are generally rights which a person enjoys over land owned by someone else.


The following are some examples of interests a person or body might hold over another person’s land;

  • A right to use a path across a neighbours land;

  • An enforceable weight to prevent a neighbouring landowner building on her land, or opening a certain type of business on her land.

  • A lenders right in relation to land subject to a mortgage.


The main categories of interests in land are:

  • Easement and profit a prendre

  • Charges by way of legal mortgage

  • Rent chargers

  • Rights of re-entry contained in legal lease.

  • Restrictive covenants over freehold land

  • Options to purchase land

  • Rights of pre-emption

  • Beneficial interests under a trust.