Statistical Analysis, Biostatistics, and the Role of Forensic Scientists
Roles of the Forensic Scientist
Investigative Role (Investigator):
Focuses on the crime at the beginning of the legal process.
Observes evidence, generates hypotheses/leads, and suggests explanations to guide police inquiries.
Acts to answer questions such as "What happened?" and "What is this?"
Evaluative Role (Evaluator):
Focuses on the suspect and acts at the end of the legal process.
Remains impartial, working for both prosecution and defence to evaluate findings given opposing propositions.
Quantifies uncertainty and provides objective assessments to assist the court in decision-making.
Deductive vs. Inductive Inference
Deductive Reasoning:
Moves from general laws or premises to specific outcomes or predictions (Causes→Effects).
Certainty: If the premises are true, the conclusion must necessarily be true.
Limitation: Does not add new knowledge beyond what is contained in the premises.
Inductive Reasoning:
Moves from specific observations or data to general laws or underlying causes (Effects→Causes).
Uncertainty: Adds new knowledge beyond the premises, but conclusions remain probabilistic rather than certain.
Forms the primary logical framework for scientific evaluation by estimating how strongly observed evidence supports a hypothesis.
Measures of Center
Mean (Arithmetic Mean):
Calculated by summing all data values and dividing by the total count.
Sample Mean Formula:xˉ=n∑x
Population Mean Formula:μ=N∑x
Properties: Uses every data value; non-resistant (highly sensitive to extreme outliers).
Weighted Mean Formula:xˉ=∑w∑(w⋅x)
Frequency Distribution Mean Formula:xˉ=∑f∑(f⋅x)
Median:
The middle value in a dataset sorted in ascending or descending order (denoted x~, M, or Med).
Odd Sample Size (n): Exact middle value.
Even Sample Size (n): Mean of the two middle values.
Properties: Resistant to outliers; does not change when extreme values are altered.
Mode:
The value(s) occurring with the greatest frequency.
Data sets may have no mode, one mode (unimodal), two modes (bimodal), or multiple modes (multimodal). Applicable to qualitative data.
Midrange:
The value halfway between the maximum and minimum values.
Formula:Midrange=2maximum+minimum
Properties: Non-resistant; highly sensitive to extreme values.
Measures of Variation
Range:
Difference between the maximum and minimum values (Range=maximum−minimum). Highly sensitive to extreme values.
Standard Deviation:
Measures how much data values deviate from the mean. Always non-negative (s≥0).
Sample Standard Deviation (s):s=n−1∑(x−xˉ)2
Shortcut Formula:s=n(n−1)n(∑x2)−(∑x)2
Population Standard Deviation (σ):σ=N∑(x−μ)2
Variance:
Equal to the square of the standard deviation (s2 for sample variance, σ2 for population variance).
s2 is an unbiased estimator of σ2, whereas s is a biased estimator of σ.
Range Rule of Thumb:
Determines significantly low or high values:
Significantly Low Values≤μ−2σSignificantly High Values≥μ+2σ
Roughly estimates standard deviation from range:
s≈4Range
Empirical Rule (Bell-Shaped Distributions):
∼68% of data fall within xˉ±1s
∼95% of data fall within xˉ±2s
∼99.7% of data fall within xˉ±3s
Coefficient of Variation (CV):
Expresses standard deviation as a percentage relative to the mean.
Sample CV:CV=xˉs×100
Population CV:CV=μσ×100
Measures of Relative Standing and Boxplots
z Score:
Standardized value indicating the number of standard deviations a data point x lies above or below the mean.
Sample Formula:z=sx−xˉ
Population Formula:z=σx−μ
Significance Criteria: A value is significantly low if z≤−2.00 and significantly high if z \ge +2.00$.\n\n\n\n* **Percentiles (P_k):**\n * Measures of location dividing sorted data into 100 groups with roughly 1\% of data per group.\n * **Percentile Calculation for Value x:**\n \text{Percentile of } x = \frac{\text{number of values less than } x}{\text{total number of values}} \times 100\n * **Locator Formula:**\n L = \left(\frac{k}{100}\right) n\n * If Lisawholenumber,P_kistheaverageoftheL\text{th}and(L + 1)\text{th} sorted values.\n * If Lisnotawholenumber,roundLuptothenextwholenumber;P_kistheL\text{th} sorted value.\n* **Quartiles & 5-Number Summary:**\n * **Quartiles:** Q_1 = P_{25},Q_2 = P_{50}(Median),Q_3 = P_{75}.\n * **Interquartile Range (IQR):**\n \text{IQR} = Q_3 - Q_1\n * **5-Number Summary:** Consists of Minimum, Q_1,Q_2,Q_3, and Maximum.\n* **Boxplots & Outliers:**\n * A graphical summary constructed using the 5-number summary.\n\n\n\n * **Outlier Criterion (Modified Boxplots):** A value is identified as an outlier if it is greater than Q_3 + 1.5 \times \text{IQR}orlessthanQ_1 - 1.5 \times \text{IQR}$$.