G125 CA1 Presentation Notes


Team Members' Declaration

  • Haziq Bin Hassim, 25046407

  • Muhammad Yusraiziq Bin Muhammad Yusof, 25047488

  • Gwen Beatrice Ang Dulay, 25003193

  • Zavier Luke Ng, 25002037

Introduction

  • Overview of Project Evergreen’s disappearance.

  • Inquiry into the reasons behind its disappearance.

Background & Context

  • Why was Project Evergreen considered a game-changer in sustainability, and how did it threaten existing industries?

  • Who were the key stakeholders involved in the project?

    • Dr. Evelyn Carter (Lead Scientist, Project Evergreen): Key researcher whose role in the project remains unclear.

    • World Plastics Alliance (WPA): A coalition of major plastic manufacturers that may have had conflicting interests.

    • Global Sustainability Summit (GSS) Task Force: A government-backed initiative that initially supported the project but later faced political pressures.

    • Anonymous Whistleblower: A source claiming that the research had significant flaws or was suppressed for other reasons.

    • Cybersecurity Analysts: Experts investigating whether the project was lost due to an external cyber-attack or internal sabotage.

Why Was Project Evergreen Considered a Game-Changer in Sustainability, and How Did It Threaten Existing Industries?

Why was Project Evergreen a game-changer?

  • Restored almost 200 million square feet of green space.

  • Created tools like the Clean Air Calculator that show real carbon & pollution reduction.

  • Promoted sustainable urban planning over concrete-heavy development.

How it threatens existing industries:

  • Disrupts traditional construction and landscaping by pushing eco-friendly methods.

  • Encourages volunteer-driven projects, reshaping labor needs in landscaping.

The Key Stakeholders

  • Board of Directors:

    • Steve Cohen – GreenMark Consulting

    • Chris McMurrough – Heritage Landscape Supply

    • Nick Minas – John Deere

    • Todd Zimmerman – Kress

Investigation & Analysis

Corporate Sabotage

Evidence
  • World Plastics Alliance’s history of blocking innovations.

  • Cases like oil companies suppressing renewable energy tech.

Credibility Assessment
  • High motive for plastic manufacturers to suppress biodegradable plastics.

  • Weakness: No direct proof of involvement.

Government Cover-Up

Evidence
  • GSS Task Force’s classified warnings.

  • Governments delaying climate policies due to economic pressures.

Credibility Assessment
  • Plausible if economic losses were a concern.

  • Weakness: Lack of leaked documents confirming suppression.

Research Fraud

Evidence
  • Whistleblower claims about flawed data.

  • Scientific scandals (e.g., falsified research in academia).

Credibility Assessment
  • Possible if scientists feared exposure.

  • Weakness: No peer-reviewed debunking of Project Evergreen’s claims.

Legitimate Cyber-Attack

Evidence
  • Cybersecurity forensics report.

  • Hacks on research institutions (e.g., SolarWinds, university breaches).

Credibility Assessment
  • Strong if breach traces lead to external hackers.

  • Weakness: Motive unclear (random vs. targeted attack).

Key Facts

  • Project Evergreen aimed to develop a revolutionary plastic waste elimination technology.

  • It involved creating a revolutionary biodegradable material that breaks down safely within months.

  • Research data, lab reports, and prototypes vanished from GICS’s secured database and laboratory just days before official findings were released.

  • Key scientists involved have either gone silent or released conflicting statements.

Discrepancies Between Different Reports

  • Corporate sabotage on major plastics

  • Government Cover-Up, would cause massive Economic losses

  • Research Fraud, scientists deleted the data to avoid being exposed

  • Legitimate Cyber-Attack, motives remains unclear. Random hack? Undercover activities? Etc.

Theories & Possible Explanations

  • Identify key evidence that supports or contradicts each theory.

  • Consider the motivations of different stakeholders i.e. who benefits or loses from Project Evergreen’s disappearance?

  • Are there any gaps or missing pieces of information that weaken or strengthen a particular theory?

  • Rank the theories in order of most to least plausible, based on logical reasoning and available evidence.

  • Ensure that each argument follows a clear structure with premises leading to a logical conclusion.

Corporate Sabotage

  • What evidence supports or contradicts this theory?

Government Cover-Up

  • What evidence supports or contradicts this theory?

Research Fraud

  • What evidence supports or contradicts this theory?

Legitimate Cyber-Attack

  • What evidence supports or contradicts this theory?

Theories & Possible Explanations

Corporate Sabotage

  • Strong motive, historical precedent, real-world parallels.

Supporting Evidence
  • The World Plastics Alliance (WPA) represents powerful corporations whose business would be severely disrupted by biodegradable plastic.

Contradicting Evidence
  • No direct evidence links the WPA to the cyberattack or disappearance.

  • Public denial from WPA and lack of concrete proof weakens this theory.

Stakeholder Motivation
  • High — WPA would face financial loss and industry disruption if Project Evergreen succeeded.

Theories & Possible Explanations

Government Cover-Up

  • Plausible due to economic concerns, but less direct evidence.

Supporting Evidence
  • The GSS Task Force, made up of governments, allegedly received classified warnings about the risks of the biodegradable technology.

  • Governments heavily invested in the plastics and petroleum industry may suppress disruptive tech to protect their economies.

Contradicting Evidence
  • No whistleblower or document directly implicates government orders or involvement in suppressing the project.

  • GSS officially supported the project initially.

Stakeholder Motivation
  • Moderate to High — Governments may act to preserve economic stability or under pressure from lobbyists.

Theories & Possible Explanations

Legitimate Cyber-Attack

  • Technically confirmed but lacking attribution.

Supporting Evidence
  • A forensic cybersecurity report confirms a sophisticated breach, possibly industrial espionage.

  • Modern sustainability projects are frequent cyberattack targets (Plastics Machinery & Manufacturing report).

Contradicting Evidence
  • No attribution — Experts could not confirm who was behind the breach.

Stakeholder Motivation
  • Unknown/Varied — Depends on whether attackers were hired saboteurs or independent agents.

Theories & Possible Explanations

Research Fraud

  • Possible, but least supported by hard evidence.

Supporting Evidence
  • An anonymous whistleblower claims the biodegradable material did not meet industry standards and the team tried to cover up flaws.

  • Scientists, including Dr. Carter, have given conflicting statements, not outright admissions.

Contradicting Evidence
  • No hard evidence confirming falsification

  • Scientists, including Dr. Carter, have given conflicting statements, not outright admissions.

Stakeholder Motivation
  • Moderate – Scientist could fear reputational damage if results are exposed as flawed.

  • No hard evidence confirming falsification.

  • Scientists, including Dr. Carter, have given conflicting statements, not outright admissions.

Credibility & Logical Soundness

  • How did your team determine which sources were credible?

    • By looking at the source link and checking whether if the link looks out of place or whether the things.

    • Verifying information on the site. Look for up-to-date information, clear and unbiased writing, and a comprehensive perspective on the topic

  • Were any sources found to be misleading or biased? Explain.

    • They were no sources that we found that was misleading or were biased to certain parties.

  • Did your team identify any logical fallacies in the conflicting reports?

    • Our team did not find any fallacies in the links or reports we have read for this project.

Credibility & Logical Soundness

  • What steps did you take to ensure your argument is free from logical fallacies?

    • Double checking the information from website we are using.

    • Making our statement clear and simple.

    • Using logical structures for our argument.

Final Argument & Conclusion

  • What is your team’s final conclusion about what happened to Project Evergreen?

  • Ensure your argument has a clear structure with premises that logically lead to your conclusion.

  • Justify your conclusion using the IIAEE framework (Interpret, Investigate, Analyse, Evaluate, Explain).

  • Address at least one counterargument and explain why your conclusion is stronger.

Final Argument & Conclusion

  • What is your team’s final conclusion about what happened to Project Evergreen?

  • Project Evergreen was most likely sabotaged through a coordinated cyber-attack commissioned by corporate interests, specifically, people among the World Plastics Alliance.

  • Ensure your argument has a clear structure with premises that logically lead to your conclusion.

  • The theory is supported by the motive, technical breach confirmation, and a pattern of suppression targeting disruptive green technologies.

Final Argument & Conclusion

  • Justify your conclusion using the IIAEE framework (Interpret, Investigate, Analyse, Evaluate, Explain).


  • Interpret – Project Evergreen, a high-impact sustainability initiative that introduced a biodegradable plastic solution, threatened major industrial sectors, until it was sabotaged.


  • Investigate – Four primary theories – Corporate sabotage, Government cover-up, Legitimate cyber-attack, Research Fraud


  • Analyse –

    • Premise 1: If Project Evergreen succeeded, World Plastics Alliance (WPA), will be in great financial loss.

    • Premise 2: Cyber-attack was confirmed.

    • Premise 3: WPA has a history of resisting sustainable innovations.

    • Premise 4: WPA or affiliated parties would most likely benefit from this damage to Project Evergreen


  • Evaluate – Corporate sabotage? Very high (in theory and motive) but no direct link to WPA, Cyber Attack (Independent) confirmed but no trace from who or where. Both are the top explanations, the sudden disappearance of data and prototypes and the timing, just before public release.

  • Given these factors, further investigation is needed to ascertain the true nature of the events surrounding Project Evergreen, including a detailed audit of WPA's internal communications and activities leading up to the attack.

  • Explain – Cyberattack is confirmed, however we are still unable to identify the specific suspect, but most likely commissioned by a threatened corporate, (e.g. WPA), mainly because of motive (financial threat), research fraud seems unlikely with only an anonymous claim. Government cover-up has moderate evidence but no direct orders or documents.

Final Argument & Conclusion

  • Address at least one counterargument and explain why your conclusion is stronger.

  • One might argue governments had reason to suppress the project due to potential economic disruptions. Governments initially backed Evergreen through the GSS Task Force. No internal government memos or leaked files suggest active suppression. Governments typically delay, not erase or sabotage, such projects — a tactic more aligned with corporate defense. Therefore, while government hesitation is plausible, full cover-up and sabotage is less consistent with typical political risk management behavior

References

  • List all sources used in your investigation