Pro-Social Behavior: Altruism & Helping

What Is Altruism?

Unselfish acts through which people help alleviate suffering

  • Comforting, sharing, helping, showing concern, community service, cooperation

A concept found across moral and religious traditions

  • Central to Buddhist, Christian, Hindu, and Islamic belief systems, among many others

Naming the Concept

Auguste Comte (1851) first framed altruism as a basis for selfless moral acts. Since Comte, psychologists have debated how selfless an act must be to count as truly altruistic

Altruism vs Egoistic Altruism

  • Altruistic Motivation

    • The helper aids the recipient as an end in itself. The helper may still experience positive feelings, but only as an unintended consequence. The aid is not used as an instrumental means to gain social approval, avoid guilt, or obtain self-satisfaction.

  • Egoistic Motivation (Freud, 1920/1955)

    • The view that acts of altruism are, at their core, driven by self-interest. People are motivated by the sense of self-worth they gain from helping others, not by genuine concern for them. Freud argued that no act is truly selfless and that all altruism is ultimately driven by egoism.

The Social Production of Altruism

Theoretical Framing & Background

  • Challenging the Deficit Model: Mainstream sociological and psychological literature historically depicted low-income urban communities (specifically public housing developments) through a deficit lens. Framing them as spaces of social disorganization, nihilism, crime, and depleted social capital

  • Reframing Altruism in Context: Classical altruism research has often focused on extreme, high-stakes acts (such as those of Holocaust rescuers) or on artificial laboratory experiments. Mattis and colleagues shifted focus toward routine, everyday prosociality embedded within structurally disadvantaged contexts.

  • Community-Based Participatory Research (CBPR): Rather than imposing top-down psychological taxonomies, the researchers partnered directly with community residents to capture indigenous, ecologically grounded definitions and expressions of altruism.

Methodological Specifics

  • Design: Qualitative, ethnographic field study using in-depth semi-structured interviews and thematic content analysis

  • Participants: N = 40 adult residents (predominantly African American) living in an economically distressed public housing community (Hasseldorn Houses) in New York City.

Key Findings: The 4 Overarching Motivational Categories

Content analyses revealed an interplay among 14 discrete sub-motives, synthesized into four primary categories:

  1. Needs-Centered Motives: Direct, affective responses to perceived vulnerability, physical crisis, or material scarcity among neighbors (ex., providing food, childcare, or shelter when immediate survival needs arise).

  2. Norm-Based Motives: Actions driven by internalized cultural, spiritual, and relational expectations. This included religious/faith obligations to serve, familial norms, and localized communal reciprocity.

  3. Abstract Moral / Axiological Principles: Commitments to overarching ethical concepts such as justice, human dignity, fairness, and moral integrity.

  4. Sociopolitical & Communal Motives: Helping is framed as an act of resistance, collective uplift, and community preservation, aimed at protecting youth and creating safety within an under-resourced environment.

Theoretical Takeaways

  • Community-Based / Ecological Perspective on Altruism: Altruism in marginalized settings operates not as an individualistic luxury, but as a vital structural buffer that compensates for systemic resource gaps.

  • Intersection with Batson’s Model: The findings support Batson’s thesis that altruism can coexist alongside personal (and communal) solidarity, demonstrating that empathy-driven helping flourishes even under extreme material constraint.

Motivation Categories of Altruism

  • Needs-centered

    • Responding to the emotional, physical, and material needs of individuals and groups

  • Norms-based

    • Enacting religious, faith, or ideological beliefs about helping selflessly

  • Abstract

    • A sense of the sanctity of human life; self-characterization as a caring person

  • Socio-political

    • Personal experience of poverty or discrimination linked to valuing human life

The Selfish Hypothesis

Core Premise: Universal Egoism

  • The psychological claim is that all human action, including helping others, is ultimately driven by self-interest. In this view, “pure” altruism is an illusion.

Key Mechanisms

  1. Negative-State Relief: Helping others primarily to escape one’s own vicarious distress, sadness, or guilt

  2. Social & Tangible Rewards: Gaining praise, status, reciprocity, or material benefits

  3. Warm Glow: Helping to achieve internal positive affect and self-reinforcement

  4. Empathic Joy: Helping solely to experience the vicarious pleasure of seeing another person’s relief

Seven Functions of Volunteering

  1. Values: to express humanitarian values

  2. Career: to explore careers

  3. Understanding: to gain an understanding of the world

  4. Enhancement: to feel important & build esteem & networks

  5. Protective: to provide distraction from personal concerns

  6. Social: to satisfy expectations

  7. Community concern: to satisfy an obligation to the community

The Costs of Volunteering

  • Compassion fatigue and burnout

    • Overextending on pro-social tasks can reduce empathy over time

  • Coercion in the workplace

    • Unpaid volunteering in the workplace can result from managerial pressure

  • Undermining status and unequal recognition

    • Unpaid work can undercut its own status; outsiders get called volunteers while the same support work within affected communities goes unrecognized (ex., a student volunteering at a public housing community [maybe for credit] vs the unpaid work those in that community do to help each other)

Kitty Genovese

  • In 1964, Kitty Genovese was murdered outside her apartment building in Queens, New York

  • Newspaper reports at the time claimed that dozens of neighbors heard or witnessed the attack and did nothing

    • A story that shocked the public (some of the reporting was later found to be exaggerated or inaccurate)

  • The case motivated social psychologists John Darley and Bibb Latene to research:

    • Does the mere presence of other bystanders change whether any one of them helps?

Darley & Latene (1968): The Bystander Study

Methodology & Design

  • Sample Condition: Participants engaged in an intercom-based discussion under the impression they were paired with either 1, 2, or 5 other individuals (who were, in actuality, pre-recorded confederates).

  • Experimental Stimulus: A designated confederate simulated an acute medical emergency (seizure) and explicitly requested assistance.

  • Independent Variable: The sole experimental manipulation was the perceived number of bystander participants privy to the distress call

Results

  • Behavioral Outcomes: Prosocial intervention rates correlated inversely with group size; both the probability and velocity of the helping response declined significantly as the perceived number of bystanders increased.

  • Physiological Indexing: The lack of intervention was not indicative of psychological apathy. Participants in larger group conditions exhibited significantly higher levels of physiological distress while failing to act, suggesting severe motivational conflict.

The Bystander Effect

The presence of other witnesses inhibits helping behavior; as group size increases, the individual likelihood of helping and the speed of response systematically decrease.

  • Diffusion of responsibility: The tendency for an individual to feel less personal responsibility to help in an emergency when other bystanders are present, because responsibility is assumed to be shared across the group. Each bystander assumes someone else will act, or already has

  • Pluralistic ignorance: People read others’ inaction as a sign that intervention isn’t needed

  • Evaluation apprehension: Fear of being judged for overreacting deters action

The 5-Step Decision Model in Intervention

Helping requires successfully passing five consecutive cognitive hurdles:

  1. Notice the event (Barrier: distraction/stimulus overload)

  2. Interpret it as an emergency (Barrier: pluralistic ignorance)

  3. Assume personal responsibility (Barrier: diffusion of responsibility)

  4. Know what form of assistance to provide (Barrier: lack of competence)

  5. Decide to implement help (Barrier: cost-reward analysis / evaluation apprehension)