Anne Lamott's Writing Process: Shitty First Drafts

Anne Lamott's "Shitty First Drafts"

Author Background

  • Name: Anne Lamott
  • Birth Year: 1954
  • Birthplace: San Francisco
  • Education: Graduate of Goucher College, Baltimore
  • Notable Works:
    • Six novels including:
    • Rosie (1983)
    • Crooked Little Heart (1997)
    • All New People (2000)
    • Blue Shoes (2002)
    • Non-fiction books including:
    • Operating Instructions: A Journal of My Son's First Year (1993)
      • Theme: Adventures as a single parent.
    • Tender Mercies: Some Thoughts on Faith (1999)
      • Theme: Journey toward faith in God.

Key Concept: Shitty First Drafts

  • Core Idea: The necessity of writing poor initial drafts to foster creativity and refine writing.
  • Writing Process:
    • Good writers often produce and embrace multiple drafts, starting with a ‘shitty first draft’ (SFD).
    • Overview of the perceived misconceptions about writing: Successful writers often face difficulties and do not write perfect drafts instantly.

The Reality of the Writing Process

  • Misconceptions:
    • Fantasy of the Uninitiated: Non-writers presume that successful writers sit down feeling confident and write perfectly.
    • Writer's experience contradicts this; they often feel insecure and uninspired.
  • Writers' Common Experiences:
    • Writers do not usually feel enthusiastic or confident.
    • Many face a struggle that resembles pulling teeth while writing.
    • A cited example describes a writer starting each day with almost suicidal pressures, indicating the mental burden writers carry.

Drafting Phases Defined

  1. First Draft (Child's Draft):

    • Described as playful and unfiltered.
    • Focus is on allowing creativity and spontaneity, disregarding errors and restrictions.
    • Writers are encouraged to channel uninhibited thoughts and emotions.
    • Example: Characters expressing absurd phrases like “Well, so what, Mr. Poopy Pants?”
    • Importance of writing without fear of judgment to uncover potential gems in the chaos.
  2. Second Draft (Up Draft):

    • Aimed at refining the narrative by revising and improving clarity.
    • Writers may begin trimming and enhancing their work, fixing structure and flow.
    • Lamott discusses her method of selection and organization using colored pens to edit her drafts critically.
  3. Third Draft (Dental Draft):

    • Involves meticulous examination of the writing akin to checking teeth.
    • Focus on details, grammar, and overall health of the draft.
    • Ensuring that the writing is precise, engaging, and well-structured.

Personal Anecdote & Reflections

  • Example from Lamott's experience:
    • Recalls her time writing food reviews:
    • The process would begin with field research, soaking in experiences with friends, and taking meticulous notes.
    • Each review would initially be panic-inducing, filled with anxiety over the outcome.
    • Emphasizes the cathartic nature of producing a lengthy first draft, even if it initially feels incoherent.
    • Lamott notes the paradox of writing where the act itself is tumultuous while the outcome can ultimately resonate humor and value in later drafts.
  • Self-Critique:
    • Lamott's reflections on the fears associated with writing, the pressure to perform, and the anxiety surrounding creativity influence her trust in the writing process.

Discussion Questions

  1. Fantasy of the Uninitiated:
    • Lamott critiques the common perception that writers easily produce polished work.
    • Explains how misconceptions differ vastly from the harsh realities writers endure.
  2. Trusting the Process:
    • The phrase “sort of, more or less” highlights a universal hesitancy in embracing the chaotic nature of drafting.
    • Raises questions about the collective experience of writers versus personal wariness in the writing process.
  3. Process vs. Product:
    • Suggests that creating a first draft is more about the process of exploration than the final product.
    • Encourages personal reflection on individual drafting experiences, emphasizing the importance of initial creativity over perfection.