The Gut-Brain Axis and the Microbiome
The Concept of Gut Bacteria and Mood Regulation
Introduction to the Microbiome:
The microbiome consists of trillions of microbes that live on and in every human being.
Science is establishing links between these microbes and physical health, but a new, controversial concept suggests they act as an "invisible hand" altering the human brain.
Conditions currently being linked to the microbiome include:
Depression.
Autism.
Neurodegenerative diseases.
The Shift in Perspective:
Historically, it was understood that emotional states affect the gut (e.g., the "butterflies" felt before an exam or job interview).
Current research suggests this is a two-way street, where the gut significantly influences mental health and brain function.
Researchers are exploring "mood microbes" or psychobiotics as a potential revolution for mental health treatment.
Foundational Research and Psychobiotics
The Kyushu University Study (Japan):
This study is credited with igniting the concept of microbial influence on the brain.
Methodology: Researchers compared "germ-free" mice (those never in contact with microbes) against normal mice.
Findings: Germ-free mice produced the amount of stress hormone compared to normal mice when distressed.
Conclusion: Because the animals were identical except for their microbes, the difference in stress response was attributed to their micro-organisms.
Expert Insight - Dr. Jane Foster:
Dr. Jane Foster, a neuropsychiatrist at McMaster University in Canada, identifies the Kyushu paper as the starting point for neuroscientists considering microbes.
She describes it as a "powerful" discovery for those studying depression and anxiety, representing the first hint of microbial medicine in mental health.
Biological Mechanisms of Influence
The Brain-Gut Connection Paths:
The Vagus Nerve: Described as an "information superhighway" connecting the brain and the gut directly.
Chemical Signaling: Bacteria break down dietary fiber into chemicals known as short-chain fatty acids, which have effects throughout the human body.
Immune System: The microbiome influences the immune system, which is increasingly implicated in brain disorders.
Genetic Alteration: Emerging evidence suggests gut bugs use microRNAs (tiny strips of genetic code) to alter the operation of DNA within nerve cells.
Clinical Observations and Microbiome Diversity
Diversity as a Health Metric:
A healthy microbiome is characterized by high diversity, meaning a wide variety of different species living throughout the body.
Prof. Ted Dinan (Cork University Hospital):
In clinically depressed patients, there is a measurable narrowing in the diversity of the microbiota compared to healthy individuals.
While not suggesting it is the sole cause, Dinan believes the microbiome plays a role in the "genesis of depression."
Lifestyles that weaken gut bacteria, such as a diet low in fiber, increase vulnerability to these conditions.
Statistical Composition of the Human Microbiome
Cellular and Genetic Data:
Cellular Ratio: Humans are more microbe than human. By cell count, only of the body is comprised of human cells.
Microbiome Components: Includes bacteria, viruses, fungi, and single-celled archaea.
The "Second Genome":
The human genome contains approximately genes (genetic instructions).
The microbial genome (the sum of all microbial genes in the body) ranges between and genes ( million to million).
Linked Diseases: This second genome is linked to allergy, obesity, inflammatory bowel disease, Parkinson's, and the efficacy of cancer drugs, as well as depression and autism.
Experimental Evidence: Microbial Transplants
Behavioral Transmission via Microbiota:
Scientists at the APC Microbiome Centre (University College Cork) performed transplants of microbiome samples from depressed humans into rats—a procedure colloquially known as a "trans-poo-sion."
Prof. John Cryan's Findings:
The researchers were surprised to find they could reproduce many features of a depressed individual in a rat simply through microbiome samples.
Anhedonia: A symptom of depression where individuals lose interest in pleasurable activities. In the study, rats normally crave sugary water, but once they received the microbiome from a depressed human, "they no longer cared" for the treat.
The Case of Parkinson's Disease
Gut-Brain Link in Neurodegeneration:
Parkinson's is classically defined as a brain disorder involving the death of brain cells, resulting in muscle control loss and tremors.
Prof. Sarkis Mazmanian (Caltech):
Argues that gut bacteria are causal or at least driving the motor symptoms of Parkinson's.
Studies on mice genetically predisposed to Parkinson's showed that gut bacteria were necessary for the disease to manifest.
Experiment: When stool from Parkinson's patients was transplanted into these mice, their motor symptoms became "much worse" compared to those receiving stool from healthy individuals.
The Future of Psychobiotics and Personalized Medicine
Therapeutic Potential:
There is potential for psychiatrists to prescribe "probiotic cocktails" of healthy bacteria to treat mental health and neurodegenerative conditions.
Dr. Kirsten Tillisch (UCLA):
Highlights the need for much larger studies to identify specific species and sub-species of bacteria that affect the brain and their chemical products in the gut.
Views this as a way to potentially prevent disease in addition to helping those already suffering.
The Malleability of the Second Genome:
Unlike human DNA, the microbiome is highly changeable. It is altered by:
The food we eat.
The pets we live with.
Medicinal drugs.
The way we are born.
Predictions for the Future (Prof. John Cryan):
Within the next years, microbiome assessments will become standard medical practice, similar to cholesterol testing.
The microbiome is considered the fundamental future of personalized medicine.