Disrupting Molded Images: Identities, Responsibilities and Relationships—Teachers and Indigenous Subject Material
Introduction
Source Information: Teaching Education, Vol. 18, No. 4, December 2007, pp. 329-342.
ISSN: 1047-6210 (print)/1470-1286 (online)
DOI: 10.1080/10476210701687625
Author: Susan D. Dion, Faculty of Education, York University, Canada (email: sdion@edu.yorku.ca).
Overview of the Paper
Main Focus: The complexities of teachers’ understanding of their relationship with Indigenous (Aboriginal) peoples in Canada.
Method: Initiation of a critical pedagogy of remembrance, allowing teachers to reflect on their past relationships with Indigenous peoples.
Thesis: Teachers often position themselves as “perfect strangers” to Aboriginal peoples due to limited understanding shaped by colonial narratives.
Proposed Change: Transformation of relationships between Aboriginal and non-Aboriginal peoples through ethical learning and critical awareness.
Disrupting Molded Images
Reference: Thomas King's Massey Lecture Series, You’re not the Indian I had in mind.
Discusses the issue of identity and representation in Aboriginal peoples.
The term "Indian" and the realities of Indigenous identities versus western perceptions.
Key Quote: "In the end, there is no reason for the Indian to be real. The Indian simply has to exist in our imaginations… for to be seen as 'real'…we must be 'authentic'" (King, 2003, p. 54).
Argument: Dominant discourses must be disrupted to alter understanding and narratives about Aboriginal peoples.
Authors Cited: Daniel Francis (1992), Battiste (1998), Dion (2000, 2005).
Effect of schooling and curriculum on perceptions of Indigenous peoples.
The Role of Teachers
Observation: Many teachers express feeling like “perfect strangers” regarding Aboriginal peoples.
Statements reflect isolation from Indigenous cultures and limited educational experiences related to Aboriginal content.
Concerns Raised:
What is the appeal of this identity?
How does it protect individuals from confronting their own knowledge about Indigenous histories?
The need for teachers to engage with their experiences and relationship with Aboriginal peoples to enhance educational practices.
Critical Pedagogy and Antiracism in Teacher Education
Literature Basis: Scholars in Canada and internationally document the successes and dilemmas of multicultural and antiracist education (e.g., Dei, 1996; Sleeter, 1993).
Critical Self-Reflection: A necessary process for teachers.
Influences of critical pedagogues like Freire, hooks, and Giroux.
Challenges: Ensuring teachers see the historical and socio-political context of their beliefs and pedagogical practices.
Remembrance as a Source of Radical Renewal
Course Requirement: "File of (un)certainties".
Involves collecting and reflecting on “cultural artifacts” related to personal relationships with Indigenous knowledge.
Purpose: To allow students to engage actively with their personal memories and contemporary Aboriginal narratives.
Key Concepts:
Personal and public memory integration.
Reflective confrontation with existing truths and assumptions.
Benjamin's Strategy: To alter the associations between past and present rather than erase history.
Engaging with Indigenous Artists
Artists Examined: Primarily Jane Ash Poitras and Gerald McMaster along with storytellers like Daniel David Moses.
Their works engage with themes of identity, culture, and colonization.
Student Engagement: Requires analysis of how their personal experiences resonate with Indigenous narratives and art.
The "File of (un)certainties" Assignment
Structure: Students juxtapose their cultural artifacts with course content.
Draws attention to personal involvement in dominant discourses about Aboriginal peoples.
Purpose: To encourage recognition of implicit biases and historical narratives.
Provides a space for learners to articulate their views and assumptions.
Learning Outcomes: Students reflect on their agency in relation to Indigenous peoples, promoting a dialogue-focused learning environment.
Examples of Student Engagement
Jessica:
Her emotional responses challenged her previous dehumanized views of Aboriginal peoples after viewing Rabbit-Proof Fence and engaging with Harrington’s photographs.
Acknowledges the humanity of Indigenous peoples and reflects on her experiences shaped by dominant narratives.
Kat:
Explores privilege and responsibility through the lens of her experiences at Camp Onondaga.
Questions the historical narratives underlying her enjoyment of the camp, recognizing the erasure of Indigenous histories.
Britt:
Confronts her shared experiences of colonialism but begins to recognize distinctions between her experiences and those of Aboriginal peoples in Canada.
Engages with artwork to critique dominant frameworks that simplify Indigenous histories.
Conclusion
The assignment and framework presented allow teachers to explore their relationships with Aboriginal peoples.
Encourages moving beyond being “perfect strangers” and challenges dominant educational narratives.
Recommendations for future practices include increasing education about Aboriginal histories and engaging with Indigenous content across curricula.
Implication: Ethical responsibility of educators to learn from and engage with Indigenous narratives to foster transformative relationships and understanding.