Study Notes on Cleisthenes and Athenian Democracy

Historical Context

  • After Hippias fled to Persia, many nobles who had been exiled by Pisistratus returned to Athens.

  • The return of these nobles marked the end of tyranny in Athens.

  • Isagoras was elected as archon in 508 BC.

Isagoras and Cleisthenes

  • Isagoras was an eponymous archon (a ceremonial position in Athens).

  • He was a rival of Cleisthenes, who was the grandson of a tyrant from the city-state Sicion.

  • The family of Cleisthenes, the Alkmaionids, was cursed, impacting their political standing.

  • Isagoras accused Cleisthenes of not being a true noble, reflecting the tension between the aristocracy and newly emerging power structures.

Cleisthenes' Reforms

  • Cleisthenes sought to reform Athenian governance by aligning with the demos (the common people).

  • Promised major reforms that would enhance political participation for the commoners, surpassing the earlier reforms of Solon.

Cleomenes' Intervention
  • Isagoras, feeling threatened by Cleisthenes, sought help from Cleomenes, the Spartan king, to remove Cleisthenes and his followers.

  • Spartan intervention resulted in the exile of Cleisthenes and his allies from Athens.

  • Athenians opposed this intervention, leading to civil unrest, culminating in a siege against Isagoras and Cleomenes on the Acropolis.

Characteristics of Athenian Governance

  • Athenian governance began to evolve under Cleisthenes’ influence towards democracy.

  • Previously, Athenian tribes were divided mainly along aristocratic lines, but Cleisthenes reformed this structure.

Establishment of the Tribes

  • Cleisthenes established a new division of the populace into ten tribes named after Athenian heroes (e.g., Heracles, Perseus).

  • Each tribe was subdivided into smaller units known as demes, promoting inclusivity and regional representation.

  • This change fostered a stronger sense of belonging among Athenians and reduced aristocratic bias.

The Structure of Demes
  • Each of the ten tribes comprised three geographic districts: city, coast, and inland regions.

  • A total of 100 demes existed within Attica.

  • Village life remained largely unchanged, allowing local governance and autonomy under elected officials, known as demarchs.

Elections and Political Structure

  • The demarch (mayor) of each deme was elected annually, reinforcing local governance and participation.

  • A list of citizens was maintained, adding new male citizens upon reaching the age of 18, guaranteeing their participation as citizens.

  • Transition from membership in phraties (clans) to more democratic deme membership.

The Boule and the Ecclesia

  • Cleisthenes expanded the council (Boule) from 400 to 500 members, with representation from each of the ten tribes.

  • The Boule managed administrative tasks and prepared legislation for the Ecclesia, the assembly of citizens.

  • The Boule met in the Agora and was instrumental in shaping Athenian policy.

Functioning of the Boule
  • Citizens over the age of 30 were eligible to serve in the Boule; however, the poor were often unable to participate due to financial constraints of not having stipends.

  • The Boule's daily affairs were managed by a rotating group of 50 counselors chosen by lot, representing each tribe.

The Assembly (Ecclesia)

  • The Ecclesia was composed of all male citizens over 18 who could speak and vote on various issues presented by the Boule.

  • Important decisions made by the Ecclesia included laws, elections, and penalties.

  • The gathering points in Athens for these assemblies were at notable locations such as the Pnyx hill.

The Concept of Ostracism

  • The practice of ostracism was introduced as a measure to prevent the rise of oppressive figures.

  • Citizens could vote to exile someone they deemed dangerous, using ostraca (pieces of pottery) to record their votes.

  • A minimum of 6,000 votes was typically required for an ostracism to take effect, with the exiled individual facing a ten-year banishment without loss of property or citizenship.

Military Organization under Cleisthenes

  • Each tribe would provide one hoplite regiment, totaling ten for the city of Athens.

  • Each regiment had a general, known as a strategos, who was elected annually by the Ecclesia.

  • The strategoi gained prominence in military and political structures as they could be re-elected during times of war, signifying their importance in Athenian governance.

Key Takeaways

  • Cleisthenes' reforms laid the groundwork for greater citizen participation in Athenian democracy by restructuring political divisions and creating institutions aimed at representing the populace.

  • The changes from aristocratic affiliations to tribal ones fostered unity among the Athenian people, who were now more closely tied to their local communities than to noble families.

  • Understanding this shift is fundamental for comprehending the evolution of democracy in ancient Athens, its contrasts with Spartan governance, and its eventual implications in historical context.