Lecture 7 – Development & Evo-Devo Study Notes

Assigned Readings

  • 10th Edition Campbell Biology: §§ 18.4, 21.618.4,\ 21.6 (from “Widespread Cons…” to end), 25.725.7 (“Major changes…”)
  • 11th Edition: §§ 18.4, 21.6, 25.618.4,\ 21.6,\ 25.6
  • 12th Edition: §§ 18.4, 21.6, 25.518.4,\ 21.6,\ 25.5
  • BBC Natural History Unit segments (visual support)

Course Administration

  • Project 11 – Lab 22 this week.
    • Attendance compulsory; if legitimately unable, e-mail Tracy Harris (T.A.Harris@massey.ac.nz).

Learning Outcomes

  • Explain how alterations in regulatory genes yield major evolutionary change.
  • Recall how Hox-gene expression & mutation create morphological diversity.
  • Describe how heterochrony generates morphological differences in closely-related species.

Key Concepts & Vocabulary

• Homology  • Homeotic / Hox genes  • Heterochrony
• Allometry  • Neoteny / Paedomorphosis  • Evo-devo
• Garstang’s Hypothesis  • Important Taxa: Chimpanzees, Chordates, Barnacles, Drosophila

Darwinian Review – Adaptation

  • Populations could grow geometrically →\rightarrow resources finite →\rightarrow “struggle for existence.”
  • Variation heritable; variants enhancing survival/reproduction rise in frequency.

What Is Developmental Biology?

  • Investigates processes that transform zygote →\rightarrow reproductive adult.
  • Evolutionary change in form/function must trace to changes in development.
    • Evo-bio asks why traits evolve; Dev-bio explains how.

Historical Interplay of Development & Evolution

Barnacles Case Study

  • 18th18^{\text{th}}–19th19^{\text{th}} C. barnacles classified as molluscs (Linnaeus, Cuvier).
  • 18341834 Burmeister describes larval stages; affinities with arthropods.
  • Darwin ( 1851–18541851\text{–}1854 ) publishes four-volume monograph “Cirripedia,” demonstrating developmental data crucial for taxonomy.

Darwin on Development ("Origin of Species," Ch. XIV)

  • Emphasized morphology, embryology, rudimentary organs; coined “unity of type.”
  • Example homology: human hand, mole paw, horse leg, porpoise flipper, bat wing share pattern.

The Modern Evolutionary Synthesis & Its Gap

  • Synthesis unified Darwinian selection + Mendelian genetics.
  • Development omitted due to:
    • Sparse mechanistic knowledge.
    • Debate: Structuralists (gradualism) vs Saltationists (large-effect mutations).

Molecular Era Bridges the Gap

  • 1950s1950s DNA confirmed as hereditary material.
  • King & Wilson (19751975): ≈99%\approx 99\% human–chimp amino-acid similarity.
  • Sibley & Ahlquist (19871987): ≈99%\approx 99\% DNA hybridization similarity.
  • Chimp genome (20052005) corroborates ≈99%\approx 99\% nucleotide identity.
  • Phenotypic gulf ( 3×3\times bigger brain, obligate bipedalism, slower maturation, reduced hair) implies importance of gene regulation.

Regulatory-Genome Hypothesis

  • Jacob & Monod (19611961): proteins regulate bacterial genes.
  • Britten & Davidson (1969,19711969, 1971): alterations in regulatory programs can yield “enormous changes”; propose repetitive DNA as reservoir for regulatory innovation.

EVO-DEVO Defined

  • Field comparing development among taxa to infer ancestry & evolutionary mechanisms.
  • Demonstrates major body-form change from mutations/rewiring of developmental genes (macro-evolution).

Evolution of Genes Controlling Development

Categories of Developmental Modification

  1. Rate (growth velocity of parts)
  2. Timing (onset/termination of events)
  3. Spatial Pattern (where genes expressed)
Heterochrony
  • Any evolutionary shift in relative rate/timing of developmental processes.
  • Alters morphology dramatically.
Allometry
  • Study of size vs shape relationships.
  • Differential growth rates →\rightarrow proportion changes.
  • Example: Human vs Chimp skulls follow distinct allometric curves; juvenile chimp skull resembles human adult (illustrates paedomorphosis).
  • Beetle horns (Onthophagus) display species-specific horn-to-thorax allometries; phylogenetically informative.
Paedomorphosis / Neoteny
  • Reproductive maturation accelerates relative to somatic; adult retains juvenile ancestry traits.
  • Ambystoma mexicanum (axolotl): sexually mature with larval gills.
Macro-examples
  • Cetacean limb reduction: heterochronic delay/loss of hind-limb buds vs ancestral artiodactyls.
  • Pakicetus →\rightarrow Rodhocetus →\rightarrow Dorudon →\rightarrow modern whales ( 7070 Mya →\rightarrow present) show progressive pelvis & limb regression.
Garstang’s Hypothesis ( 19281928 )
  • Proposed chordates originate via neoteny in tunicate larva.
    • Larval tunicate possesses chordate traits (notochord, dorsal nerve cord, tail, pharyngeal slits).
    • Hypothetical lineage: tunicate larva abandons sessile adult phase, becomes sexually mature →\rightarrow cephalochordate-like ancestor →\rightarrow vertebrates.
  • Modern molecular phylogenies: Cephalochordates basal; Tunicates sister to vertebrates; hypothesis historically pivotal for concept that life-cycle stage can found new lineage.

Chordate Overview

  • Subphyla:
    • Cephalochordata (lancelets): retain all 44 chordate features for life.
    • Urochordata (tunicates): features present only in larva; adult loses notochord, tail, most nervous system.
    • Vertebrata: express features in embryo; some lost later (e.g., human notochord →\rightarrow intervertebral discs).

Homeotic (Hox) Genes & Spatial Patterning

  • Hox proteins give cells positional identity along anterior–posterior axis.
  • Conserved across Metazoa; often arranged in colinear clusters.

Classic Drosophila Phenotypes

  • Antennapedia mutant: legs replace antennae.
  • Bithorax mutant (Ubx loss): third thoracic segment grows wing instead of haltere ⇒\Rightarrow four-winged fly.

Vertebrate Examples

  • Limb buds form where Hox C6 expression absent (chicken) vs ubiquitous axial expression suppressing limbs (snake).
  • Change in Ubx-like gene in crustaceans can “turn off” legs posteriorly →\rightarrow six-legged insects from many-legged ancestors (lab recapitulation ∼400\sim 400 Mya event).

Synthesis

  • Major evolutionary innovations may require few genetic changes if those changes occur in regulatory/developmental loci.
  • Evo-devo integrates genetics, embryology, paleontology, and comparative morphology to explain macroevolutionary patterns—mass radiations, body-plan novelties, and lineage-specific morphologies.

Ethical, Philosophical & Practical Implications

  • Understanding regulatory mutations refines debates on human uniqueness despite ≥99%\ge 99\% genomic identity with chimps.
  • Insight into congenital malformations, regenerative medicine, and synthetic-biology (engineering body plans).
  • Conservation: developmental plasticity influences species’ ability to adapt to environmental change.

Take-Home Messages

  • Developmental processes are the proximate mechanism through which natural selection shapes form.
  • Changes in when, how fast, or where genes act can yield new morphologies without extensive protein-coding divergence.
  • Evo-devo shows that micro-level genetic tweaks can scale to macro-level evolutionary transitions, making development central to evolutionary theory.