Study Notes on Indian Sociologists

UNDERSTANDING SOCIETY: INDIAN SOCIOLOGISTS

Introduction to Sociology in India

  • Sociology is a relatively young discipline globally, established about a century ago in Europe.

  • India's interest in sociology began slightly over a century ago, with formal university teaching starting in 1919 at the University of Bombay.

  • Subsequent establishment of sociology and anthropology programs in the 1920s at Calcutta and Lucknow universities.

  • Presently, every major university in India has departments of sociology, social anthropology, or both.

  • Initially, the nature of Indian sociology was uncertain; scholars had to define the discipline's role in the context of a colonized nation experiencing modernity.

Major Founding Figures of Indian Sociology

Development of Indian Sociology
  • Early Indian sociologists were often 'accidental' in their roles, developing the discipline through hands-on experience rather than formal paths.

  • Pioneering figures included L.K. Ananthakrishna Iyer and Sarat Chandra Roy, who laid foundational work in the field.

  • Following pioneers who established formal institutions in Indian sociology were G.S. Ghurye, D.P. Mukerji, A.R. Desai, and M.N. Srinivas.

L.K. Ananthakrishna Iyer (1861-1937)
  • Career: Started as a clerk, later became a teacher in Cochin State.

  • Conducted ethnographic surveys during voluntary service as Superintendent of Ethnography for Cochin's Dewan.

  • National and international recognition despite lacking formal qualifications in anthropology.

  • Contributed to anthropology education by establishing the first post-graduate anthropology department in India at Calcutta University (1917-1932).

  • Awarded honorary doctorate; recognized as a notable figure by British scholars.

Sarat Chandra Roy (1871-1942)
  • Background: Started as a teacher in Ranchi before practicing law, influencing his interest in tribal societies.

  • Conducted extensive ethnographic research, leading to authority on the culture of tribal peoples in the Chhotanagpur region (now Jharkhand).

  • Published extensively, founding the journal "Man in India," the first of its kind in India.

The Challenges of Defining Indian Sociology

  • Early sociologists grappled with defining what Indian sociology should focus on, particularly related to issues of modernity and colonialism.

  • They faced the challenge of how to relate to tribal cultures within a society characterized by both ancient civilizations and perceived 'primitive' societies.

  • The necessity for sociology in post-independence India was linked to the upcoming challenges of planned development and democracy.

Institutional Development of Sociology in India

G.S. Ghurye (1893-1983)
  • Birth: December 12, 1893, in Malvan, Maharashtra.

  • Education: Joined Elphinstone College, graduated in 1916, completed M.A. in 1918.

  • Influence: Studied at LSE and Cambridge, influenced by notable scholars L.T. Hobhouse and W.H.R. Rivers,

  • Contributions: Headed the first post-graduate department of Sociology at Bombay University (35 years), authored numerous research works.

  • Notable ideas: Combined teaching and research, merged sociology with anthropology, prolific writings on caste, tribes, and Hindu identity.

    • Caste and Race in India (1932): Critique of race theories proposed by Herbert Risley, analyzed the intersection of race and caste dynamics.

D.P. Mukerji (1894-1961)
  • Born on October 5, 1894; educated in Economics and Sociology.

  • Held various notable positions, including lectureships at different universities.

  • Concerned with India's socio-cultural context, emphasized the significance of tradition adjusted for change.

    • Argued that sociology must reflect on social traditions to understand social dynamics in India, emphasizing 'living traditions.'

A.R. Desai (1915-1994)
  • Born in 1915; involved with various political movements, primarily Marxist.

  • Best work: Social Background of Indian Nationalism (1948) analyzed nationalism through a Marxist lens.

  • Critiqued the welfare state, arguing it failed to deliver on its promises.

  • Identified critical aspects of the welfare state, including interventionist roles and the complexities of state ownership versus capitalism.

M.N. Srinivas (1916-1999)
  • Influenced by Ghurye; earned doctorates from Bombay University and Oxford, focused on social anthropology.

  • Notable work on village studies; emphasized the relevance of the village as a social unit amidst changing dynamics.

  • Engaged in debates on the significance of villages versus social institutions like caste, highlighting historical changes in villages.

Themes in Indian Sociology

Caste and Race
  • Ghurye defined caste using six essential features: segmental division, hierarchical division, restrictions on social interaction, differential rights and duties, occupational restrictions, and marriage restrictions.

  • His works suggested that caste functions as a means of regulating social interactions and maintains traditional structures.

Tradition and Change
  • D.P. Mukerji discussed ‘living traditions’ as adapting frameworks linking past and present, highlighting the shifts in social practices while retaining traditional elements.

  • Proposed dynamics of collective experiences in fostering changes within traditions.

Village Studies in Sociology
  • M.N. Srinivas emphasized the empirical necessity of villages in understanding rural sociology and dynamics. He challenged notions of villages as stagnant entities and illustrated their interactions with broader socio-economic contexts.

Conclusion

  • The contributions of scholars like Ghurye, Mukerji, Desai, and Srinivas laid the groundwork for Indian sociology, reflecting diverse and contextual inquiries into Indian society's evolution.

  • Their work demonstrated the need to adapt sociological practices to the Indian context, moving beyond purely western paradigms while fostering critical discussions on tradition and modernization.

GLOSSARY

  • Administrator-anthropologists: British officials who engaged in anthropological research during the colonial period.

  • Anthropometry: Study of human racial types through bodily measurements.

  • Assimilation: The absorption of one culture into another, leading to loss of distinctive cultural identities.

  • Endogamy: Marriage limited to within a specific social group.

  • Exogamy: Marriage outside a defined social or kin group.

  • Laissez-faire: Economic philosophy of minimal government intervention in markets, often linked to classical liberalism.