Nationalism and Patriotism Notes

Nationalism

  • An ideology and movement focused on promoting the interests of a particular nation, especially its sovereignty.
  • A nation should be self-regulating without external intervention.
  • The nation is seen as a natural and ideal political foundation and the only legitimate source of political authority.
  • Emphasizes loyalty to the country.
  • Aims to establish and maintain a unified national identity based on shared culture, language, religion, politics, and history.
  • Seeks to preserve traditional culture and foster pride in national achievements.
  • Strongly associated with patriotism.
  • Often combined with other ideologies like conservatism or socialism.

Types of Nationalism

  • Expressed along civil, ethnic, cultural, religious, or ideological lines.
  • Categories are not mutually exclusive.

Ethnic Nationalism (Ethnonationalism)

  • Based on shared ethnicity, descent, culture, and language.
  • The nation is hereditary.
  • The state's legitimacy comes from its role as the ethnic group's homeland and its duty to protect and promote the group.
  • Anthony D. Smith uses "ethnic nationalism" for non-Western concepts of nationalism.
  • "Ethnonationalism" is used for explicit ideologies, while "ethnic nationalism" is used for informal views.
  • "Ethnocentric nationalism" or "tribal nationalism" are pejorative terms, though "tribal nationalism" can be non-pejorative in certain contexts.

Civic Nationalism

  • The state's legitimacy comes from citizen involvement and reflecting the "will of the individual."
  • Rooted in rationalism and liberalism.
  • Membership is voluntary.
  • Influenced the growth of representative democracy in nations like the United States and France.

State Nationalism

  • A version of civic nationalism, often paired with ethnic nationalism.
  • The country is a community of those who contribute to the state's maintenance and strength.
  • Individuals exist to contribute to the state's objectives.
  • Can lead to fascism, characterized by authoritarianism and nationalism.

Expansionist Nationalism

  • A radical form of imperialism combining patriotic feelings with expansionism, often through military aggression.
  • Coined in the late 19th century during the "Scramble for Africa."
  • Associated with military governments in the 20th century like Fascist Italy, Nazi Germany, and Imperial Japan.
  • Believes some nations are superior and have the right to expand at the expense of their neighbors.

Romantic Nationalism

  • Also known as organic nationalism or identity nationalism.
  • The state's legitimacy comes from the nation's natural expression.
  • Based on a historical ethnic culture meeting a romantic ideal.
  • Expresses Romanticism's values and opposes the rationalism of the Enlightenment.
  • Emphasizes folklore.

Cultural Nationalism

  • The country is defined by shared culture, not just civic or ethnic factors.
  • Membership is neither fully voluntary nor hereditary.
  • A traditional culture can be integrated into people's lives, especially early in life (Conversi, 2008).
  • Defined as a variety of non-civic or ethnic nationalism (Nielsen, 1999).

Third World Nationalism

  • Nationalist feelings arise from opposition to colonial rule to maintain domestic identity.
  • "Third World" is an outdated term for economically developing nations, falling behind First and Second Worlds but ahead of Fourth World.
  • Preferred terms: developing nation, underdeveloped country, or low- and middle-income country (LMIC).

Liberal Nationalism

  • Defended by political philosophers as a non-xenophobic form of nationalism compatible with liberal values.
  • Asserts that people need national identity for a meaningful life and that liberal democracies need domestic identity to function correctly.
  • Values liberty, tolerance, equality, and individual rights (Tamir, 1993; Kymlicka, 1995; Miller 1995).
  • Ernest Renan and John Stuart Mill are considered early liberal nationalists.

Religious Nationalism

  • Connects nationalism to a specific religious faith or affiliation.
  • Shared religion contributes to domestic unity and a mutual bond.
  • Involves the politicization of religion and religion's effects on politics.
  • Religion can support national identity and inspire political activism (Juergensmeyer, 1996).

Pan-Nationalism

  • Ethnic or cultural nationalism referring to a country as a cluster of associated ethnic and cultural communities.

Diaspora Nationalism

  • Nationalist sentiment among an ethnic population residing outside their traditional homeland.

Stateless Nationalism

  • An ethnic or cultural minority within a nation-state aims for independence.

National Conservatism

  • A political term, mainly used in Europe, describing a version of conservatism focused on domestic interests without being unduly nationalist or far-right.

Revolutionary Nationalism

  • An ideological theory advocating for domestic groups united by shared intent and destiny.
  • Promoted by Benito Mussolini.
  • An intellectual synthesis of "radical nationalism and dissident society" in France and Italy in the early 20th century.

Left-Wing Nationalism

  • Combines left-wing politics or socialism with nationalism.
  • Examples include Fidel Castro's 26th of July Movement, Ireland's Sinn Fein, Israel's Labor Zionism, and the African National Congress.