Processing and output controls

Processing Controls and Batch Processing Systems

  • Processing Control Objectives

    • Ensure all records and transactions are processed completely.
    • Ensure transactions are processed with complete accuracy.
    • Ensure transactions are processed no more than once (strictly once, preventing duplicate processing).
    • Establish and maintain a detailed audit trail to enable tracking and resolution of processing difficulties or anomalies.
  • Batch Processing System Characteristics

    • Accumulate transactions occurring throughout the operating day into a bundled batch.
    • Execute batch processing at the end of the day when demands on computer resources are less taxing on infrastructure.
    • Utilize batch controls to effectively manage high volumes of transaction flows.
    • Reconcile final system output directly against the input originally entered into the system.
  • Real-World Case Study on Audit Trails (PricewaterhouseCoopers Merger)

    • Background: Experience as an auditor at Coopers & Lybrand prior to its merger with Price Waterhouse to form PricewaterhouseCoopers (PWC).
    • Operational Assignment: Deployment to the National Administrative Center in Tampa, Florida.
    • Objective: Align inputs from the Coopers & Lybrand Accounting Information System (AIS) and the Price Waterhouse AIS into the unified PWC global system designed for firm-wide financial reporting and cash forecasting.
    • Discrepancy Identified: Revenue-side inputs entering the global PWC system failed to match the revenue-side outputs generated by the system.
    • Audit Trail Functionality: An established end-to-end audit trail provided the necessary visibility to trace information inflows and outflows and pinpoint the exact stage where processing broke down.

Output Controls: Confidentiality, Integrity, and Availability

  • Scope of Output Controls
    • Address security and management surrounding information system outputs.
    • Confidentiality: Ensure that system output is accessible exclusively to authorized individuals.
    • Integrity: Provide assurance that output is truthful, accurate, complete, and uncorrupted.
    • Availability: Guarantee that output is readily accessible to authorized users when expected.

Hard Copy Output Controls and Print Spooling Security

  • Centralized Printing Architecture

    • Print Job Transmission: Sending a print command from a workstation or laptop transmits a signal across the network to a central print server situated in a data center.
    • Traffic Management Role: The print server operates as a traffic controller for inbound print requests sent to shared printers.
    • Direct Execution: When a single print request is received, the server routes it directly to the designated printer.
    • Spooling Process: When multiple print requests arrive concurrently, the server holds requests in memory and queues them based on submission sequence and priority.
  • Risks and Vulnerabilities of Print Spooling

    • Unauthorized File Deletion: An unauthorized user gaining access to spooled print files can delete queued print jobs, preventing physical report output.
    • Unauthorized Copies and Output Redirection:
    • Parameter Modification: On confidential reports restricted to specific limits (e.g., maximum limit of 22 printed copies), an unauthorized actor can modify spool parameters to print extra copies (e.g., 33 copies).
    • Network Redirection: Attackers can alter job settings to redirect an extra copy to an output file (out file) on the network, facilitating exfiltration via email or network access without needing to intercept physical printouts.
    • Value Tampering in Payroll Spool Files:
    • Organizations often maintain physical checkbooks for emergency overrides while utilizing dedicated, physically secured check printers for routine payroll execution.
    • Gaining unauthorized access to payroll spool files stored on the print server allows malicious actors to alter numerical values prior to printing (e.g., appending an extra zero to a check amount or doubling payment values).
    • Primary Print File Safeguards: Block unauthorized copy creation, prevent numerical value modifications, and prohibit unauthorized job deletion or destruction.

Waste Management and Physical Security Risks

  • Dumpster Diving and Document Security

    • Discarding sensitive hard-copy documents into regular trash or recycling bins routes them to unsecured outdoor dumpsters.
    • Dumpster Diving: Threat actors search through unsecured waste containers to collect confidential corporate paperwork.
  • Case Study: Remington Arms, Smith & Wesson, and Ruger (.44 Magnum.44\text{ Magnum})

    • Historical Context: In the 1950s1950\text{s}, Remington Arms Company collaborated with revolver manufacturer Smith & Wesson to introduce a high-power "super magnum" revolver cartridge: the .44 Magnum.44\text{ Magnum}.
    • Division of Labor: Smith & Wesson engineered the revolver to chamber and fire the new cartridge manufactured by Remington.
    • Confidentiality and Market Target: The joint initiative was kept strictly confidential to launch as the most powerful handgun cartridge on the market, maintaining that status until approximately the 1980s1980\text{s}.
    • Security Compromise: Developers at Remington improperly disposed of technical specification sheets into regular waste.
    • Competitor Exploitation: Bill Ruger, founder of an upstart firearms company reproducing classic Western single-action army revolvers (featured in John Wayne films), obtained the discarded detailed technical specifications.
    • Market Impact: While Remington and Smith & Wesson planned a simultaneous launch to secure complete first-mover advantage, Ruger utilized the leaked specifications to engineer a competing .44 Magnum.44\text{ Magnum} revolver and brought it to market within days of Smith & Wesson's release.
    • First-Mover Loss: Smith & Wesson lost its exclusive market monopoly on the hyped cartridge due to discarded paperwork.
    • Pop Culture Connection: The .44 Magnum.44\text{ Magnum} achieved widespread popularity through the 1970s1970\text{s} and 1980s1980\text{s} Dirty Harry movies starring Clint Eastwood, where character Dirty Harry carried a Model 2929 Smith & Wesson chambered in .44 Magnum.44\text{ Magnum} ("Go ahead, punk. Make my day."), making it one of the most popular revolver cartridges.
  • Internal Security: Janitorial Staff and Desk Security

    • Clear Desk Policy ("Police Your Desk"): Employees must clear all sensitive paperwork off desks and lock items in secure storage before leaving at the end of the day.
    • Janitorial Security Vulnerabilities:
    • Janitorial personnel possess unrestricted after-hours physical access across corporate facilities.
    • Workers carry master keys capable of unlocking all doors and offices.
    • Janitorial roles typically involve lower pay scales, lower hiring hurdles, and minimal background screening.
    • Corporate Espionage Exposure: Threat actors or competitors can obtain janitorial employment to inspect unattended desks and duplicate confidential documents overnight without detection.
    • Preventive Controls: Shred quasi-sensitive documents using affordable local shredders and enforce strict clear-desk compliance.

Report Distribution Controls: Physical vs. Digital Safeguards

  • Historical Physical Delivery Controls

    • Accounting Clerk Experience: Employment at the Department of Transportation, State of Florida in Tallahassee during the late 1980s1980\text{s} and early 1990s1990\text{s}.
    • Operational Routine: Navigating a 10-floor10\text{-floor} facility daily with a delivery cart containing sensitive reports (e.g., payroll registers).
    • Signature Control: In-person signature verification was mandatory prior to releasing any report. If the designated authorized recipient was absent, the report was withheld.
    • Physical Limitation: Once delivered, no physical mechanism prevented the authorized recipient from making unauthorized photocopies.
  • Modern Specialized Physical Delivery

    • Courier Delivery: Confidential paper reports remain in limited use for highly sensitive contexts (e.g., CFO office delivering private financial documents via courier to the Chair of the Faculty Senate Finance Committee at the University of Alabama at Birmingham [UAB]).
  • Modern Digital Output Security

    • Shift to Electronic Distribution: Replacement of physical printouts with electronic or PDF documents delivered directly into secure electronic mailboxes.
    • Technical File and Email DRM Controls:
    • Configuring security permissions on files to prevent attachment to outgoing emails.
    • Securing email settings to restrict messages and attachments from being printed.
    • Applying email security rules to block external or internal forwarding.