Business Communication: Credibility, Rhetorical Appeals, and Professional Ethics
Course Logistics, Classroom Expectations, and Policies
Academic Space Expectations:
- Students must maintain total focus while in the classroom environment and acknowledge that they are operating in an academic space.
- Personal communication (phone calls or text messages) must be handled by stepping outside the room and returning only when ready to re-enter the academic space.
- Social media usage (e.g., Facebook), playing games, or off-topic computer usage is strictly prohibited during class due to the distraction it causes to surrounding students.
Classroom Distraction Case Example:
- A student sitting near the back of the classroom kept his laptop open during class.
- Upon receiving a Facebook notification informing him that his grandmother had passed away, he became intensely upset in the middle of class, causing widespread emotional distress throughout the entire classroom.
- Maintaining professional boundaries protects the learning environment for everyone.
Student Roster and Attendance Verification:
- Sean
- Allie
- Ruby
- Elizabeth Brown and Macy Brown (sisters)
- Ryan
- Dorian
- Amaya
- CJ
- Uten
- Madison
- Olivia
- Maya
- Daniel
- Naomi
- David
- Angel
Course Deliverables and Badges:
- Welcome Email Reply: An initial exercise focused on establishing professional communication standards and confirming assignment protocols.
- Syllabus Quiz: Required syllabus comprehension evaluation.
- Self-Assessment: Required self-evaluative exercise.
- Module 1 Master Badge: Earned by successfully completing every required task and item contained within Module 1.
Questions and Class Discussion on Policies
Inquiry Regarding Citation and Document References:
- Question: What specific items need to be referenced or cited in submitted course documents?
- Response: Any external information, data, or secondary content incorporated into an assignment to support an argument must be formally cited and accompanied by a references section.
Inquiry Regarding Late Work and Submission Policies:
- Question: What is the policy regarding late assignments and resubmissions?
- Response: Late assignments are not accepted automatically. The formal standard penalty for tardiness is a deduction of per week. However, accepting late work requires a direct verbal conversation between the student and the instructor to create an explicit submission plan. If an assignment is submitted late without a prior conversation, it will be treated as unsubmitted.
Conceptual Foundations of Credibility and Trust
Definition of Credibility:
- Credibility is defined as the degree to which others believe in and trust an individual.
- It represents a person's overall reputation for trustworthiness and honesty.
Impact of Deception on Credibility:
- Deception or lying—even regarding minor or insignificant matters—permanently impairs how an individual is perceived.
- Once a person is caught in a lie, others develop a permanent cognitive bias assuming that the individual cannot be trusted.
- Straightforwardness and honesty in daily actions are essential for building a long-term professional reputation.
Benefits of High Credibility:
- Enables clearer, more persuasive communication because listeners believe the speaker's assertions.
- Forms the baseline for constructing high-trust relationships, which are critical in professional networking and business environments.
Trust in the Global Economy:
- Dr. Stephen Covey defined trust as the key leadership competency of the new global economy.
- Competency: An area of proficiency; being highly skilled or effective at something.
- Global Economy: An interconnected international marketplace where goods, services, and digital interactions are conducted across national borders (e.g., direct international purchases, global social media advertising) rather than solely within local, state, or regional markets.
- Risks in Unverified Global Commerce:
- An online order placed years prior resulted in the paid item never arriving, no refund being issued, and no customer service contact existing.
- An online purchase made through platforms such as Wish resulted in receiving an item that did not match the advertised product description or quality.
Minding the Business of Life
Context of Business Communication:
- Business communication takes place continuously within interpersonal and professional working relationships, including interactions with professors, supervisors, and co-workers.
Managing Personal Affairs as a Business:
- Individuals are actively responsible for managing the "business of life."
- Core components include securing housing, arranging reliable transportation, maintaining bank balances, paying recurring bills, and negotiating with utility companies, landlords, and banking institutions.
Boundaries of Personal Authority:
- Individuals are responsible for minding their own personal affairs and only the affairs of those over whom they possess direct legal or ethical authority (e.g., partners, dependent children, elderly parents, or dependent siblings).
- Interfering in the external business of others outside one's authority damages professional credibility.
The Three C's and Rhetorical Appeals
Communication and Personal Perception:
- The quality, accuracy, and honesty of communication directly influence how others judge an individual's intelligence, capability, and competence.
The Three C's of Credibility:
- Caring: Demonstrating genuine concern for oneself, the quality of the work produced, accuracy, and the needs of others.
- Competence: Demonstrating expertise, capability, skill, and deep subject knowledge in executing tasks.
- Character: Displaying strong moral values, ethics, integrity, and responsible conduct.
Aristotle's Rhetorical Framework:
- In his foundational texts on rhetoric, Aristotle established that effective persuasion depends directly on personal credibility.
- Persuasive messages require three core elements:
- Pathos (Appeal to Caring/Emotion): Engaging the audience's emotions, demonstrating empathy, and establishing a shared personal or human connection.
- Logos (Appeal to Competence/Logic): Demonstrating subject competence through structured, logical reasoning, evidence, clear organization, and step-by-step clarity.
- Ethos (Appeal to Character/Ethics): Establishing moral authority, ethical responsibility, and overall personal credibility.
Practical Applications of Pathos, Logos, and Ethos
Group 1 Analysis: American Red Cross CPR Video:
- Core Message: Learning CPR is vital because emergency skills can save lives at any moment.
- Demonstrated CPR Protocol:
- Assess responsiveness using the "shout-tap-shout" technique.
- Check for breathing, life-threatening bleeding, or other critical conditions.
- Assign a specific bystander to call 911 and retrieve an Automated External Defibrillator (AED) and first aid kit.
- Initiate compression-only CPR immediately if the victim is unresponsive and not breathing normally.
- Pathos (Caring): Appeals directly to emotion by reminding viewers of their capacity to save the life of a family member or stranger.
- Logos (Competence): Published by the American Red Cross, a premier nonprofit organization dedicated to public safety, training, and emergency relief.
- Ethos (Character): Intersects with competence; relies on the recognized organizational integrity and established ethical mission of the Red Cross.
Group 2 Analysis: Sid Meier Quote Evaluation:
- Analyzed Text: "I think that in life, as in game design, you have to find the fun. There is joy out there waiting to be discovered, but it might not be where you expect to be. You can't decide what something's going to be before you embark on it, and you shouldn't stick with a bad idea just because you're fond of it. Take action as quickly and repeatedly as possible. Take advantage of what you already know, and take liberties with tradition. But most important, take the time to appreciate the possibilities and make sure all of your decisions are interesting ones."
- Pathos (Caring): Frames life and professional efforts as a search for fun, joy, and emotional fulfillment.
- Logos (Competence): Advises utilizing established knowledge while abandoning flawed concepts quickly through rapid iteration.
- Ethos (Character): Demonstrated by Sid Meier's extensive record of successful game design and long-standing professional reputation.
Group 3 Analysis: High School Science Teacher Strawberry DNA Video:
- Pathos (Caring): Makes complex scientific concepts engaging and accessible for students.
- Logos (Competence): Demonstrates a step-by-step physical laboratory experiment extracting strawberry DNA.
- Ethos (Character): Supported by the instructor's explicit background, professional credentials, and teaching experience as a high school educator.
Group 4 Analysis: Acne Skincare Product Campaign:
- Pathos (Caring): Empathizes with the emotional distress and lowered self-esteem caused by chronic acne; offers a risk-free 30-day trial to demonstrate consumer care.
- Logos (Competence): Details exact product formulations, explaining chemical mechanisms and scientific rationale refined over years of development.
- Ethos (Character): Demonstrates ethical concern for customer emotional well-being and personal confidence.
Group 5 Analysis: Emergency Blanket Rescue Incident:
- Scenario: A young girl fell from the side of a building and was caught in a blanket held by bystanders below, resulting in only a broken wrist rather than fatal impact.
- Pathos (Caring): Bystanders took immediate action to protect human life.
- Logos (Competence): Efficiently utilized available environmental tools (a blanket) to manage kinetic impact forces.
- Ethos (Character): Displays altruism and moral courage under pressure.
Group 6 Analysis: Culinary Content Creator:
- Pathos (Caring): Conveys care and love through the cultural tradition of sharing recipes and food preparation.
- Logos (Competence): Delivers precise, step-by-step cooking instructions using accessible ingredients.
- Ethos (Character): Demonstrates authenticity and consistency in public communication.
Group 7 Analysis: Tootsie Roll Commercial (Tootsie Pop / Mr. Owl):
- Pathos (Caring): Uses an innocent, curious young boy to create an emotional connection with the audience.
- Logos (Competence): Displays sequential experimentation (inquiring across characters to determine exact numeric licks required).
- Ethos (Character): Backed by Tootsie Roll as an established, historically trusted brand.
Professional Credibility in Career Environments
Career Fair Logistics:
- Attendance is required during class hours for the campus Career Fair, which runs between 10:00 AM and 2:00 PM.
Demonstrating Professional Credibility to Employers:
- Professional Appearance: Maintain clean hair, clean face, clean hands, and clean attire. Adhere to business casual standards at minimum, or full professional attire for active job seekers.
- Verbal Communication: Speak respectfully, articulate ideas clearly, and utilize precise vocabulary to demonstrate intelligence.
- Non-Verbal Communication: Maintain upright posture, make direct eye contact, offer a proper handshake, smile, and exhibit enthusiasm.
- External Proof: Provide verifiable references and supervisor contact information from prior employment.
Academic Integrity, Plagiarism, and Legal Responsibilities
Definition of Plagiarism:
- According to the Oxford Dictionary, plagiarism is the practice of taking someone else's work or ideas and passing them off as one's own.
- It constitutes the theft of intellectual property.
Consequences of Plagiarism:
- Academic Setting: Assignment failure, course failure, formal institutional disciplinary action, or revocation of earned academic degrees.
- Professional Setting: Severe reputational ruin, termination of employment, and legal repercussions.
Public Cases of Plagiarism:
- Digital Media: A YouTube content creator copied the exact structure and content of another journalist's work without attribution, subsequently editing the material covertly when exposed.
- Public Figures: Melania Trump delivered a major political address that contained verbatim plagiarized passages from a prior speech by Michelle Obama.
- Academic Administration: The President of Harvard University resigned and was stripped of her doctoral standing after an investigation revealed plagiarism in her historical PhD dissertation written years prior.
- Media Piracy: The unauthorized burning and distribution of copyrighted CDs and movies.
Legal Responsibilities:
- Professionals maintain a strict legal and ethical duty to avoid plagiarism and libel (written defamation).
Standards for Citation, Paraphrasing, and Workplace Transparency
Core Strategies to Prevent Plagiarism:
- Mandatory Source Citation: Always attribute information sources to reinforce content legitimacy and give proper credit to original creators.
- Verbatim Quotations: Enclose exact wording in quotation marks, mention the author's name explicitly in the sentence, and include exact page or paragraph numbers for verification.
- Proper Paraphrasing: Express source information using entirely unique language, altered sentence structures, and original analytical perspectives. Paraphrasing proves subject mastery and comprehension.
Workplace Trust Quote (Robert Eckert):
- Robert Eckert, former CEO of Mattel, stated: "As you go to work, your top responsibility should be to build trust. Because without it, you're not going anywhere."
Citation Formatting Models:
- Parenthetical Citation Example: "In the workplace, developing trustworthiness among your colleagues is a must," stated Eckert (2020).
- In-Text Narrative Citation Example: When discussing credibility in the workplace, Robert Eckert, CEO of Mattel, stated, "Developing trustworthiness among your colleagues is a must."
Workplace Transparency Principles:
- Avoid hiding critical operational details or holding back information from colleagues and supervisors.
- Share decision-making processes and underlying data fully with stakeholders.
- Maintain open accessibility for questions and validate the concerns of others.
- Consistently fulfill stated commitments.
- Practical Commitments Axiom: Avoid making commitments that exceed operational capabilities ("don't make alligator promises your hummingbird ass can't cover").
- Execution Rule: Underpromise and overdeliver (e.g., promising project completion by tomorrow, but delivering results early that afternoon).
Course Motto and Continuous Improvement
Class Motto:
- "Good, better, best. Never let it rest until your good is better, and your better is best."
Application:
- Commitment to continuous daily improvement across all academic, personal, and professional activities.